List Mgmt. MSD Watch 2023 [NMFC select Robert Hansen Jnr with #2 in 2023 MSD]

[shinboner magic]

Hope we take two picks to the msd and hope a small fwd or wingman is there at our second pick

 

[Shinboner1]

View attachment 1696592

We must really rate tucker as a key forward/ruck.

 

[Ligma]

We must really rate tucker as a key forward/ruck.

No shit lol

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

We must really rate tucker as a key forward/ruck.

Ruck. Don’t really see a forward there.

The explanation for our pick still doesn’t make sense. We need to replace Free, a ruck, to help fill a short term gap with a development player who would barely be ready for vfl footy?

 

[Shinboner1]

Ruck. Don’t really see a forward there.

The explanation for our pick still doesn’t make sense. We need to replace Free, a ruck, to help fill a short term gap with a development player who would barely be ready for vfl footy?

obviously edwards isnt getting another contract and we're looking to the future.
Xerri has a huge injury cloud and if he goes down when goldy is out we'll need to replace him with our VFL guy.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

obviously edwards isnt getting another contract and we're looking to the future.
Xerri has a huge injury cloud and if he goes down when goldy is out we'll need to replace him with our VFL guy.

I get that, but then why not just take on a mature ruck for 6 months and pick up a project ruck in the main draft. A development ruck is horrible cover for short term needs.

 

[Souup]

Main stand-out trait for me regarding Tucker are his foot-skills - he's a seriously good kick for a ruck. Needs to work on his ability to get around the ground and impact with ball in hand. He's got a strong pair of hands but needs to work on his endurance and getting to the right spot to make sure he can impact in the air.

He's a project-type pick, and while I'd prefer we go with some more experience, I don't mind the selection if we go with him.

 

[The acurate one]

We must really rate tucker as a key forward/ruck.

Yes well we seem to be a little besotted by tall fellas that for whatever reason don't play at AFL level often

1.Comben
2.Xerri
3.CCJ
4.Edwards.
5.Free
6. So heck one more can't hurt

 

[DesertRoo]

obviously edwards isnt getting another contract and we're looking to the future.
Xerri has a huge injury cloud and if he goes down when goldy is out we'll need to replace him with our VFL guy.

I don’t know man, both Xerri and Comben have gone down with serious injuries, both may never come back the same, Edwards might have to show a bit more but he’ll probably be afforded time to do it because of the above.
Fwiw I think he should be tried down back as a Darcy Moore type. And it wasn’t to long ago most called Darcy hopeless.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Really don’t like they are mentioning Tucker as a ruck/forward. He isn’t a forward, like most underage 200+cm talls the only reason why he gets on the end of a few goals is because he is so tall.

 

[Makeshift Park]

So are we any clearer on whether we're taking one or two players?

When does the decision on Mahoney and Free get made again?

 

[roos_fanatic08]

So are we any clearer on whether we're taking one or two players?

When does the decision on Mahoney and Free get made again?

No decision has been made on 1 pick let along 2

 

[My Left Foote]

View attachment 1696533

It feels like FOMO is the driving force behind our strategy for the midseason draft. We seem to always select the player that 'a lot' of other clubs are into.

 

[andana]

Hope we take two picks to the msd and hope a small fwd or wingman is there at our second pick

Hansen Jr not playing for a second week

 

[giantroo]

 

[Shinboner1]

It feels like FOMO is the driving force behind our strategy for the midseason draft. We seem to always select the player that 'a lot' of other clubs are into.

And we always seem to go hard in the trade period for players that have their one good game for the year when they play us.

 

[the big lebowski]

Yes well we seem to be a little besotted by tall fellas that for whatever reason don't play at AFL level often

1.Comben
2.Xerri
3.CCJ
4.Edwards.
5.Free
6. So heck one more can't hurt

Let’s be real though, come end of season edwards is gone.

Free, despite being “ready to go” couldn’t get a game when we played st kilda without CCJ and Comben. So I’d suggest he’s gone too.

Goldy retires after next year.

So that leaves us with Xerri, Comben (who is a forward anyway) and CCJ.

 

[shinboner magic]

Hansen Jr not playing for a second week

I smell the dodgy eagles at play here

 

[chubbspeterson]

I'm ok with a ruck if we think that's the best prospect. Be interesting to see if WCE go Hansen Jnr over Maric, would we take Maric?
There could be many things at play here, Xerri and CCJ injury history and Free may not be AFL level.
Could CCJ be a trade option at year end if he wants to be a full time ruck somewhere else?

 

[andana]

I smell the dodgy eagles at play here

I had the same thought

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

I smell the dodgy eagles at play here

Freo want him.

 

[big_e]

Main stand-out trait for me regarding Tucker are his foot-skills - he's a seriously good kick for a ruck. Needs to work on his ability to get around the ground and impact with ball in hand. He's got a strong pair of hands but needs to work on his endurance and getting to the right spot to make sure he can impact in the air.

He's a project-type pick, and while I'd prefer we go with some more experience, I don't mind the selection if we go with him.

Positives: Good kick.

Negatives: Doesn't get many kicks?

 

[King Corey]

Main stand-out trait for me regarding Tucker are his foot-skills - he's a seriously good kick for a ruck. Needs to work on his ability to get around the ground and impact with ball in hand. He's got a strong pair of hands but needs to work on his endurance and getting to the right spot to make sure he can impact in the air.

He's a project-type pick, and while I'd prefer we go with some more experience, I don't mind the selection if we go with him.

Appreciate your insights and haven't forgotten the stick you copped when you rightly gave your honest opinion about the Dawson selection.

Unfortunately ~12 months later and the current club's selection committee look to be on the same page as you.

 

[shinboner magic]

Positives: Good kick.

Negatives: Doesn't get many kicks?

Bread McKenzie??

 

[Moti]

Leave the ruck alone, let's get someone who can run.