Recommitted Joe Daniher 2019 [requested a trade to Sydney - didn't get there]

[perplexed]

I expect it'll get done, just pointing out if it doesn't, its not about Essendon 'holding him to his contract', Daniher has an obligation until he doesn't.

So does Essendon. Even if they don't think that way.

 

[Rich01]

5 straight swap is my guess. Doesn’t make sense for Sydney to offer more.

Hmmm....
If they give 5 for Joe and accept 8 for Papley that’s good business.

Not sure if Dodoro will allow it though.

 

[rumply]

It appears I did so.

& still reads as silly the second time around

 

[rumply]

Hmmm....
If they give 5 for Joe and accept 8 for Papley that’s good business.

Not sure if Dodoro will allow it though.

Put the pipe down.

 

[The King!]

pick 5 would be ok, bloody generous from us

 

[Rich01]

Put the pipe down.

Joes had one good year followed by two injury ravaged ones.
Prestia was pick 6. Carlisle pick 5. Pick 5 is a decent return for an underwhelming talent.

 

[HurleyHepsHird]

Dodo is going to make this as painful as possible.

Lets see which wins, the Bombers getting decent compensation or Dodos ego and Daniher leaving next year as an RFA?

 

[Yoda_]

Just like to point out that if Joe stays at Essendon in 202 and the Swans do come calling for his services again, we have every right to match the offer in front of Sydney.

With such a bulging salary cap, it likely won’t be a godfather deal we couldn’t afford and as such would need to have a trade sorted to satisfy us or enter the draft.

Take it or leave it but we will get fairly compensated as even though I don’t like the bloke, Adrian Dodoro is the master negotiator.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Suma Magic]

Hmmm....
If they give 5 for Joe and accept 8 for Papley that’s good business.

Not sure if Dodoro will allow it though.

I think best case scenario next year is pick 10. If I was a swans fan I’d be pissed if they gave up more than pick 5.

 

[tombomb]

Just like to point out that if Joe stays at Essendon in 202 and the Swans do come calling for his services again, we have every right to match the offer in front of Sydney.

With such a bulging salary cap, it likely won’t be a godfather deal we couldn’t afford and as such would need to have a trade sorted to satisfy us or enter the draft.

Take it or leave it but we will get fairly compensated as even though I don’t like the bloke, Adrian Dodoro is the master negotiator.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

unlike others I don't proclaim to know the state of our salary cap.

But it would be seriously odd if it was 'bulging'.

 

[carnthedons]

Hmmm....
If they give 5 for Joe and accept 8 for Papley that’s good business.

Not sure if Dodoro will allow it though.

He won’t and Sydney have got Joe to nominate them, he wouldn’t do that without an undertaking they’ll do “whatever it takes” to make it happen.

Trade will happen, it’ll burn for an extended period, swans fans will think they overpaid until they see him dominating, bombers fans will bleed because we know our recruiters will pick vanilla types or flankers they try and turn into mids, we’ll go another 15 years without sniffing success and the world will keep turning.

 

[Mikka84]

Joes had one good year followed by two injury ravaged ones.
Prestia was pick 6. Carlisle pick 5. Pick 5 is a decent return for an underwhelming talent.

With pick 14 coming back, that ended up being Gresham. The fantasy that it was pick 5 alone for Carlisle still continues.

 

[Linda Lovelace]

Just like to point out that if Joe stays at Essendon in 202 and the Swans do come calling for his services again, we have every right to match the offer in front of Sydney.

With such a bulging salary cap, it likely won’t be a godfather deal we couldn’t afford and as such would need to have a trade sorted to satisfy us or enter the draft.

Take it or leave it but we will get fairly compensated as even though I don’t like the bloke, Adrian Dodoro is the master negotiator.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

One thing I will give Dodoro - he's managed to oversee Essendon's list management for nearly two decades of dismal failure (he had essentially nothing to do with 2000) and not only miraculously keep his job, but even get people on the internet to call him a 'master.

That is some dark magic.

 

[HurleyHepsHird]

Just like to point out that if Joe stays at Essendon in 202 and the Swans do come calling for his services again, we have every right to match the offer in front of Sydney.

With such a bulging salary cap, it likely won’t be a godfather deal we couldn’t afford and as such would need to have a trade sorted to satisfy us or enter the draft.

Take it or leave it but we will get fairly compensated as even though I don’t like the bloke, Adrian Dodoro is the master negotiator.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Sure.

But can Dodo keep his job? Squeezing a poor year out of Daniher, then matching, then forcing a trade. That's a big gamble for a club figure skating on name recognition.

 

[boncer34]

With pick 14 coming back, that ended up being Gresham. The fantasy that it was pick 5 alone for Carlisle still continues.

It was from us.

 

[HurleyHepsHird]

One thing I will give Dodoro - he's managed to oversee Essendon's list management for nearly two decades of dismal failure (he had essentially nothing to do with 2000) and not only miraculously keep his job, but even get people on the internet to call him a 'master.

That is some dark magic.

It's the Trump effect.

If you talk shit enough, have enough influence and just a titanic ego, you can be hard to shake.

 

[Messenger]

I would have thought the Ellis compo decision today should give Essendon pause if they want him to fulfil his contract in 2020. Especially given Ellis has been, well, playing football and Daniher has not.

 

[Mikka84]

It was from us.

Who else would it be from

 

[Messenger]

One thing I will give Dodoro - he's managed to oversee Essendon's list management for nearly two decades of dismal failure (he had essentially nothing to do with 2000) and not only miraculously keep his job, but even get people on the internet to call him a 'master.

That is some dark magic.

Apparently he’s the best.

 

[boncer34]

Who else would it be from

We didn't give you pick 14.

 

[HurleyHepsHird]

It was from us.

Yet they still got Gresham.

But cherry picking trades is really a stretch, his run has to be looked at in totality. One that hasn't been productive.

 

[boncer34]

Yet they still got Gresham.

But cherry picking trades is really a stretch, his run has to be looked at in totality. One that hasn't been productive.

I don't rate Dodoro at all.

 

[perplexed]

Just like to point out that if Joe stays at Essendon in 202 and the Swans do come calling for his services again, we have every right to match the offer in front of Sydney.

With such a bulging salary cap, it likely won’t be a godfather deal we couldn’t afford and as such would need to have a trade sorted to satisfy us or enter the draft.

Take it or leave it but we will get fairly compensated as even though I don’t like the bloke, Adrian Dodoro is the master negotiator.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Coz that would show Joe (and his teammates) what happens when you want to leave.

 

[BEEG]

Daniher + a future 2nd for 5 + 9

Yeah if he was consistently playing the past 2 years the bloke has become a talented liability

1st and 2nd about right

 

[HurleyHepsHird]

Apparently he’s the best.

It's such a toxic circle jerk between him and the Essendon media coterie. They talk him up, he does his thing, which allows the media to talk the team up, which puts pressure on the coaches and players.

But they can't reevaluate. Admitting they were wrong, means recognising the list is no good, which means accepting Dodo is a spud farmer.

Which clubs are historically easy to deal with? WC and Hawthorn. It's been a fairly successful formula.