Off limits (staying put)

[TheClokes]

The Untouchable Players

Ben Reid
Dale Thomas
Martin Clarke
Nathan Brown
Scott Pendlebury
Travis Cloke
Chris Dawes
Heath Shaw

 

[NWTYRX]

well, you can probably forget about Judd then

 

[Burzum]

Ok..

 

[I'm the Juggernaut]

Kiss Juddy bye bye

 

[walkers a legend]

i think you may have to give up at least one of pendles, cloke or thomas

 

[Eddie Gold]

Lets go to courts for Free Agency then and West Toast get nothing.

 

[Scotland]

The Untouchable Players

Ben Reid
Dale Thomas
Martin Clarke
Nathan Brown
Scott Pendlebury
Travis Cloke
Chris Dawes

With apologies to Harvey Danger:

'Been around the world and found that only stupid people are breeding...'

 

[unstable punt]

The Untouchable Players

Ben Reid
Dale Thomas
Martin Clarke
Nathan Brown
Scott Pendlebury
Travis Cloke
Chris Dawes

you will lose at least one maybe two of these if you want Judd

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Everybody wants something for nothing.

You won't get Judd by offering picks 88 and 95 in the draft.

 

[Hap Hapablap]

well, you can probably forget about Judd then

agreed.

 

[Eddie Gold]

okay you can have Carlton's pick 3 and Josh Kennedy

a guy washed up at 19.

 

[HFF]

Jeez, talk about people overblowing the situation. That list looks about right.

If we HAVE to lose one or two of those players, does that mean the Blues need to lose Murphy or Gibbs?

Does that mean Melbourne should lose Mclean or Jones?

Do Essendon need to lose Gumbleton or Ryder?

Didak and/or Fraser will be shopped around as trade bait if we are to get Judd. Adelaide are reportedly chasing Didak so we will get ahold of a top10 pick-maybe top5 if Didak is to be traded.

A top 10 pick/top5 pick + another first rnd pick (14) would be an equitable trade. Maybe throw in a sweetener as well.

 

[TheBrownlowMan37]

well, you can probably forget about Judd then

Why? Rusling and Swan could easily be traded for Judd.

 

[The Majestic]

i think you may have to give up at least one of pendles, cloke or thomas

They have signed contracts, which will mean we pay them off if they leave, so that ain't happening.

 

[thesting]

The Untouchable Players

Ben Reid
Dale Thomas
Martin Clarke
Nathan Brown
Scott Pendlebury
Travis Cloke
Chris Dawes

As everyone else has pointed out already, say goodbye to Chris Judd then. Why would you not consider trading Cloke or Rusling if it came down to it as part of the Judd trade? West Coast could be interested in another key forward. Any trade involving Judd is going to casue at least some pain...

BTW, I realise you have not even mentioned Judd, we have all just assumed he is part of your plan.

Edit: Maybe because it is on the Judd board...

 

[_RT_]

The Untouchable Players

Ben Reid
Dale Thomas
Martin Clarke
Nathan Brown
Scott Pendlebury
Travis Cloke
Chris Dawes

While your on the computer better send an email to Paul Connors and tell him the meeting is off then.

 

[sweet17]

Lets go to courts for Free Agency then and West Toast get nothing.

Wow, we're all shakin in our boots.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Why? Rusling and Swan could easily be traded for Judd.

They could ?

Explain.

 

[lyall]

Lets go to courts for Free Agency then and West Toast get nothing.

Your a fool

 

[matta]

The Untouchable Players

Ben Reid
Dale Thomas
Martin Clarke
Nathan Brown
Scott Pendlebury
Travis Cloke
Chris Dawes
Heath Shaw

Why is anyone off limits. The way I see it is that players are only off limits if what else has to be given as well as that player is too high (ie the overall trade is too unattractive). Surely any of thsoe players would not be untouchable if all the club had to give was them (ie Thomas/ Pendlevary for Judd straight up - no extra draft picks etc). Of course this won't happen as the WCE won'ty accept it but I think people have to get over this unouchable tag. Judd is the best player in the comp period and still has 5+ years to play at the highest level. Any other player is worth that.

 

[SOT4]

Pies fans need to realise that you dont have a high draft pick. You may trade away for one but you'll need two. Blues, Dons, Dees all have at least one high draft pick. Reid and/or Brown would certainly be on the table you would think.

 

[HFF]

If we did get our hands on another draft pick which most likely be top 10-maybe top 5, then our offer of 2 first rnd draft picks would be alot better than anyone else's offer of just 1.

Only carlton could trump it if they activated pick1-which is off limits.

Anyway, lets just wait until Judd makes a decision.

 

[TheBrownlowMan37]

They could ?

Explain.

Because they'd be an adequate replacement for Judd.

 

[Brahma Bull]

I think our only untouchables are:

Pendles, Thomas, Cloke, H.Shaw and possibly M.Clarke and Goldsack

 

[Podge2Flanklin]

Why? Rusling and Swan could easily be traded for Judd.

Champagne comedy