Name your frontrunner to take Whitnall (serious thread)

[WakeUpPies]

he might go to the bulldogs to eat McDougall ....

ok seriously though why would anyone want to take him, his overweight with bad knees, injury waiting to happen

 

[Dogga79]

AFC wont take him as we have finally started rebuilding and a youth policy.

My money would be on Sydney. Smaller ground for big Lance to run around on and would add to their forward line.

 

[Messenger]

Make a great backline coach somewhere.

If he is hoping to be draft, he is going to be disappointed.

 

[borgy]

Adelaide and Bulldogs should take him.

They can have his knees. We'll take the head, thankyou.

 

[nananana catman]

Would look great in a Swans jumper.

 

[jcraw1]

only club i could see him at is bulldogs as they dont have a tall forward.. even so i reckon it would be a poor pickup as he is way past his time.. also thought it was a harsh dropping from carlton.. 11 year player, captain, B&F winner... what do you think????????

I think their ethics, or lack thereof, in the last 10-15 years has been fairly consistent. Hardly surprising to see them sink the boot in with everything else they have done..

 

[SCRAY72]

Blues,who aren't flush with talls, sack their captain and immediately the Dogs are mentioned because they lack tall forwards. If his bone on bone knee is stuffed and he can't play for Carlton then he can't play for anyone.

Front runnner is suburban football.

 

[lyall]

Carlton to redraft him

 

[pazza]

Footscray
Melbourne

 

[Stevie_Crow]

I would like to see him at the crows next year but him in the goal square

If Adelaide pick him up, i think i'll vomit

He is done

 

[SCRAY72]

Footscray
Melbourne

Don't discount your mob, they have picked up Carlton hacks before.

 

[mulhollanddrive]

The original poster being a Hawthorn supporter and all...

Why would you even put our team in the list. Too many obvious reasons to list.

 

[pazza]

Don't discount your mob, they have picked up Carlton hacks before.

Knights is the coach..not Sheedy. We are more liely to get Brennan but if Brisbane sign him, it'll be a case of getting a Jude Bolton if he still available.

 

[WoGiTaLiA]

If we have to be serious...

Bendigo or Williamstown or someone in the VFL is the obvious pick. I can't see any AFL team that is serious about winning picking him up. He wasn't good enough to get a game for Carlton last year(as in he shouldn't not he couldn't) and they were the least talented team in the league.

All that Whitnall can achieve now in the AFL is restricting the progress of a young KP player. That is it.

If it's a joke... Jenny Craig's team.

 

[Pie eyed]

StKilda are the front runner... they get him for nothing...

BARGAIN!!!

He will be a good "bookend" with King from Geelong....
St Kildas new "anti-youth" policy?

 

[Oxygeneral]

I hope the Bombers have a serious think about him. I'd just leave him in the square and help out Lloyd and Lucas. But I reckon Adelaide and the Bulldogs might look at him as well.

 

[Marns]

Kangaroos Football Club

I like what you did there, with the K and the F and the C

 

[unstable punt]

no-one will pick him up, he's finished and will be playing for Lalor next year

 

[NWTYRX]

Looks like the Doggies are out

http://realfooty.com.au/news/news/bulldogs-not-keen-on-whitnall/2007/10/14/1192300599576.html

 

[Asgardian]

He wouldn't survive Herr Craig's fitness regime at the Crows

 

[huggy_b]

I cant see any teams taking him on to be honest. His best footy came and went years ago and he would be just a liability to anyone who picks him up.

 

[Bombers_Forever]

He will retire due to his injury

 

[evo]

I wouldn't mind him. Even if he doesn't play he will be a very good depth player to have. However I wouldn't sign him on much money.

Breadth player would be more accurate.

 

[krisholio14]

Whether anyone picks him up remains to be seen, but I reckon Footscray and a couple of other clubs will at least get him in and have a look.

 

[PsyCrow23]

Crows wouldnt take him I guarentee it.

Port, West Coast, Freo, Bulldogs, Saints might look at him as they seem to be topping up in the last year