-
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mark Sheehan's Top 50
- Thread starter happy_eagle
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #52
worst top 50 that he's ever done.
Ender Wiggen
Rookie
- Sep 22, 2000
- 62,351
- 41,703
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Ford
- Banned
- #56
Jed Adcock = Rorted.
Ender Wiggen
Rookie
First page - 14th post.
He was actually beaten a few times this year.
- Banned
- #60
No way guess what I found. The whole list isn't just Geelong!! Just the first 40 odd players.....
- Banned
- #61
Pavlich 18th best player in the comp
Fremantle 18th greatest team in the VFL/AFL!! Yep behind Fitzroy, University you name it fremantle are worse than them. Just give up freo you seriosuly suk. The AFL gifts new clubs premierships in the first 10 years but seen you couldnt even win then what hope now??? hahahaha the only new club not to win a flag in first 10 years!!!! post AFL. absolute disgrace.
- Sep 22, 2000
- 62,351
- 41,703
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Ford
Cam Mooney is a much better player than Riewoldt, and had a better year too.
Riewoldt polled 14 Brownlow votes and Mooney polled 1.
Riewoldt won his club's B&F, and Mooney finished 7th in his.
But of course, Mooney deserves to be ranked higher on Mike's Top 50 list, because he plays for Geelong and, um, ... wait ... kicked a few more goals?
Oh, okay.
I though the Top 50 list was supposed to recognise the Best 50 players in the AFL as of now ... not a list of the best 50 of 2007, but just who Mike thought were the most valuable fifty in the AFL.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
Riewoldt polled 14 Brownlow votes and Mooney polled 1.
Riewoldt won his club's B&F, and Mooney finished 7th in his.
But of course, Mooney deserves to be ranked higher on Mike's Top 50 list, because he plays for Geelong and, um, ... wait ... kicked a few more goals?
Oh, okay.
I though the Top 50 list was supposed to recognise the Best 50 players in the AFL as of now ... not a list of the best 50 of 2007, but just who Mike thought were the most valuable fifty in the AFL.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
- Nov 30, 2006
- 4,023
- 7
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Nathan Foley and Joel Corey had almost identical seasons.
One is #7, the other #40
Foley is underrated, and Mike can you get over your thing against Richo?
One is #7, the other #40
Foley is underrated, and Mike can you get over your thing against Richo?
I was hoping Matty Priddis would have cracked a mention, surely he had a better year than the 2 Harris's. Pavlich at #18 is ridiculous, should be top 10 if not top 5. If its best players then Brown should be #1, but Kerr at 8, that's a seriously bad decision.
Agreed.
Incorrect:
Franklin v Geelong: 19 disposals, 6 marks, 1 goal 3. Hardly going missing there. In fact, quite good..
Franklin v Port Adelaide: Ok so you choose the bad game, how bout the good one against them? 10 disposals, 3 goals 3, 8 marks..
Against West Coast he was ordinary.
But he had quality games against good sides such as the Lions (late in the year when they were up and running), Kangaroos, Western Bulldogs (earlier in the year when they were going alright) and Collingwood.. Not including the game against Sydney and Adelaide..
yeah, there goes your arguement..
