Traded Jesse Hogan [traded with #65 to Fremantle for #6 and #23]

[Better Loosen Up]

Thank you, finally someone who sees it as it is. It’s all Freo can offer right now as it’s all we have. Can’t trade picks we don’t hve.

Anyone here bought a car? Do you waln in and offer your best straight away? Geez

The car analogy is probably a little off the mark. At the moment, you guys are more like the T-shirt salesman in Thailand

 

[Suma Magic]

Sounds like Peter Bell is trying to win the trade period.

 

[Coach_Required]

They way Freo are going they will have burned Hogan and will refuse to go there.

You guys just need to hold on for 12 months, free up some cap, maybe trade a few picks and possibly a swap with young Brander to Melbourne and you have your ready made Kennedy replacement.

 

[nurries]

Oh boy. Classic.

obsessed much

 

[Mr Magic]

Yeah nah. Players can't be juggled like that. Only picks can.

They can as part of a multi-deal.

So players cannot be on-traded but GCS can do the bidding on before of Melbourne to push through a multi deal so ultimately Freo or West coast can cough up the desired compo to allow the full deal to emerge and players go where they want to go without other clubs restricting trade options through narrow bilateral set-ups.


For example, Melbourne agree theoretically on the currency between May and Hogan, Melbourne have the extra pick(s) in limbo quarantined, then GCS needs to offload Hogan to West Coast or Freo via Adelaide/Port and other deals as part of a multi deal. Melbourne can assist knowledge wise with GCS in this task because if Melbourne can't off load Hogan, GCS can't offload May.This can be down in the cloud on a spreadsheet, Once the full agreement is reached between all clubs they can convene and sign-off.

The point is this set-up promotes clarity and brings more options to the table in a multi-deal

 

[Freoforever86]

The car analogy is probably a little off the mark. At the moment, you guys are more like the T-shirt salesman in Thailand

You want transport?

 

[Johnny Karate]

If we've seriously only offered 11 and a future second we're on crack.

It’s all the Dockers have to offer at this stage. I expect a deal will still get done, post Neale. That said, it’s not a great look for Freo that the media have got hold of it.
There’s irony that Sam McClure is carrying on though. He’s been pretty relentless in opining that Hogan is only worth one first rounder. Earlier today he stated that all he would offer for Hogan is pick 11.

 

[Duskfire]

I dont think they are eager, just know that Hogan returning to WA is inevitable.

If it’s inevitable then why shouldn’t Freo play hardball then?

 

[purpleman]

The West is reporting that this is only an initial offer and that both clubs are happy to negotiate.

"However the two clubs are openly discussing a deal for him. The news of the Demons rejecting the offer was reported by multiple outlets on Thursday afternoon"

Move on..

 

[Coach_Required]

If it’s inevitable then why shouldn’t Freo play hardball then?

because they also risk another Western Australian club getting involved in 12 months time. I know which club id prefer to play the rest of my career out with.

 

[Mr Magic]

If it’s inevitable then why shouldn’t Freo play hardball then?

Because nothing is inevitable

 

[Rion]

Just a (terrible) starting offer. I'm sure it'll eventually end up as something like two picks in the 8-11 range which will suit both parties.

 

[Duskfire]

because they also risk of another Western Australian club getting involved in 12 months time. I know which club id prefer to play the rest of my career out with.

While that is true, Eagles also have a lot less to work with unless they seriously turn to shit next season. They also don’t have any high value players hitting free agency either; Gaff was pretty much that. Eagles being able to get the picks to satisfy Melb seems unlikely.

 

[freofc1994]

because they also risk of another Western Australian club getting involved in 12 months time. I know which club id prefer to play the rest of my career out with.

Gold Coast?

 

[CWaffles]

Thank you, finally someone who sees it as it is. It’s all Freo can offer right now as it’s all we have. Can’t trade picks we don’t hve.

Anyone here bought a car? Do you waln in and offer your best straight away? Geez

No, but I dont waltz into a ferrari dealership offering a Camry for trade in along with $15,000 either

 

[nurries]

The West is reporting that this is only an initial offer and that both clubs are happy to negotiate.

"However the two clubs are openly discussing a deal for him. The news of the Demons rejecting the offer was reported by multiple outlets on Thursday afternoon"

Move on..

are you telling me that's not worth twenty shekels ?... You're supposed to argue, 'Ten for that? You must be mad

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Oh boy. Classic.

It's been an entertaining afternoon. Your supporters love to give, some absolute brainlets on the line.

 

[Jibroni]

It’s all the Dockers have to offer at this stage. I expect a deal will still get done, post Neale. That said, it’s not a great look for Freo that the media have got hold of it.
There’s irony that Sam McClure is carrying on though. He’s been pretty relentless in opining that Hogan is only worth one first rounder. Earlier today he stated that all he would offer for Hogan is pick 11.

Same guy who thought only Hawthorn could beat Richmond and many other useless observations. Ignore him.

 

[freofc1994]

No, but I dont waltz into a ferrari dealership offering a Camry for trade in along with $15,000 either

You'd get it for that, just have about $2000/week on finance over 7 years. Its a reasonable offer though.

 

[Max zero]

20 + 22 + 2019 1st rounder (15-18).

Pawnshop: best I can do.

Will make Freo honest at least.

 

[LeverPuller]

The West is reporting that this is only an initial offer and that both clubs are happy to negotiate.

"However the two clubs are openly discussing a deal for him. The news of the Demons rejecting the offer was reported by multiple outlets on Thursday afternoon"

Move on..

Nope.

Jay Clark has been immaculate on Melbourne for about 5 years now, he wouldn’t put that ‘prepared to deal with West Coast’ line if his source hadn’t said it.

 

[Freoforever86]

No, but I dont waltz into a ferrari dealership offering a Camry for trade in along with $15,000 either

Little off base though. Not like we offered 23 & 30.

Half the trade is right. Just need a pick for the other half

 

[Ge3ks]

obsessed much

Strewth. Ya not wrong. He needs to get a job. Too bad trolling doesn't pay the bills.

No, but I dont waltz into a ferrari dealership offering a Camry for trade in along with $15,000 either

What if it's a used Ferrari with a rusty bent chasis? Haha.

 

[LeverPuller]

Little off base though. Not like we offered 23 & 30.

Half the trade is right. Just need a pick for the other half

Yup. Pick 5.

 

[Freoforever86]

Yup. Pick 5.

Pretty much.