NFNL Div 3 discussion 2024

[Champ or Chump]

Will he though? Other side of 40 and not sure he will be getting great supply.

Caff won the comp B&F and is how old? And
Schultz was runner up at 41 or 42.

I think whilst these guys are older they will continue to make Rezza a much more competitive outfit across both sides as they rebuild.

 

[yearoftheeagle]

Caff won the comp B&F and is how old? And
Schultz was runner up at 41 or 42.

I think whilst these guys are older they will continue to make Rezza a much more competitive outfit across both sides as they rebuild.

Yeah fair point. 35 year old wins the league medal and Shultz runner up at 41 is a great effort.

Agree reservoir to leap frog a few sides this year for sure. To early for ladder predictor!?

 

[Champ or Chump]

Yeah fair point. 35 year old wins the league medal and Shultz runner up at 41 is a great effort.

Agree reservoir to leap frog a few sides this year for sure. To early for ladder predictor!?

Go for it Eagle ............

I'll have a crack at something based on absolutely nothing but Big Footy, pub chatter and Social media hype! ie: SFA knowledge of anything and just a bit of fun!!!

Epping
Laurimar
Stars
Mernda
Kilmore
Eltham
Hoers
Ressa
Kinglake
West H
Lalor

 

[Bagsy 82]

Go for it Eagle ............

I'll have a crack at something based on absolutely nothing but Big Footy, pub chatter and Social media hype! ie: SFA knowledge of anything and just a bit of fun!!!

Epping
Laurimar
Stars
Mernda
Kilmore
Eltham
Hoers
Ressa
Kinglake
West H
Lalor

Laurimar
Stars
Epping
Kilmore
Mernda
Ivanhoe
Reservoir
Kinglake
Eltham
West
Lalor

 

[NorthernBastard]

Ivanhoe doing some business too, looks like another strong div 3 season ahead

 

[Big Unit 30]

Ivanhoe doing some business too, looks like another strong div 3 season ahead

I was a little worried about the lack of activity but they’ve dropped a Melb Cup day bonanza on us

 

[Champ or Chump]

I was a little worried about the lack of activity but they’ve dropped a Melb Cup day bonanza on us

Same here biggy!

Some handy additions so far

 

[yearoftheeagle]

I was joking about doing the ladder but now that a few have -

Fitzroy
Epping
Laurimar
Ivanhoe
Kilmore
Mernda
Kinglake
Reservoir
Eltham
Heidleberg west
Lalor

 

[illumineer]

Epping
Laurimar
Ivanhoe
Kilmore
Stars
Reservoir
Mernda
Kinglake
Eltham
Lalor
Heidleberg west

 

[NorthernBastard]

Epping
Fitzroy
Laurimar
Ivanhoe
Mernda
Kilmore
Eltham
Kinglake
Reservoir
Heidelberg West
Lalor

Very much a wild guess on a few of these

 

[Thunder1]

Division 3 shaping up again to be very competitive and even competition which is great for the league.
Promotion/relegation has always been one up and one down, be interested to hear Champ or Chump thoughts on 2 up/2down that the ammos have
Pros/Cons??

 

[Champ or Chump]

Division 3 shaping up again to be very competitive and even competition which is great for the league.
Promotion/relegation has always been one up and one down, be interested to hear Champ or Chump thoughts on 2 up/2down that the ammos have
Pros/Cons??

Think the 2/2 works in Ammo's as they have so many divisions. I don't think a three division comp requires it.

Also, losing an GF and going up is never 'wonderful' even though you move to a better standard of football / greater chance of attaining quality players. Most players are in it for flags so any chance to maximise that should be the starting point of any decision a league H/Q could go with - IMO

 

[CrustyDemon]

Go for it Eagle ............

I'll have a crack at something based on absolutely nothing but Big Footy, pub chatter and Social media hype! ie: SFA knowledge of anything and just a bit of fun!!!

Epping
Laurimar
Stars
Mernda
Kilmore
Eltham
Hoers
Ressa
Kinglake
West H
Lalor

any change to this after yesterday's announcements? Some massive ins for the hoers!

 

[Champ or Chump]

any change to this after yesterday's announcements? Some massive ins for the hoers!

We are in the same basket as Kilmore and Eltham right now I would suggest - so anywhere around that.

But I think Epping, Laurimar, Stars and Mernda out in front on paper with thier form last year/Relegation from higher level and new signings. - IMO.

 

[God Yeah]

Think the 2/2 works in Ammo's as they have so many divisions. I don't think a three division comp requires it.

Also, losing an GF and going up is never 'wonderful' even though you move to a better standard of football / greater chance of attaining quality players. Most players are in it for flags so any chance to maximise that should be the starting point of any decision a league H/Q could go with - IMO

Agree with that take, 2/2 works well in the VAFA due to the size of the comp. One of the major downfalls of the model is historically the 'runner-up' promoted side finds it quite difficult the next season in the higher grade (especially at the pointy end).

A major positive is that there are less meaningless games in the back half of the season.

1/1 works well for NFNL and SFNL and it should remain that way.

 

[tasmanlvr]

Think Laurimar, Stars and Epping should be favourites but it's way too early for a ladder prediction IMO, pre-season yet to kick into gear

 

[Champ or Chump]

Just a bit of meaningless fun Tas on the Wednesday arvo

 

[bertybeetle]

Some impressive Templestowe signings now on their way to Reservoir. and they are still not done Definitely bridging the gap very fast and all teams should be concerned about them next season. Points squeeze could be on.

Scanlon - 4
Palazollo - 5
Grabowski - 4
Cantwell - 3
Schwarzer - 3
Sandric - 4
Beckwith - 4
Ferraro - 2
El Moussali -3
Total - 32

If the Dyson and Edwards rumours are true they are 4 points each.
That is an elite level of top enders to compete with any team.

 

[Champ or Chump]

Some impressive Templestowe signings now on their way to Reservoir. and they are still not done Definitely bridging the gap very fast and all teams should be concerned about them next season. Points squeeze could be on.

Scanlon - 4
Palazollo - 5
Grabowski - 4
Cantwell - 3
Schwarzer - 3
Sandric - 4
Beckwith - 4
Ferraro - 2
El Moussali -3
Total - 32

If the Dyson and Edwards rumours are true they are 4 points each.
That is an elite level of top enders to compete with any team.

Might be hoping they get 50 points again to play with?

 

[Swoopingtime]

Epping
Laurimar
Ivanhoe
Kilmore
Stars
Reservoir
Mernda
Kinglake
Eltham
Lalor
Heidleberg west

What makes you think Mernda drops so far down?

 

[DOOMGLOOM]

Heidelberg West make more promises than a kid does around Xmas time. Frauds. Will never be a top 4 team in Div 3.