1. G. Ablett (Geelong)
2. J. Brown (Brisbane)
3. J. Bartel (Geelong)
4. D. Cox (West Coast)
5. M. Scarlett (Geelong)
6. C. Cornes (Port Adelaide)
7. J. Corey (Geelong)
8. D. Kerr (West Coast)
9. B. Harvey (Kangaroos)
10. S. Johnson (Geelong)
11. D. Glass (WestCoast)
12. K. Cornes (Port Adelaide)
13. C. Ling (Geelong)
14. S. Mitchell (Hawthorn)
15. B. Ottens (Geelong)
16. A. McLeod (Adelaide)
17. L. Franklin (Hawthorn)
18. M. Pavlich (Fremantle)
19. M. Egan (Geelong)
20. C. Judd (West Coast)
21. S. Lucas (Essendon)
22. C. Mooney (Geelong)
23. N. Riewoldt (St Kilda)
24. L. Hodge (Hawthorn)
25. A. Goodes (Sydney)
26. S. Fisher (St Kilda)
27. H. McIntosh (Kangaroos)
28. D. Fletcher (Essendon)
29. P. Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
30. C. Brown (Hawthorn)
31. C. Bolton (Sydney)
32. D. Milburn (Geelong)
33. B. Lade (Port Adelaide)
34. B. Johnson (Western Bulldogs)
35. T. Edwards (Adelaide)
36. H. Shaw (Collingwood)
37. J. Hird (Essendon)
38. B. Kirk (Sydney)
39. S. Black (Brisbane)
40. N. Foley (Richmond)
41. S Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
42. T. Cloke (Colingwood)
43. B. Sewell (Hawthorn)
44. D. Swan (Collingwood)
45. S. Goodwin (Adelaide)
46. H. Scotland (Carlton)
47. N. Malceski (Sydney)
48. B. Harris (Western Bulldogs)
49. L. Montagna (St Kilda)
50. D. Harris (Kangaroos)
2. J. Brown (Brisbane)
3. J. Bartel (Geelong)
4. D. Cox (West Coast)
5. M. Scarlett (Geelong)
6. C. Cornes (Port Adelaide)
7. J. Corey (Geelong)
8. D. Kerr (West Coast)
9. B. Harvey (Kangaroos)
10. S. Johnson (Geelong)
11. D. Glass (WestCoast)
12. K. Cornes (Port Adelaide)
13. C. Ling (Geelong)
14. S. Mitchell (Hawthorn)
15. B. Ottens (Geelong)
16. A. McLeod (Adelaide)
17. L. Franklin (Hawthorn)
18. M. Pavlich (Fremantle)
19. M. Egan (Geelong)
20. C. Judd (West Coast)
21. S. Lucas (Essendon)
22. C. Mooney (Geelong)
23. N. Riewoldt (St Kilda)
24. L. Hodge (Hawthorn)
25. A. Goodes (Sydney)
26. S. Fisher (St Kilda)
27. H. McIntosh (Kangaroos)
28. D. Fletcher (Essendon)
29. P. Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
30. C. Brown (Hawthorn)
31. C. Bolton (Sydney)
32. D. Milburn (Geelong)
33. B. Lade (Port Adelaide)
34. B. Johnson (Western Bulldogs)
35. T. Edwards (Adelaide)
36. H. Shaw (Collingwood)
37. J. Hird (Essendon)
38. B. Kirk (Sydney)
39. S. Black (Brisbane)
40. N. Foley (Richmond)
41. S Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
42. T. Cloke (Colingwood)
43. B. Sewell (Hawthorn)
44. D. Swan (Collingwood)
45. S. Goodwin (Adelaide)
46. H. Scotland (Carlton)
47. N. Malceski (Sydney)
48. B. Harris (Western Bulldogs)
49. L. Montagna (St Kilda)
50. D. Harris (Kangaroos)
Cam Mooney is a much better player than Riewoldt, and had a better year too.
Riewoldt polled 14 Brownlow votes and Mooney polled 1.
Riewoldt won his club's B&F, and Mooney finished 7th in his.
But of course, Mooney deserves to be ranked higher on Mike's Top 50 list, because he plays for Geelong and, um, ... wait ... kicked a few more goals?
Oh, okay.
I though the Top 50 list was supposed to recognise the Best 50 players in the AFL as of now ... not a list of the best 50 of 2007, but just who Mike thought were the most valuable fifty in the AFL.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
You're wrong. It's solely based on 2007 performances, not 'who is the best'.
And you shouldn't necessarily use a clubs B&F to illustrate who is better, especially a St.Kilda one. Didn't that hack Baker win one?
Also, the 6 players who finished above him in the B&F also finished above him in this list, so I'm kind've missing your point?
Mooney kicked more goals, had more goal assists and took more contested marks than Riewoldt. Riewoldt did average 4 extra possessions, but they are easy to get when you're leading up to the half back flank getting the cheap ones.
Is Mooney better than Riewoldt in the big scheme of things? Probably not.
Is Mooney worth more than Riewoldt to his club? Yes.
Was Mooney better than Riewoldt in 2007? Absolutely.
Woewodin#1
Team Captain
Western Bulldogs ... haven't won one in 53 years.
- Feb 15, 2006
- 5,555
- 3,461
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Sunderland & Penrith
Nathan Foley and Joel Corey had almost identical seasons.
One is #7, the other #40
Foley is underrated, and Mike can you get over your thing against Richo?
Foley was very unlucky even in the Brownlow will be a very good player in years to come,Richo please very overated player plenty of forwards that are better then him.
Brisbane, inducted in 1989?
First flag, 2001?
12 years i think, but yes i get your call, just love proving people wrong!
1987
roger explosion
Team Captain
what? nobody gifted Port their premiership, they earned it after screwing up 3 times previously...
