-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Official trade week thread
- Thread starter Demon37
- Start date
- Tagged users None
is it AFL approved?
then i wont post....
j/k
im tipping there will be big names that havent been talked about getting traded. i doubt tigers will get brown or solomon. just crap all of it, just because there doing there trading thru the media ppl believe it. there giving up there details, while other clubs are doing it private.. no doubt bettering the deals the tigers have done. no cap room, just crap or untouchables will see them get not much at all. watch essendon rip ppl off once again. watch the swans try and off load players 27 to 29 years of age, varlton trying to trade anyone for big names, while clubs will just wait to they get delisted. any other views on the trading period ppl?
j/k
im tipping there will be big names that havent been talked about getting traded. i doubt tigers will get brown or solomon. just crap all of it, just because there doing there trading thru the media ppl believe it. there giving up there details, while other clubs are doing it private.. no doubt bettering the deals the tigers have done. no cap room, just crap or untouchables will see them get not much at all. watch essendon rip ppl off once again. watch the swans try and off load players 27 to 29 years of age, varlton trying to trade anyone for big names, while clubs will just wait to they get delisted. any other views on the trading period ppl?
CowboyFromHell
Witchtripper
- Sep 13, 2001
- 13,582
- 2,074
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Denver Nuggets, Man Utd.
Here is what I believe we will get, without going overboard.
Gains:
Dean Solomon
Danny Jacobs
Ben Holland
Possibly a pick(s)
Losses:
Pick #5
Pick #20
Chris Lamb
Paul Wheatley
Pick #5 will go for Solomon and Jacobs. Pick #20 will probably go for Holland, but I could be wrong. I think Lamb and Wheatley are just about dead certs to be traded, either for mid range picks or as a sweetner.
Gains:
Dean Solomon
Danny Jacobs
Ben Holland
Possibly a pick(s)
Losses:
Pick #5
Pick #20
Chris Lamb
Paul Wheatley
Pick #5 will go for Solomon and Jacobs. Pick #20 will probably go for Holland, but I could be wrong. I think Lamb and Wheatley are just about dead certs to be traded, either for mid range picks or as a sweetner.
Ok, here is what I realistically think we'll do..
IN: Stevens, Holland, Hulme, Jacobs, Wheatley
OUT: Pick5, Pick 20, Lamb, pick 52
Stevens for pick 5
holland for Lamb, pick 52
Hulme for Wheatley
Jacobs for pick 20
Although I do think we will also be VERY close to solomon, and if Michael becomes available, he'll overtake Jacobs..
Sounds too good to be true, but all these players, believe it or not, are possible, but to get all, say goodbye to White.
IN: Stevens, Holland, Hulme, Jacobs, Wheatley
OUT: Pick5, Pick 20, Lamb, pick 52
Stevens for pick 5
holland for Lamb, pick 52
Hulme for Wheatley
Jacobs for pick 20
Although I do think we will also be VERY close to solomon, and if Michael becomes available, he'll overtake Jacobs..
Sounds too good to be true, but all these players, believe it or not, are possible, but to get all, say goodbye to White.
did u make an error buddy . YOu got wheatley going out and coming back in
Mate im a port fan and i think that port might want more than just pik 5, but u never know. If you get all that you will be doin very well...
Wishful thinking tho
Mate im a port fan and i think that port might want more than just pik 5, but u never know. If you get all that you will be doin very well...
Wishful thinking tho
I think we will be able to do some good deals.
Michael for Pick 5
or
Stevens for Pick 5 + Pick 34
---
Jacobs for Pick 20
---
Holland for Pick 52 + Wheatley
---
Pick 34 (WB) for Lamb
---
If we want Stevens, then don't give Port a ridiculous offer like they are asking for. Give them 5 and 34 which is sufficient I believe. If we don't want him, then it will be a straight swap for Mal Michael (if he is available, which I doubt he will be). Otherwise, we will keep the pick.
Ben Holland will come with our 4th round pick plus Paul Wheatley, which is fair in my opinion. Pick 20 is too much, Pick 36 is taken and Pick 52 alone isn't enough. If they don't accept, and the Stevens deal falls through, we could still use Pick 34, which we would get from the Bulldogs in exchange for Lamb.
Danny Jacobs for Pick 20 alone would be fair in my opinion, and a win for both clubs. Essendon's first round pick comes at 13 I think, so this pick is only 7 spots lower. A fair deal there.
