My Top 50

[MickZu]

SS's Top 50

1 - Judd, C (WCE)
2 - Hall, B (Syd)
3 - Brown, J (BL)
4 - Goodwin, S (Ade)
5 - Pavlich, M (Fre)
6 - Ricciuto, M (Ade)
7 - Cox, D (WCE)
8 - West, S (WB)
9 - Hodge, L (Haw)
10 - Kerr, D (WCE)
11 - Edwards, T (Ade)
12 - Johnstone, T (Mel)
13 - Johnson, B (WB)
14 - Embley, A (WCE)
15 - Cousins, B (WCE)
16 - Hird, J (Ess)
17 - Bolton, J (Syd)
18 - Bowden, J (Ric)
19 - Lloyd, M (Ess)
20 - O'Keefe, R (Syd)
21 - Robertson, R (Mel)
22 - Goodes, A (Syd)
23 - Dal Santo, N (StK)
24 - Glass, D (WC)
25 - Buckley, N (Col)
26 - Kirk, B (Syd)
27 - Mitchell, S (Haw)
28 - Johnson, M (Ess)
29 - Cornes, K (PA)
30 - McDonald, J (Mel)
31 - Rutten, B (Ade)
32 - Bruce, C (Mel)
33 - Rocca, A (Col)
34 - Bassett, N (Ade)
35 - Stenglein, T (WCE)
36 - Bell, P (Fre)
37 - Thompson, N (Kan)
38 - Clement, J (Col)
39 - Croad, T (Haw)
40 - McGregor, K (Ade)
41 - Williams, M (Haw)
42 - Akermanis, J (BL)
43 - Didak, A (Col)
44 - Everitt, P (Haw)
45 - Carr, J (Fre)
46 - Harris, B (WB)
47 - Newman, C (Ric)
48 - Johnson, B (Col)
49 - Bartel, J (Gee)
50 - Prestigiacomo, S (Col)

Stiff: Riewoldt (StK), Archer (Kan), Fevola (Car), Ball, (StK), Richardson (Ric), McLeod (Ade), Barry (Syd), Whitnall (Car)

Thoughts?

I always enjoy reading these lists (wether I agree or not), good effort.

BTW Don’t be to concerned about the ferals on here throwing insults at you, these type of “no life people” will probably end up behind bars (nothing really going for them except angry pills).

 

[lebron]

I always enjoy reading these lists (wether I agree or not), good effort.

BTW Don’t be to concerned about the ferals on here throwing insults at you, these type of “no life people” will probably end up behind bars (nothing really going for them except angry pills).

Yes, people who disagree on who the top 50 players in the league are will surely end up in prison. Good post

 

[SpInNeR]

the fact that reiwoldt isnt in the top 5 let alone 50 shows how much you know about football.

Dont waste peoples time.

 

[Leg_Spinning_Sensation]

As I have said on bigcricket, Nick Riewoldt is in my top 5 so I was a bit bemused with that decision but good effort South, obviously mistakes but good effort nonetheless.

Wait, I have just seen you have left off Luke Ball and Andy Mcleod sorry massive supporters of those guys, Bally in top 15 for mine and Mcleod was top 10 but at least top 25 nowadays, carry on.

 

[saint_kozzy33]

