Opinion Non-Crows AFL 11

[Kane McGoodwin]

Port have not done that (yet)

Was mentioned on the news last night?

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

This podcast is absolutely brilliant, a must listen. As much detail as I’ve heard about what happened at our club from 05-17. It’s a shame he’s been lost to footy.

 

[PeterSalt]

This podcast is absolutely brilliant, a must listen. As much detail as I’ve heard about what happened at our club from 05-17. It’s a shame he’s been lost to footy.

I enjoyed listening to his story .. generally wouldn't bother with a hour podcast

 

[Mostyn]

This podcast is absolutely brilliant, a must listen. As much detail as I’ve heard about what happened at our club from 05-17. It’s a shame he’s been lost to footy.

Surely he comes back at some stage.

There's a lot of experience that he holds, and some genuine success.

 

[Cromulant]

Surely he comes back at some stage.

There's a lot of experience that he holds, and some genuine success.

Sort of.

He didn't win a flag with Brisbane and DJR have gone backwards in Supercars with him.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Sort of.

He didn't win a flag with Brisbane and DJR have gone backwards in Supercars with him.

He’s critical to that success at Brisbane. The story about Neale is a very interesting listen and Noble was absolutely key in this.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Surely he comes back at some stage.

There's a lot of experience that he holds, and some genuine success.

Unfortunately it doesn’t sound like it, very definitive at the end when asked if he would ever come back to footy. Seems a very forward looking guy and doesn’t want to go back now he’s made this career change.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Surely he comes back at some stage.

There's a lot of experience that he holds, and some genuine success.

Noble is vastly superior to our current incumbent & the Crows now have better structure.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Noble is vastly superior to our current incumbent & the Crows now have better structure.

Unfortunately the media attacks on him during his time at North took a toll, he did not leave open a return to footy at all and seems very happy with his decision. Clarko hasn't done any better with that list (which is probably better now) and doesn't cop anywhere near the same heat.

He also mentioned that Phil Walsh is the best footy tactical mind he's ever come across (Sando said the same in another Sacked podcast ep) and has no doubt he would have won at least one or two flags as a senior coach.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Hmmm... whole year?

 

[glengowan]

Hmmm... whole year?

Port are better off without him. Seen him put in some weak efforts on the field over the years. The exact type of player you don't want in your team if you want to win a premiership.

 

[Cromulant]

Port are better off without him. Seen him put in some weak efforts on the field over the years. The exact type of player you don't want in your team if you want to win a premiership.

They're not better off without him at all.

He's close to their most important player

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Unfortunately the media attacks on him during his time at North took a toll, he did not leave open a return to footy at all and seems very happy with his decision. Clarko hasn't done any better with that list (which is probably better now) and doesn't cop anywhere near the same heat.

He also mentioned that Phil Walsh is the best footy tactical mind he's ever come across (Sando said the same in another Sacked podcast ep) and has no doubt he would have won at least one or two flags as a senior coach.

Said at the time i though Noble made a strange career choice to coach the Roos who had an awful list.

I rated his time at both the Crows & Lions... & would have him back in an instant over our incumbent as vastly superior operator.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

They're not better off without him at all.

He's close to their most important player

Saw how much they missed him in finals.

Sure they get Farrell back next year, but Houston is another level & now easier to shut Farrell down given they missed out on FA's.

Meanwhile we have Cumming joining Hinge, Max & even Dawson coming off half back.

 

[Crow_68]

Port are better off without him. Seen him put in some weak efforts on the field over the years. The exact type of player you don't want in your team if you want to win a premiership.

He was of 3 x A-graders they have, certainly not better off.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Said at the time i though Noble made a strange career choice to coach the Roos who had an awful list.

I rated his time at both the Crows & Lions... & would have him back in an instant over our incumbent as vastly superior operator.

Noble goes into the decision to coach North in that interview. It was his ultimate career goal to become an AFL senior coach and he had to take the opportunity when it presented, or another one might not come.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Noble goes into the decision to coach North in that interview. It was his ultimate career goal to become an AFL senior coach and he had to take the opportunity when it presented, or another one might not come.

Was coaching & career suicide.

Said so at the time.

Man needs to know his limitations.

 

[hugecannon]

Unfortunately the media attacks on him during his time at North took a toll, he did not leave open a return to footy at all and seems very happy with his decision. Clarko hasn't done any better with that list (which is probably better now) and doesn't cop anywhere near the same heat.

He also mentioned that Phil Walsh is the best footy tactical mind he's ever come across (Sando said the same in another Sacked podcast ep) and has no doubt he would have won at least one or two flags as a senior coach.

Bring him back as a board member?

 

[Billy Cart]

Sort of.

He didn't win a flag with Brisbane and DJR have gone backwards in Supercars with him.

Er no but not because of him though. Their current driver line up is not the best and they lost their best engineer to a rival, however they will be getting the current champion and Bathurst winner next season.

 

[adelaidecrows]

Unfortunately the media attacks on him during his time at North took a toll, he did not leave open a return to footy at all and seems very happy with his decision. Clarko hasn't done any better with that list (which is probably better now) and doesn't cop anywhere near the same heat.

He also mentioned that Phil Walsh is the best footy tactical mind he's ever come across (Sando said the same in another Sacked podcast ep) and has no doubt he would have won at least one or two flags as a senior coach.

Coaches get screwed over by club culture more than their ability. North has been an irrelevant club in its entire history even when they were dominating the 90s. Like the Bulldogs, saints they will be the same 100 years from now. Just crap and irrelevant with the need to be carried. Gold Coast and GWS look destined to fall into the same category.

On CPH2371 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Scorpus]

Noble goes into the decision to coach North in that interview. It was his ultimate career goal to become an AFL senior coach and he had to take the opportunity when it presented, or another one might not come.

From the podcast it sounded like Noble knew very quickly that he didn't have the experience or skills to be a senior coach and I think that's proven from his results