Recommitted Joe Daniher 2019 [requested a trade to Sydney - didn't get there]

[TiAn_]

Nice to see him following in his father’s foot steps. Bombers supporters can’t begrudge him that.

 

[Foxx]

If Papley is worth pick 9, then surely Joe is worth 5 and 9.

 

[Giant Pete]

Yep. We saw in the Grand Final that GWS's forward line is not the problem. They need midfielders who actually are willing to do the hard stuff and not a lot of silky downhill skiiers.

You mean like they did in the 3 other finals they played?

 

[Mikka84]

We didn't give you pick 14.

You received it from Sydney for Bird and picks 23. So yes, it came from you. Unless you think Bird was worth a pick upgrade from a second round to first round. If that’s the case, may god have mercy on your soul.

 

[Off Tap]

If Papley is worth pick 9, then surely Joe is worth 5 and 9.

Surely if you can't get on the field he's not.

Essendon and Swans supporters aside, what's he actually worth as a trade?

 

[Giant Pete]

No.

And don't give the 3 firsts to us. Send em to GWS. We'll take Cameron.

He won’t want to play for you.

 

[Tippett2Goal]

Carlton Receive: Tom Papley
Essendon Receive: Pick 5,9 and Ben Ronke
Sydney Receive: Joe Daniher, Lewis Taylor, Riley Knight, Future Second Rounder(Ess) and Future Third Rounder(BL)
Adelaide Receive: Pick 51(Ess)
Brisbane Receive: Pick 37(Ess)

Just get in from a big night drinking?

 

[Bollox]

Hmmmmm
We're a tad desperate for key defenders to give Rampe a break.
Reid had a terrific season, he could even play outside midfield next year.

Buddy, Reid, Daniher, TheGoodMcCartin, Blakey.
The ground looks a little lop sided. Sheeeezus

I hope Bud can play fullback

 

[Mikevk123]

Carlton Receive: Tom Papley
Sydney Receive: Joe Daniher, Riley Knight, Lewis Taylor, Future Second(Ess)
Essendon Receive: Ronke, 5 and 9
Brisbane Receive: Pick 37(Ess)
Adelaide Receive: Pick 54(BL)

Carlton
Gain: Papley
Lose: Pick 9

Sydney
Gain: Daniher,Taylor,Knight and Future Second.
Lose: Papley, Ronke and 5

Essendon
Gain: Ronke, 5 and 9
Lose: Daniher, 37 and Future Second

Adelaide
Gain: Pick 54(BL)
Lose: Riley Knight

Brisbane
Gain: Pick 37(Ess)
Lose: Taylor and Pick 54

 

[Gavin Excell]

Surely if you can't get on the field he's not.

Essendon and Swans supporters aside, what's he actually worth as a trade?

It’s a tough one as in Essendons favour he is a KPP that are rarely on the table but countering that is his injury record

A first rounder you’d think - particularly as high as 5 - is sufficient I would have thought

Thing is he is under contract. Essendon aren’t forced to deal if offer isn’t right. Look at Tim Kelly last year. Requested a trade - eagles and Geelong couldn’t agree and he remained at Geelong and played good football. Delaying the inevitable though

 

[Gavin Excell]

Carlton Receive: Tom Papley
Sydney Receive: Joe Daniher, Riley Knight, Lewis Taylor, Future Second(Ess)
Essendon Receive: Ronke, 5 and 9
Brisbane Receive: Pick 37(Ess)
Adelaide Receive: Pick 54(BL)

Carlton
Gain: Papley
Lose: Pick 9

Sydney
Gain: Daniher,Taylor,Knight and Future Second.
Lose: Papley, Ronke and 5

Essendon
Gain: Ronke, 5 and 9
Lose: Daniher, 37 and Future Second

Adelaide
Gain: Pick 54(BL)
Lose: Riley Knight

Brisbane
Gain: Pick 37(Ess)
Lose: Taylor and Pick 54

Adel be thrilled with that deal

 

[iBeng]

Surely Sam Reid looks elsewhere if this happens? Who would want him?

 

[Gavin Excell]

Hmmmmm
We're a tad desperate for key defenders to give Rampe a break.
Reid had a terrific season, he could even play outside midfield next year.

