-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Joel Selwood
- Thread starter The Panther
- Start date
- Tagged users None
He already is.
In that top 10 mids of the comp thread i had him at number 2 on my list. I have seen nothing from him which makes me think i was incorrect.
1. Ablett
2. Hayes
3. Montagna
4. Judd
5. Swan
6. Dal Santo
7. Selwood
After this round Selwood and Swan will probably move up.
rizzo
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 11, 2003
- 14,342
- 1,037
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Everton, Melbourne Heart, Raptors
I assume this list is based on current form? If not Judd/Selwood and NDS >>>>>>> Montagna imho.
Yes of course it is. Otherwise I'd have players like Goodes, Bartel and Black in it.
- Apr 3, 2006
- 34,627
- 13,373
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Hey Warchild, tell me where Thomas fits in?
STC
Norm Smith Medallist
Considering Selwood gets the number 1 tag every other week (he got Sewell yesterday), it's laughable to suggest he's anything like Kerr.
Selwood is an elite midfielder, no question about it.
Selwood is an elite midfielder, no question about it.
Selwood was absolutely bloody magnificent yesterday. Geelong had no right to get up and snatch that thing, but it was the will of Selwood, and then a few others that saw him leading from the front when the chips were down, that got them over the line.
That was as great a game by a single individual as I have seen for a decade. (Basically since Carey used to do the same for North on a regular basis).
That was as great a game by a single individual as I have seen for a decade. (Basically since Carey used to do the same for North on a regular basis).
Boy, imagine if the Hawks ha have taken him with pick 6
Of all your insults and blatant trolls....
That one hurts the most.
Brilliant player.
He is a bloody freak player!
He will come close to winning the Brownlow this year and he will make the AA team.
He will also dominate games for years and years.
The Kerr comparisons are an absolute joke, he has proven himself time and time again and hes only in his 3rd year of AFL.
He will come close to winning the Brownlow this year and he will make the AA team.
He will also dominate games for years and years.
The Kerr comparisons are an absolute joke, he has proven himself time and time again and hes only in his 3rd year of AFL.
STC
Norm Smith Medallist
He really is the complete footballer as far as midfielders go, pace being the only thing he doesn't really have.
Rohan Connolly gave Selwood 10 votes for his effort yesterday - the maximum amount of votes possible. I'm not sure if anyone has ever gotten 10 before, 9 is usually the most they give out to a star.
The Truth
Senior List
Rohan Connolly? Really? WOW.
Leigh Matthews & James Hird rated Hodge the best in the GF, yet Cat fans thought they were wrong. What would those 2 past players know.
Rohan Connolly gives Selwood a 10 and suddenly he's the expert
Gotta love Cat fans... they sure are battlers
STC
Norm Smith Medallist
What does any of that have to do with anything? Rohan Connolly has been a football analyst for many years and has watched a shitload of football. His credentials are only somewhat relevant, because his opinion that Selwood played a bloody awesome game is hardly one that isn't widely held.Rohan Connolly? Really? WOW.
Leigh Matthews & James Hird rated Hodge the best in the GF, yet Cat fans thought they were wrong. What would those 2 past players know.
Rohan Connolly gives Selwood a 10 and suddenly he's the expert
Gotta love Cat fans... they sure are battlers
What are you actually trying to say with your post? It seems to have nothing to do with Joel Selwood or his performance.
The Truth
Senior List
If Rohan came out and bagged Selwood about his continual playing for frees and favourtism by the umps, he'd be nothing but a hack journalist.
Caro will write a positive piece soon and then she'll be the no.1 journalist again
Cats fans. The gift that keeps on giving
Rohan Connolly? Really? WOW.
Leigh Matthews & James Hird rated Hodge the best in the GF, yet Cat fans thought they were wrong. What would those 2 past players know.
Rohan Connolly gives Selwood a 10 and suddenly he's the expert
Gotta love Cat fans... they sure are battlers
Yep, I thought that then and I think that now. In my opinion Ablett was clearly best on ground. If you wanted to choose a Hawthorn player as they won - Sewell would have been my choice. Norm Smith medals often go to the best story as opposed to the best player. Steve Johnson the year before was very similar - Scarlett or Chapman were just as good.
Daring to disagree with an ex-player doesn't make you an idiot.
And I don't care what any journalist says about Geelong, it's irrelevant.
- Banned
- #145
How do you explain Andrew Embley winning the Norm Smith?
Mate, its about what happens on the day.
Clinton Young was ahead of Hodge in the Norm Smith before he got injured.
If he had won, all hell would of broken lose!
Back on topic. Im glad to be humiliated by a guy like Joel Selwood. His debut season made my mind up that he is one of a kind!
