He's still a chance to get Scott Gumbleton.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mick still bitter?
- Thread starter livnixon9
- Start date
- Tagged users None
He's still a chance to get Scott Gumbleton.
Sunshine Saint
Cancelled
St Kilda - Player Sponsor Nathan Wright 2015
St Kilda - Nathan Wright Player Sponsor 2014
St Kilda Saints - Tom Ledger Sponsor 2013
- Dec 1, 2011
- 4,464
- 6,211
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Mitta United, Tapalinga, St Marys
You are right Sheedy was at Essendon too long. But possibly you went two years early on pulling the pin on Malthouse???
Equally, we could have easily sacked him at the end of 2006. Theres always debate about the timing of change, but clearly a smooth transition is preferable to bloodletting.
- Banned
- #254
no denying that any sane Collingwood supporter would wish he was still coach, especially when he had everyone by his side and willing to put the hurt of 2011 beside them and rectify things.
Buckley came in and there were immediate rumblings inside the Collingwood walls....history may prove it was one of the most ridiculous appointments since Tim Watson got the gig at St Kilda.
Wheres the evidence of these rumblings?
All our key players have re-signed. Nobody has asked to be traded to Carlton to play for Mick.
Do you still wish Bomber Thompson was Geelong coach? Hes twice the success than Malthouse was, in less time.
- Banned
- #256
Carey said said something about it and then people began looking closer, there was that incident with Dale Thomas staying on the bench but comes on to the field, immediately kicks a goal and looks up to the coaches box and salutes the coaching staff.
Simple things like that along with the usual rumor and innuendo which you often hear about certain players (namely-ex Collingwood players now).
Wayne Carey is your source of evidence?
- Banned
- #258
sure, he knows just as much as Hutchinson, Barrett, Robinson and all those other journos so why deliberate over it?
exactly.
One single alleged gesture towards the coaching box. Wow. The place is falling apart.
- Banned
- #261
you heard about the rift between Leon Davis and a couple of current day players haven't you?
I'm not trolling but you sound like this all relatively new when most people have known this crap for a while now.
Leon Davis is no longer at the club. If theres a rift, who cares. Davis left in pretty ordinary circumstances so its his problem if he burnt some bridges.
I hear Don Scott and Leigh Matthews hate each others guts too.
Yes you are trolling. Show me some evidence that the club is divided.
Why does he need to do that? He never said that right? Just said there were some rumblings and I think he's already demonstrated well enough he's not out of line in saying that. You Collingwood folk are super touchy about your coach these days ... no wondering why
Ok, so theres no evidence.
Duly noted.
Duly noted.
O
Old Spice
Guest
Wayne Carey, nice one, the winner of the Ricky Nixon award for outstanding judgment. We know Carey hates Buckley from the tour of Ireland where Bucks wanted to go to a movie with the playing group after a game while Carey wanted to go and get smashed.
A **** of the very highest order.
Walls stated Carey needed to put up or shut-up. We never heard anything else, but the Mrs Jessops of Bigfooty took this turkey at face value.
- May 27, 2012
- 1,185
- 1,106
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Melbourn Victory, 49ers
The thing that has always puzzled me, what was Eddie thinking when he had it in his mind that NB and MM would be alble to work together as coach and Football Director? There would sure to be some overlap between the two roles. NB and MM both have strong personalities and I'm tipping they would have clashed on issues that did overlap. Pagan summed it up well when he said that he's never seen two bulls work together in a paddock.
Obviously Eddie implemented this arrangement to keep both NB and MM at the club, both signed on so you can't blame Eddie for doing that. I'm sure Eddie would love to have reversd the arrangement once the 2010 flag was won, but the problem is, he is bound by it, not because of how he would look in the public eye, but because NB has a contract in hand which says that in 2012, he will be the senior coach. IMO, it all came down to NB. If he went to Eddie and said Eddie, for the benefit of the club, I'm willing to wait another couple of years, let MM stay on as coach, I'm confident Eddie would have welcomed that with open arms. He would have called a presser, with the 2010 cup sitting next to him to symbolise that he can do no wrong, and tell the world that as a result of this cup, we'll be keeping MM on as coach and NB as assistant for 2 more years. But that didn't happen, NB wanted the job notwithstanding the premiership and so this is what has eventuated. Can't blame NB for that, it's what was agreed.
