Nominate the DUD of the decade!

[Murraj1966]

Took 69 years to win your first and lucky premiership mate, so you cannot talk and St.Kilda was an after-thought in joining the league, the VFL back then asked Port Melbourne and Williamstown to join the VFL before St.Kilda.



lol I think he is referring to our long drought mate, but appreciate the effort though.

Funny, you'd think with the AFL handouts after having your culture destroyed in a move to Sydney it would've taken you longer than 23 years to win a flag? The AFL were basically handing it out on a silver platter and you still ****ed it up in 96! But thanks for taking that away from us!

Oh and 69 < 72

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

David Teague.

Carlton's B and F award has been meaningless since.

 

[loz14]

Kent Kingsley.... I used to laugh everytime he would mark the ball inside the 50, good times

^ This

Gotta add Henry Playfair - my whole family still calls him "Oh Henry".....facepalm. Our words & action for the majority of his time @ Geelong.

 

[TheGoatBaron]

Funny, you'd think with the AFL handouts after having your culture destroyed in a move to Sydney it would've taken you longer than 23 years to win a flag? The AFL were basically handing it out on a silver platter and you still ****ed it up in 96! But thanks for taking that away from us!

Oh and 69 < 72

What handouts did we receive from 82 to 92? But hey, glad to know that you're still paranoid, that I nominated a St.Kilda player though. You cannot handle the fact, that you do indeed have duds in your side?

Like someone else said, he was clearly not worth a number 2 draft pick.

But, never seen a shitter post like that before, so well done on achieving something, unlike your mob.

 

[Mungo Sugars]

Oh God you just reminded me of this spud. I had completely blocked him out of my memory.

Don't complain we had his brother Fabian.

Even bigger spud!

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

McDougall just ahead of Sampi.

 

[Deelighted]

Maybe not to the standard of others in this thread but Daniel Bell is one that comes to mind

 

[Woody15]

+ 1 for McDougall.

 

[Northworth]

Definitely Shannon Watt

round 18 one year i wanted to run onto the ground when he had the 100th goal kicked against him for the season


but cracked the ton a few times

 

[Chism]

Now that it has been reduced to 1 game surely that little fat bloke that ate Derrick Kickett gets a mention in Relton Roberts....

1 game spud of the year for mine. Woefull Tigers just keep producing them.

 

[Murraj1966]

What handouts did we receive from 82 to 92? But hey, glad to know that you're still paranoid, that I nominated a St.Kilda player though. You cannot handle the fact, that you do indeed have duds in your side?

Like someone else said, he was clearly not worth a number 2 draft pick.

But, never seen a shitter post like that before, so well done on achieving something, unlike your mob.

Why exactly are you stopping at 1992?

 

[lionaround]

Daniel Pratt.

 

[Bombers 2003]

Karl Norman?
Chris Dudd

 

[Woody15]

Steven Dodd is rubbish as well.

 

[Pariah]

Nick Gill

 

[PHX]

Does Daniel McAllister qualif?. Drafted in about 97, finished in 02 I think. Top 10 pick, 6 games or so. Delisted, then unfathomably redrafted by Sheedy at about pick 64. Lasted another season.

Which is why I said Partly, because he still managed to stink it up until the end of 2002 when he was no where near up to to it after being drafted in 1996 at pick 5.

 

[Ed_Gein]

I'd nominate Daniel o'keefe, but I've never seen him play. Lol. 1st round pick by the swans a few years back, never got a game, delisted and apparently can't even cement a spot with his current vfl side

 

[Dangas]

simon arnott

 

[Something more...]

Has to be McDougall.

After being traded from WC to Bullies, he said in an interview that he was happy to be traded because "... I just didn't fit in with the other (WC) players; all they ever talked about was footy, and I'm not into it that much."

 

[roo_to_kozi]

I'm suprised to one has mentioned brett moyle. biggest potato farmer i've ever seen

 

[IAMJUNGLEMUFFIN]

Rhys Palmer

He won a Rising star, and was what, pick 7?

Chris Masten has won and will win, **** all, not bad for pick 3. Even if Palmer never accomplishes anything else, it's one more achievement than Masten.

 

[Ealesy]

"Dancing" Darren Walsh, managed 2 games before being delisted by the Bombers. Last I heard (it was a few years ago) he was struggling to hold a spot in the seniors in his EDFL team.

 

[jackster83]

simon arnott

He did alright with Centrals in the SANFL

 

[Look2Me4Guidance]

Simon Cox

Dylan Addison

Peter Street

but we'll go with Josh Thurgood.

 

[Big Blow Hard]

Which is why I said Partly, because he still managed to stink it up until the end of 2002 when he was no where near up to to it after being drafted in 1996 at pick 5.

Sorry bud, had not noticed your earlier post, so was not referring to it. But I think we agree on his duddiness.