Now, there are 4/5 deals which are fair I believe, and should benefit all clubs involved. Of course, we won't be lucky enough to get all of them, but I'm hoping that at least 2 can arrive.
Michael for Pick 5
or
Stevens for Pick 5 + Pick 34
---
Jacobs for Pick 20
---
Holland for Pick 52 + Wheatley
---
Pick 34 (WB) for Lamb
---
If we want Stevens, then don't give Port a ridiculous offer like they are asking for. Give them 5 and 34 which is sufficient I believe. If we don't want him, then it will be a straight swap for Mal Michael (if he is available, which I doubt he will be). Otherwise, we will keep the pick.
Ben Holland will come with our 4th round pick plus Paul Wheatley, which is fair in my opinion. Pick 20 is too much, Pick 36 is taken and Pick 52 alone isn't enough. If they don't accept, and the Stevens deal falls through, we could still use Pick 34, which we would get from the Bulldogs in exchange for Lamb.
Danny Jacobs for Pick 20 alone would be fair in my opinion, and a win for both clubs. Essendon's first round pick comes at 13 I think, so this pick is only 7 spots lower. A fair deal there.
Now, there are 4/5 deals which are fair I believe, and should benefit all clubs involved. Of course, we won't be lucky enough to get all of them, but I'm hoping that at least 2 can arrive.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
i think we should try to get solomon for pick 20 and a player (not crap like lamb or wheatley unless they are interested)
solomon for the above trade, holland for lamb, michael for pick 5
if we dont get michael for pick 5 then stevens for pick 5
solomon for the above trade, holland for lamb, michael for pick 5
if we dont get michael for pick 5 then stevens for pick 5
I think Mal Michael is a little overrated...he is playing in the team with the best midfield so you think that would make him look a bit better than he is. I wouldn't give pick 5 for him.
- Sep 18, 2003
- 5,592
- 4
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Banned
- #14
just reported over hear in the west on Ch.10 that the eagles are making a big play for Stevie Armstrong - despite signing a new contract with u guys.
But u guys told us to come up with alot more.
Basically im asking what would u people consider reasonable from the eagles for Armstrong???
(positive suggestions- none of the "wont trade him" -cause it looks like u will if u get the right deal)
But u guys told us to come up with alot more.
Basically im asking what would u people consider reasonable from the eagles for Armstrong???
(positive suggestions- none of the "wont trade him" -cause it looks like u will if u get the right deal)
- Sep 18, 2003
- 5,592
- 4
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Banned
- #16
ppffttt .....sorry stinga those boys r in different leagues.
Wat about Armstrong + Nicholson for our 1st and 3rd round picks?
Wat about Armstrong + Nicholson for our 1st and 3rd round picks?
Deestroy
Norm Smith Medallist
No.
Deemolition
Rookie
That's right, Arma will be a substantially better player in years to come!
CowboyFromHell
Witchtripper
- Sep 13, 2001
- 13,582
- 2,074
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Denver Nuggets, Man Utd.
Armstrong for Kerr.
That's about the amount you would need to land Steve Armstrong, plus he's stated numerous times he's VERY happy at the Dees.
That's about the amount you would need to land Steve Armstrong, plus he's stated numerous times he's VERY happy at the Dees.
Who would we want for Armstrong?
Well Eagles fans, look at your list, pick your best young talent that you can't afford to lose, that's him.
That's how we feel about arma.
Well Eagles fans, look at your list, pick your best young talent that you can't afford to lose, that's him.
That's how we feel about arma.
I'll you what would work..
Armstrong, pick 20
for
Judd
still wanna deal??? hahahaha
Armstrong, pick 20
for
Judd
still wanna deal??? hahahaha
Seriously though,
We'd take sampi, add in a 3rd rnder..
We'd take sampi, add in a 3rd rnder..
CowboyFromHell
Witchtripper
- Sep 13, 2001
- 13,582
- 2,074
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Denver Nuggets, Man Utd.
I wouldn't. Try Sampi and a 2nd rounder at least.
Not a huge Sampi fan myself.
How old is Braun? Him & decent pick? I know he's a hack but that hasn't stopped us in the past....
How old is Braun? Him & decent pick? I know he's a hack but that hasn't stopped us in the past....
