- Thread starter
- #826
Call was made when he was on 30 odd goals last year.
Will tear the Sainters defence a new one tonight
Jack Riewoldt will be the AFL's best KPF in 2012
- Thread starter King Of The Hille
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Call was made when he was on 30 odd goals last year.
Will tear the Sainters defence a new one tonight
AFLOnline
Norm Smith Medallist
LOL what's this shit about Nick not being a great contested mark?
The fact that Fev disrupted the playing group, brought team morale down with antics on and off the field and is not playing in the vfl because no-one wanted him has to count in order to consider whether he's better than Jack. Footballers are more than just feet and legs, they're members of a team and a club and Carlton realised this before it was too late.
Jack works hard, helps his teammates out, is willing to work and move out of the 50 and doesn't seem like an absolute pillock. I can also see Riewoldt being able to work within a forward structure that's more than him, and IMO he can play more than just FF, he can be a CHF or third tall.
But this is academic, Fev isn't an afl footy player anymore and wont be ever more IMO.
Jack works hard, helps his teammates out, is willing to work and move out of the 50 and doesn't seem like an absolute pillock. I can also see Riewoldt being able to work within a forward structure that's more than him, and IMO he can play more than just FF, he can be a CHF or third tall.
But this is academic, Fev isn't an afl footy player anymore and wont be ever more IMO.
Fiora, Polo, Pattison.....Chin up, we have had our share of hacks
- Thread starter
- #830
Bump this up. I made this in 2010, stating he'd be the best in 2012.
It's now 2013, after winning last years Coleman was my call justified? Is he currently the best key forward in the game. I'd take him ahead of Cloke and it'd be very tough with Franklin.
Thoughts?
It's now 2013, after winning last years Coleman was my call justified? Is he currently the best key forward in the game. I'd take him ahead of Cloke and it'd be very tough with Franklin.
Thoughts?
Still not even the best riewoldt.
Zach Package
Prespakis2Tsatas
I'd have him behind Kennedy, Franklin, Saint Nick, Cloke, and Jeremy Cameron considering their comparable output and Cameron getting bugger all supply and having only played 30 odd games.
Edit: I'd have him behind a fit Tex Walker as well
- Thread starter
- #834
I'd have him easilly ahead of Kennedy and Cameron and marginally ahead of his cousin and Cloke.
Saint Nick will always be a champion, but he isn't that prolific goalkicker that Jack is.
I you were looking purely for a full forward to kick you goals in a Premiership year, who would you target?
- Oct 2, 2008
- 9,089
- 19,339
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Brothers of Destruction
BETTER THAN - Cameron, Kennedy
ON PAR - Nick Riewoldt 2013, Cloke, Roughhead.
NOT BETTER THAN - Franklin.
Reasonable call and justified as well.end thread.
It's all well and good to have an opinion but it doesn't make it particularly factual.
You'd be in the minority to take him ahead of Kennedy and Cameron.
- Thread starter
- #839
Thread title stating, Riewoldt will be the best KPF in 2012. It's 2013.
You can't honestly tell me Cameron and Kennedy are better than him?
I'd take Jeremy Cameron ahead of Jack Riewoldt.
lol... Is your post based on potential or stats?
2 x Coleman medal winner - might have a third by the end of the year.
Backs it up by being one of the top players in the league for assists.
Makes me laugh how you put Walker ahead of him but not Pav because pav has missed half the season.
- Banned
- #842
No he is not the best KPF in the game.
- Banned
- #843
Kennedy is, he offers more than just goal kicking. Kennedy is brilliant defensively and also works harder to contest the ball further from goal.
Jack may be more naturally talented but I would rather Kennedy.
Both Cloke and Reiwoldt are far better players when in form.
BF Logic: Jack Riewoldt is not the best KPF in the league, he just happens to kick the most goals.
lol... Is your post based on potential or stats?
2 x Coleman medal winner - might have a third by the end of the year.
Backs it up by being one of the top players in the league for assists.
Makes me laugh how you put Walker ahead of him but not Pav because pav has missed half the season.
Pav is past his prime which would have likely showed this year. Feel free to start a poll with Walker or Riewoldt as the preferred options. I don't think it will go well for you
A KPF is more than just goals.
Kicking the most goals makes you the best KPF in the league? Lloyd>>>Carey
Zach Package
Prespakis2Tsatas
Key forward is more than just goals, just as the best midfielder isn't the one that get's the most touches.
- Banned
- #850
Especially in the modern game, there is far more to be the best KPF than kicking the most goals, especially when it is only by a negligible amount.
Similar threads
