-
Please read this post on the rules on BigFooty regarding posting copyright material, including fair dealing rules. Repeat infringements could see your account limited or closed.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Kyabram DFL 2017
- Thread starter smooth mover
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Last edited:
phantom man
Team Captain
Believe rushworth player will front the tribunal tommorow night.
Doona2
Cancelled
Not about Finals
and will be affecting the league itself
New Clubs into KDFL or clubs looking to opt out?
Doc Larkins
All Australian
- Nov 30, 2016
- 857
- 564
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
Could be about the Ardmona Cats future.
That's the rumour and it is terrible to see regardless of whether you like or dislike a club.
jobbytonny
Team Captain
- Sep 20, 2006
- 436
- 481
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Anyone else heard there might be more then 1 club gone next year
to another league ?
jobbytonny
Team Captain
- Sep 20, 2006
- 436
- 481
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Not sure Roar , did hear that it was going to be more then one team gone from the Kdfnl next year , unsure if they are folding or going to another league.
- Jan 9, 2013
- 2,191
- 3,126
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
They have just been hanging on roar Went there Saturday hoping to see some positives but was disappointed in what I saw got there just when a Lancaster 3rds player was headlock by an ardy spectator It was just disappointing to see just a couple of ardy die hards running the whole show it was just a mess They can't continue they need 25 to 30 players they have little coin sponsors and helpers I'm not being negative just a realist
phantom man
Team Captain
It's is a sad situation but cannot see Ardmona surviving "they haven't been
spot on swoop sadly cannot see them surviving , I know poor old sharpy is trying hard to keep them going ,but I think the end is near "they haven't been competitive in reserves at all ,they have no support,no money no players that could possibly get them up to senior level again next year .credit to the handful of people who have tried. To keep the club afloat.
The workload becomes too much so people start droppping off, which increases the workload on those left.
The increasing in staffing needs to be at club level not the AFL Melbourne head office , whilst the work load at club level needs to be reduced not increased as is continually happening.
phantom man
Team Captain
Hearing from the hub that rushworth player Martyn Forde had been suspended for 15 years, tonight at the tribunal at 26 years of age that makes him 41 when he is eligible to play again.
Why 15 years ?
Life is 16 weeks , just adds more negative drama to the sport.
Another appeal for Findlay coming up.
There is a bit more to it than just appeal and get re-instated. The panel also consider the charge history and what they have done to rehabilitate.
The league they go to also has the right to reject them.
Post padding
Premiership Player
But that's somewhat my point Roota.
Bloke gets king hit and breaks his jaw.
Didn't see it coming so no chance to defend himself.
Gets taken to hospital most likely with concussion.
Has jaw wired , misses work,
Eats through a straw for 5 weeks .
10-12 weeks out of playing footy and high chance of brain injury through the concussion which can have long term effects.
Headaches for 2-3 weeks .
charged player gets - 6-8 weeks
Umpire touches someone , no case to answer and they'll refuse to umpire if anyone tries to investigate it.
Player touches a umpire , game is called off and player gets 15 years.
I don't condone any of it , but the penalty seems way out of proportion.
IIRC Greg Williams got 12 .
Last edited:
phantom man
Team Captain
well done to the kdfl tribunal for their outcome on the s
well to the kdfl tribunal for making a stand on their descion
well done to the kdfl tribunal on the sentence handed out to the rushworth player' no one likes to see theses actions on the field.
umpires should never be touched. no matter what. 15 year penalty will give him plenty of time to reflect on his actions.
what i dont understand,is how two players in the picola football league get red carded and reported and the umpires there
bungle the report,and both players get let off.even though the katandra coach sam ahmet ends up with a broken jaw.
also roar could please explain a couple of weeks ago .im hearing a thirds umpire was pushed and the thirds player was
given a 6 week suspended sentence. and played the next week.whats the differance between the two incidents . reckon
15 years good result by the kdfl
If you are referring to Saturday's match involving Sam , I think you'll find that clubs have 5 days to seek an investigation if they believe a incident warrants an investigation , so you might be putting the cart before the horse .
Please explain where the consistency is in.
king hit ,broken jaw 6 weeks
Umpire touches a player ( no action / untouchable )
Player touches a umpire 15 years.
Last edited:
phantom man
Team Captain
So he got 14 years and 6 matches more than Greg Williams for abusing the umpire and because, the umpire fell over as a result of the push?
It would appear not uncommon elsewhere including the AFL for umpire abuse to be 2 weeks and contact forcing the umpire to fall over to be 2-4 weeks.
If what was described in the shepp news is correct what the hell was the umpire doing approaching the player ?
Oh and I have never sat on a tribunal far less chaired one.
But please do tell the whole story.
Was it from a report, is a party filthy on the outcome ?
It would appear not uncommon elsewhere including the AFL for umpire abuse to be 2 weeks and contact forcing the umpire to fall over to be 2-4 weeks.
If what was described in the shepp news is correct what the hell was the umpire doing approaching the player ?
Oh and I have never sat on a tribunal far less chaired one.
But please do tell the whole story.
Was it from a report, is a party filthy on the outcome ?
Last edited:
- Status