Obviously Eddie implemented this arrangement to keep both NB and MM at the club, both signed on so you can't blame Eddie for doing that. I'm sure Eddie would love to have reversd the arrangement once the 2010 flag was won, but the problem is, he is bound by it, not because of how he would look in the public eye, but because NB has a contract in hand which says that in 2012, he will be the senior coach. IMO, it all came down to NB. If he went to Eddie and said Eddie, for the benefit of the club, I'm willing to wait another couple of years, let MM stay on as coach, I'm confident Eddie would have welcomed that with open arms. He would have called a presser, with the 2010 cup sitting next to him to symbolise that he can do no wrong, and tell the world that as a result of this cup, we'll be keeping MM on as coach and NB as assistant for 2 more years. But that didn't happen, NB wanted the job notwithstanding the premiership and so this is what has eventuated. Can't blame NB for that, it's what was agreed.
- Banned
- #268
still good enough to knock your mob outta the finals you post absolute shite all your points are baseless
I want to know how did we slide down the ladder? We finished top 4.We still made the prelim with hardly any luck on our side the whole year.4 knee reconstructions.No continuity all year of the playing group playing together.Injuries during games(sydney)we won.Even when one was subbed off after the first half.Swan and reid getting injured in the game against geelong in the fourth quarter when the game was there for geelong to win it and beating adelaide without both of them and lachy keefe doing his knee over in adelaide and adelaide at the time were in their best form, all year. Mick malthouse mouthing off in the background.Apparently we were going out in straight sets according to everyone else. What happened? One of the players best mates,that they lived with died and they still beat west coast in a semi. I am so amazed at what they have done.
And wayne carey is a tosser and i wouldn't believe a word he says.You know sleeping with his best mates wife and all that,but everyone holds his word as gospel when he speaks about collingwood. He is a proven liar that cant be trusted and its no secret he hates buckleys guts. Just wanted to cause more trouble.What else can he do,no way north would have wayne carey come back and coach.They hate him too.
Everyone take off your i hate collingwood/nathan buckley glasses and look at the facts before mouthing off. Mick was past his time,last years grand final proved that.
And wayne carey is a tosser and i wouldn't believe a word he says.You know sleeping with his best mates wife and all that,but everyone holds his word as gospel when he speaks about collingwood. He is a proven liar that cant be trusted and its no secret he hates buckleys guts. Just wanted to cause more trouble.What else can he do,no way north would have wayne carey come back and coach.They hate him too.
Everyone take off your i hate collingwood/nathan buckley glasses and look at the facts before mouthing off. Mick was past his time,last years grand final proved that.
Guess who reads the Herald Sun. Do you know the Herald Sun survives thanks to the support of Collingwood supporters, hence they direct their reporting towards Collingwood supporters?
BTW, how did Jolly, Ball, Tarrant, Krakouer etc get to Collingwood?
The thread title says "Mick still bitter", yet going on the posting in this thread it is quite obvious who is bitter.
neroblack
Premiership Player
I agree wholeheartedly. It's kind of surprising, given that you'd think Carlton fans would be used to missing the finals by now.
They all arrived after Malthouse was given two years notice.
In the ten years prior we got Shane Woewodin Cameron Wood Andrew Williams Chris Bryan Chad Morrison Paul Medhurst Simon Buckley Leigh Brown and Anthony Corrie.
Not much joy there.
Syrus
Premiership Player
- Oct 6, 2010
- 3,449
- 725
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
No joy with Leigh Brown?? Then why did you bother getting Lynch to play the same/similar role to what he played.
Similar threads
