Slobbos top 50

Remove this Banner Ad

Joe Daniher plays 1 good game and is all of a sudden top 10, not surprising Robbo can't remember further back than 4 weeks, I think Tom Green is probably 10 spots too high however outside of this I think he has done a reasonable job at his end of season rankings.

Personally, I would have Harry McKay a head of Curnow, Waterman and even Jeremy Cameron, but that is just because I rate what he did this year so highly, but many disagree.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I think Nick Larkey has to be a top 50 player has been a top forward with no support for a few years now.
 
This is how I rate the players going into next season - not ratings for the year.

1- Neale
2-Daicos
3-Bont
4-Heeney
5- Cripps
6- Petracca
7- Hogan
8- Serong
9- Cameron
10- Weitering
11- Merrett
12- Green
13- Stewart
14- Gulden
15- Butters
16- Sheezel
17- Newcombe
18- N Anderson
19- Rozee
20- Curnow
21- Brayshaw
22- Mcgovern
23- Gawn
24- Holmes
25- Warner
26- JHF
27- Young
28- Dy Moore
29- J Sicily
30- I Rankine
31- S Walsh
32- H Andrews
33- M Rowell
34- S Darcy
35- Stengle
36- Blakey
37- R Marshall
38- N Larkey
39- T Greene
40- K Pickett
41- J Dawson
42- LDU
43- L Jackson
44- H Mcluggage
45- A Treloar
46- W Ashcroft
47- O Allen
48- J Steele
49- H Reid
50- JUH
 
Lingsface said:
This is how I rate the players going into next season - not ratings for the year.

1- Neale
2-Daicos
3-Bont
4-Heeney
5- Cripps
6- Petracca
7- Hogan
8- Serong
9- Cameron
10- Weitering
11- Merrett
12- Green
13- Stewart
14- Gulden
15- Butters
16- Sheezel
17- Newcombe
18- N Anderson
19- Rozee
20- Curnow
21- Brayshaw
22- Mcgovern
23- Gawn
24- Holmes
25- Warner
26- JHF
27- Young
28- Dy Moore
29- J Sicily
30- I Rankine
31- S Walsh
32- H Andrews
33- M Rowell
34- S Darcy
35- Stengle
36- Blakey
37- R Marshall
38- N Larkey
39- T Greene
40- K Pickett
41- J Dawson
42- LDU
43- L Jackson
44- H Mcluggage
45- A Treloar
46- W Ashcroft
47- O Allen
48- J Steele
49- H Reid
50- JUH
Click to expand...
Good list.

But the glaring omission from both your list and Robbo's list is....

Josh Dunkley.

He is everything you want in a footballer, and would be one of the first picked at Brisbane. I notice he came 3rd in the Lions B&F - 2 votes behind the winner Neale, and 1 vote behind the runner-up Andrews.

I may overrate him, but he'd comfortably be in my best 25 players.

Also, good to see you have Darcy Cameron in your top 10. Slightly higher than I'd have him, but good, unique selection.
 
Fadge said:
Good list.

But the glaring omission from both your list and Robbo's list is....

Josh Dunkley.

He is everything you want in a footballer, and would be one of the first picked at Brisbane. I notice he came 3rd in the Lions B&F - 2 votes behind the winner Neale, and 1 vote behind the runner-up Andrews.

I may overrate him, but he'd comfortably be in my best 25 players.
Click to expand...
Good shout that one! Again under appreciated I would say top 35.
 
Libbaaaa said:
List is fine except for Newcombe which is laughable.
Click to expand...

No issue with this comment if you can back if up.

But,
Top 15 over the past 2 seasons worth of coaches votes.
18th in the Brownlow last year. 10th this year.
Coaches association young player of the year in 2022 ahead of Daicos.
4th in the Gary Ayres medal this year despite only playing 2 games.
Just won a B&F a few nights ago.

Where would you place him personally?
 