Buddy, Reid, Daniher, TheGoodMcCartin, Blakey.
The ground looks a little lop sided. Sheeeezus

I hope Bud can play fullback

Indeed

Wonder if this is tacit acknowledgment of Buds career at an end

 

[Bollox]

Indeed

Wonder if this is tacit acknowledgment of Buds career at an end

You can almost guarantee that will be the first cheap media story.

" Swans move on Daniher signs Buddy's death warrant"

 

[Mikevk123]

Essendon Receive: Pick 5, Sam Reid and Ben Ronke
Sydney Receive: Joe Daniher, Michael Hartley and Future Second Round Pick

 

[Foreign Legion]

Swans will have to back end him a la Buddy
Say 300k a year for 2 years then 1 mil a year the next 3

We have just lost $1.2M - $1.6M/year through retirements.

 

[zeggie]

Didn't Anthony say at the Past Players Function that Joe was going nowhere and would be at Essendon in 2020?

 

[carnthedons]

You received it from Sydney for Bird and picks 23. So yes, it came from you. Unless you think Bird was worth a pick upgrade from a second round to first round. If that’s the case, may god have mercy on your soul.

Nah we never had 14 was a 3 way trade.

We had Carlisle and 44 out for 5 and Bird. Also went from 23 to 24.

Sydney had 14 and Bird out for 23 and 44 (academy points)

St Kilda had Carlisle and 14 in for 5 and 24.

Here’s the AFL website if you don’t believe me.

Carlisle becomes a Saint, Dons get another top pick, Bird leaves Swans

Dons land prized pick in return for big man, with Swans also involved

m.afl.com.au

 

[boncer34]

You received it from Sydney for Bird and picks 23. So yes, it came from you. Unless you think Bird was worth a pick upgrade from a second round to first round. If that’s the case, may god have mercy on your soul.

We never had pick 14.

And they gave us Bird. So you're suggesting Sydney traded Bird + 14 for 23?

 

[Wayne Swan]

Didn't Anthony say at the Past Players Function that Joe was going nowhere and would be at Essendon in 2020?

Correct, he knew then that Dododoro won't be able to get a fair deal done for his injured son so Joe will be at Essendon in 2020, probably not playing but will be at Essendon.

 

[Mikka84]

We never had pick 14.

May god have mercy on your soul

 

[Mikka84]

Nah we never had 14 was a 3 way trade.

We had Carlisle and 44 out for 5 and Bird. Also went from 23 to 24.

Sydney had 14 and Bird out for 23 and 44 (academy points)

St Kilda had Carlisle and 14 in for 5 and 24.

Here’s the AFL website if you don’t believe me.

Carlisle becomes a Saint, Dons get another top pick, Bird leaves Swans

Dons land prized pick in return for big man, with Swans also involved

m.afl.com.au

Yeah that’s what I said.. received it from Sydney in a 3-way. The theory that we gave pick 5 for Carlisle in a straight swap as always quoted, is false.

 

[boncer34]

Yeah that’s what I said.. received it from Sydney in a 3-way. The theory that we gave pick 5 for Carlisle in a straight swap as always quoted, is false.

You received it from Sydney.

We never had pick 14.

Unless you're saying Sydney gave us 14 + Bird for 23?

 

[Edmund hunt]

Carlton Receive: Tom Papley
Sydney Receive: Joe Daniher, Riley Knight, Lewis Taylor, Future Second(Ess)
Essendon Receive: Ronke, 5 and 9
Brisbane Receive: Pick 37(Ess)
Adelaide Receive: Pick 54(BL)

Carlton
Gain: Papley
Lose: Pick 9

Sydney
Gain: Daniher,Taylor,Knight and Future Second.
Lose: Papley, Ronke and 5

Essendon
Gain: Ronke, 5 and 9
Lose: Daniher, 37 and Future Second

Adelaide
Gain: Pick 54(BL)
Lose: Riley Knight

Brisbane
Gain: Pick 37(Ess)
Lose: Taylor and Pick 54

Why would Sydney want 3 forwards?

 

[FreeAgent1]

I reckon that most sydney fans are scared right now.

Yep because we are going to have to wait all week as Dodo demands Carlton’s first and 5.

As we aren’t trading Papley he will wait till last hour to confirm before agreeing to trade and the 45 subsequent deals will need to be don’t in the last hour.