![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/fremantle.png)
Purple7x08_24
President: Galactic Federation
Melbourne should get rid of Goodwin, the performance team and bring some new coaches in and they should start this week.1. Goodwin
2. Nicks
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Melbourne should get rid of Goodwin, the performance team and bring some new coaches in and they should start this week.1. Goodwin
2. Nicks
looks that way - he has a great list on paperHardwick, clearly never wanted to coach again, only there for the money.
Is it though?looks that way - he has a great list on paper
What are Adelaide waiting for with Nicks. He sucks…
Adelaide aren’t poor, they can afford to pay it out.Gave him a contract extension in at the start of season before it fell apart, now they’re too embarrassed to back out of it
Not sure beating the Swans was as good as you thought. We are a rabble.Is it going to be Ross the boss or did beating the 1st place team save his career??? lol
You have a had a lot of close losses and have a very young side.Gave him a contract extension in at the start of season before it fell apart, now they’re too embarrassed to back out of it
You have a had a lot of close losses and have a very young side.
There is some argument to be made in support of Nicks.
harsh, i reckon more about the senior players on the field than the coach. sam mitchell lost a couple close ones after a decent lead, i think hes a pretty good coach.How teams handle close games say’s something about the coach
Lets be realistic. Suns won all but one home game this year they are good enough for finals but cant win away. Barring an injury riddled season Suns must win 15 games next season or there abouts or Hardwick has failedHardwick is in his first year, Martin certainly wasn't going to be the difference between that squad's success or failure, he has nothing to worry about until at least the end of year three.
harsh, i reckon more about the senior players on the field than the coach. sam mitchell lost a couple close ones after a decent lead, i think hes a pretty good coach.
How about we sack all coaches and we replace them with chairs.Crazy vossy making a late charge
So much for the wisdom of crowds.
Simpson had somehow managed to convince people he was going to "turn the ship around" after it already sunk.
And it turns out crazy Bevo might just be a crazy wacky mad scientist genius afterall!
As it stands now - Nicks surely must be worst placed? 102 games and 36 wins. Those are bad numbers. Not sure anyone comes back from those numbers? I think hes as good as gone.
Crazy Vossy and Badloss are probably in a similar boat - they're safe for this year but if they start 2025 poorly they'll be in serious strife.Crazy vossy making a late charge
Surely not. After many decades of failure he got them to a prelim in his second season just like Hinks, so it's only fair to give him at least another decade without questioning his tenure. If Carlton fans start agitating in eight or so years time, I fully expect the AFL media to rally around him by calling the fans ingrates and having unrealistic expectations because it's not the VFL anymore.Crazy vossy making a late charge
Crazy vossy making a late charge
Yeah, Goodwin should get the sack for sure. Players not up to standard.Everyone is safe besides Goodwin
Seems like best of both parties for Melb and Goodwin to part ways. Been there for 9 seasons. Don’t want to overdo your stay as coach. Fresh start needed into a new eraEveryone is safe besides Goodwin