Blackhawk42 said:
Coaches association young player of the year in 2022 ahead of Daicos.
Click to expand...
Criteria for the AFLCA Young Player Of The Year Award:
The AFL Coaches Association Best Young Player Award is presented in recognition of the player based on performances in his first two seasons of AFL Football and is determined by the weekly votes of the AFL coaches.

As good as Daicos is, he wasn't able to cram two years of football into his first season....
 
Fadge said:
Criteria for the AFLCA Young Player Of The Year Award:
The AFL Coaches Association Best Young Player Award is presented in recognition of the player based on performances in his first two seasons of AFL Football and is determined by the weekly votes of the AFL coaches.

As good as Daicos is, he wasn't able to cram two years of football into his first season....
Click to expand...

Newcombe didn't score any votes in his first season.

They both started 2022 from the same point.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Fadge said:
Good list.

But the glaring omission from both your list and Robbo's list is....

Josh Dunkley.

He is everything you want in a footballer, and would be one of the first picked at Brisbane. I notice he came 3rd in the Lions B&F - 2 votes behind the winner Neale, and 1 vote behind the runner-up Andrews.

I may overrate him, but he'd comfortably be in my best 25 players.

Also, good to see you have Darcy Cameron in your top 10. Slightly higher than I'd have him, but good, unique selection.
Click to expand...
We may disagree on a lot but cannot agree more with the above. Josh Dunkley has to be the most underrated player in the comp. The man literally has no weaknesses in his game - can play inside and outside, can play as a defensive midfielder or go forward, take a mark and kick a goal. Star!
 
Last edited:
carlton_99 said:
We may disagree on a lot but cannot agree more with the above. Josh Dunkley has to be the most underrated player in the comp. The man literally has no weaknesses in his game - can play inside and outside, can play as a defensive midfielder or go forward and kick a goal. Star!
Click to expand...
We don't disagree about that much, do we?
 
Fadge said:
My point was... Daicos wasn't eligible in 2022.

It's for players who have played two seasons.
Click to expand...

I always thought it was possible for a first year player to win it if they polled more votes than any other player over their first two. Unless I'm mistaken?
 
Fadge said:
Nah - It's based on a player's first two years.
Click to expand...

If that's the case I've been reading it wrong for 2 years.

I thought the votes were cumulative over two seasons, but you had to be in the first 2 years of your career to be eligible.
So hypothetically speaking, if a first year player scored more than the next best young player over two seasons, they'd still win.

Always happy to be proven wrong though.
 
Fadge said:
Nah - It's based on a player's first two years.
Click to expand...
Blackhawk42 said:
If that's the case I've been reading it wrong for 2 years.

I thought the votes were cumulative over two seasons, but you had to be in the first 2 years of your career to be eligible.
So hypothetically speaking, if a first year player scored more than the next best young player over two seasons, they'd still win.

Always happy to be proven wrong though.
Click to expand...
Since 2003 where it’s been awarded. The award is based off of the best player inside their first two seasons, counting the votes they get across that time. However, there is no age or game limit, so a first year player could win this if they have more votes than the rest eligible, both Newcombe and Daicos got all of their votes in 2022.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Slobbos top 50

Similar threads

G
Rumour Slobbo sacked, Lyon in the box seat
2 3 4
Replies
81
Views
11K
bobs head soup
bobs head soup
Lingsface
Top 50- Season 24
Replies
15
Views
1K
Lingsface
Lingsface
tropicaltiger
Best 3 players last 50 years under 70kg
2
Replies
25
Views
1K
PiCkLeJuiCe
PiCkLeJuiCe
Lingsface
Opinion My top 10- Positions-2024
2
Replies
34
Views
1K
kaiserchief13
K
Lunchtime
Top 10 Players Since 2000
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
259
Views
8K
Fadge
F
Robroy22
Who are your teams Top Eight players
2 3
Replies
67
Views
2K
Robroy22
Robroy22
Lingsface
Top 5 Indigenous families
Replies
8
Views
550
Lingsface
Lingsface

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top