RPCB
Community Leader
- Moderator
- #2,576
halftime on * board:
"Sadly Shiel will be an ever lasting memory of the worsfold era. He was never worth those first round picks and probably salary cap. I hope he can lift himself in future but so far just an outside guy with speed and a poor kick. And speed slows fast as you get older. He’ll probably peak quickly with age. Hope I’m wrong."
"I'd honestly trade Shiel if we could get a top 20 pick for him. He is a front runner of the highest order. Can't defend for sh*t."
In the end it was totally worth it as Carlton supporters to have opposition supporters mock us that Shiel “snubbed“ our club.