This thread is pathetic.
if you wanna judge a player by their debut game, then lets take a look -
Lance Franklin is a hack.
Nick Riewoldt is a spud.
Adam Cooney is rubbish.
Justin Koschitze is woeful.
Gary Ablett Jnr is laughable.
Andrew Walker is a god.
Dean Polo is a freak.
Brad Dalziell walks on water.
Mark McGough is a hall of famer.
I suspect this is and will forever be your best post.