SS's Top 50

1 - Judd, C (WCE)
2 - Hall, B (Syd)
3 - Brown, J (BL)
4 - Goodwin, S (Ade)
5 - Pavlich, M (Fre)
6 - Ricciuto, M (Ade)
7 - Cox, D (WCE)
8 - West, S (WB)
9 - Hodge, L (Haw)
10 - Kerr, D (WCE)
11 - Edwards, T (Ade)
12 - Johnstone, T (Mel)
13 - Johnson, B (WB)
14 - Embley, A (WCE)
15 - Cousins, B (WCE)
16 - Hird, J (Ess)
17 - Bolton, J (Syd)
18 - Bowden, J (Ric)
19 - Lloyd, M (Ess)
20 - O'Keefe, R (Syd)
21 - Robertson, R (Mel)
22 - Goodes, A (Syd)
23 - Dal Santo, N (StK)
24 - Glass, D (WC)
25 - Buckley, N (Col)
26 - Kirk, B (Syd)
27 - Mitchell, S (Haw)
28 - Johnson, M (Ess)
29 - Cornes, K (PA)
30 - McDonald, J (Mel)
31 - Rutten, B (Ade)
32 - Bruce, C (Mel)
33 - Rocca, A (Col)
34 - Bassett, N (Ade)
35 - Stenglein, T (WCE)
36 - Bell, P (Fre)
37 - Thompson, N (Kan)
38 - Clement, J (Col)
39 - Croad, T (Haw)
40 - McGregor, K (Ade)
41 - Williams, M (Haw)
42 - Akermanis, J (BL)
43 - Didak, A (Col)
44 - Everitt, P (Haw)
45 - Carr, J (Fre)
46 - Harris, B (WB)
47 - Newman, C (Ric)
48 - Johnson, B (Col)
49 - Bartel, J (Gee)
50 - Prestigiacomo, S (Col)

Stiff: Riewoldt (StK), Archer (Kan), Fevola (Car), Ball, (StK), Richardson (Ric), McLeod (Ade), Barry (Syd), Whitnall (Car)

Thoughts?

at least you tried, its a super hard thing to do and nobody is really qualified as bias will always creep in...Jude Bolton and O'Keef very good players...but really better than reiwolt, ball, mcleod and co?

If anyone has a link to mike sheehans top 50 and could point me in that direction it would be appreciated. interesting to see who has risen and dropped from the start of the year through viewing it

 

[MickZu]

Yes, people who disagree on who the top 50 players in the league are will surely end up in prison. Good post

Where did I say "disagree on who the top 50 players"?
How did you interpret my post with that?
Amazing!!

 

[lebron]

Where did I say "disagree on who the top 50 players"?
How did you interpret my post with that?
Amazing!!

The 'ferals throwing insults at you' are just people who disagree with his choices, and are suggesting who they would have in place.

 

[SpInNeR]

I always enjoy reading these lists (wether I agree or not), good effort.

BTW Don’t be to concerned about the ferals on here throwing insults at you, these type of “no life people” will probably end up behind bars (nothing really going for them except angry pills).

No life people???

Surely it takes more time to create a top 50 on a subject that clearly the author knows nothing about than to post an insults that took...like 30 seconds.

Think of it this way, this "top 50" is so bad it deserved 30 seconds of my life to create an insult and reply to an absolute rubbish of a post.

And another 30 seconds to reply to ur boyant outlook on life.

 

[The Hobo]

Put Lenny Hayes in there before he realises he made another mistake

I actually thought about him, but for some reason decided against him. Cant remember the reason now. Drop Licuria, and put in Hayes

Either way, that team should NOT be able to beat his 2nd team, but i am sure it would easily best his 2nd team.

Would put in a damn good fight against the 1st team, and i think the biggest difference would be Chris Judd.

 

[MickZu]

The 'ferals throwing insults at you' are just people who disagree with his choices, and are suggesting who they would have in place.

I wouldnt have thought so, but there you go!!

There are posters who disagree and say "enter name here" should be in that side. (I'm not referring to them)

There are posters who say "you are a so and so and have no idea" (I was referring to them)

I encourage and compliment those who make an effort and don't have much time for those who criticize.

 

[MickZu]

No life people???

Surely it takes more time to create a top 50 on a subject that clearly the author knows nothing about than to post an insults that took...like 30 seconds.

Think of it this way, this "top 50" is so bad it deserved 30 seconds of my life to create an insult and reply to an absolute rubbish of a post.

And another 30 seconds to reply to ur boyant outlook on life.

"no life people" was just a throw away line but point taken.