thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #276
You 2 rabbits need to be permanently domed, Bubble Boy style.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Our best rolling 22
- Thread starter HBF
- Start date
- Tagged users None
BlueGum
Navy Blue
Liked for bubble boy. That's old school
Pretty young when i had Johnnys Greenroom in Carlton packed deep on a few occasions back in the day heading up into levels no one had reached before, with my total game high initials all down the page, fantastic game back in the day...
It took you long because you may have been looking for evidence to support your claim.....but couldn't find it.
You can't find it because you're just imagining shit and then you want to highlight others having mental issues. Poor form buddy.
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #280
Or possibly an obscure reference to the Seinfeld episode......
- Sep 26, 2004
- 47,838
- 64,817
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #281
Nothings finer than a classic Thy one-liner...
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #282
Crikey, it must be the season for giving......
I have dragged it all over here
This is truly hilarious, especially suggesting people are imagining or making stuff up. You banged on all year, "How are we going to fit in all these mids", yet now you are suggesting that they can play other roles? Mindblowing
So lets look at the evidence:
Was it not you that wanted to bet on Fogarty getting the last spot ahead of Gibbons? Would that suggest you had him slotted in as best 22?
In this post " Fogarty - We didn't get him for no reason. he new boys start and he'll take Gibbons spot." Pretty definitive wouldn't you say?
www.bigfooty.com
Now on to you changing your opinion with the passing breeze, or hedging bets, or listening to other people
From these 2 posts, you had Marchbank as a starter, then a WHOLE 2 days later " Newman now somehow just feels right in this mix to me. He has no issue finding the ball and now we have plenty of exit players for support. He doesn't have to find opening up the ground himself, any more. "
www.bigfooty.com
www.bigfooty.com
Then this last one
Betts is now back in as a starter and affter wanting to lay a bet that Fogarty will start ahead of Gibbons, we get this, " Still scope for Fogarty or Gibbons to get involved.
www.bigfooty.com
Yet you want to call people out for imagining, calling people liars? Looking in the mirror?
This will be the last time I go easy on you, told you a while back, you may have others fooled, but I will keep calling out your inaccuracies
This is truly hilarious, especially suggesting people are imagining or making stuff up. You banged on all year, "How are we going to fit in all these mids", yet now you are suggesting that they can play other roles? Mindblowing
So lets look at the evidence:
Was it not you that wanted to bet on Fogarty getting the last spot ahead of Gibbons? Would that suggest you had him slotted in as best 22?
In this post " Fogarty - We didn't get him for no reason. he new boys start and he'll take Gibbons spot." Pretty definitive wouldn't you say?
Our best rolling 22
Docherty Jones Plowman Saad Weitering Williams Walsh SPS Newnes Kennedy Cripps Martin Fisher Mckay Silvagni DeKonig Setterfield Curnow Cottrell Gibbons Kemp Fogarty Cottrell gets a game due to his hard edge We explore Kennedy in the Grigg short Ruck role. Cripps more time forward No...
www.bigfooty.com
Now on to you changing your opinion with the passing breeze, or hedging bets, or listening to other people
From these 2 posts, you had Marchbank as a starter, then a WHOLE 2 days later " Newman now somehow just feels right in this mix to me. He has no issue finding the ball and now we have plenty of exit players for support. He doesn't have to find opening up the ground himself, any more. "
List Mgmt. - 2020 List Management II
See above We had two of them KPD's and they didnt develop..what good is another that doesnt ? Reckon they will play Casboult back and see how Kemp goes. Plus the young rookie Parks will fill out nice over a couple of preseasons. Plenty of options.
www.bigfooty.com
Our best rolling 22
I don't know this place anymore........... Jimmae starting business all over the shop.
www.bigfooty.com
Then this last one
Betts is now back in as a starter and affter wanting to lay a bet that Fogarty will start ahead of Gibbons, we get this, " Still scope for Fogarty or Gibbons to get involved.
Our best rolling 22
Ed still doesn't get the credit he deserves. In 2020 he ranked: - #1 at the club for centre bounces attended; - Top 30 for clearances, second at the club behind Cripps; - Top 10 for tackles, top 5 if you exclude finals; and - Top 20 for inside 50s, top 15 if you exclude finals Sure, we'll...
www.bigfooty.com
Yet you want to call people out for imagining, calling people liars? Looking in the mirror?
This will be the last time I go easy on you, told you a while back, you may have others fooled, but I will keep calling out your inaccuracies
How about you don’t...you just ignore (yes, use the button) & you can use your crusading powers elsewhere.
The Great Ian
Senior List
- Sep 3, 2010
- 224
- 708
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Teague surely won’t waste another year essentially playing a man down trying to get Murphy to 300....?
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #286
gee, that's a rubbish comment......and I'm not his biggest fan..........
- Sep 19, 2019
- 10,904
- 15,443
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Lakeshow
Still one of our cleverest ball users. Play forward of centre and be opportunistic for 15 plus games. Happy for a youngster to overthrow if form permits.
Might be the first of Teague’s big calls, Clarko/Scott style.
- Nov 3, 2020
- 3,030
- 11,214
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Sandringham Zebras
- Larke Medal: 2005
- AFL Rising Star nominee: 2006
- AFLPA Best First Year Player Award: 2006
- International rules series: 2008
- AFLCA Champion Player of the Year: 2011
- All-Australian team: 2011
- 2× John Nicholls Medal: 2011, 2017
- Carlton captain: 2013–2018
285 game player, and a club champion
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #289
had the rs in his pocket halfway through the season until thug copeland
I tell you what ...find a Murphy highlights reel ..settle in as it will be at least an hour long....then come back and talk to us...........
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #291
in ian the lesser's defence, I believe he is talking about current murph as opposed to murph's career contribution............still a pretty unfair comment........
- Sep 19, 2019
- 10,904
- 15,443
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Lakeshow
No issue with that. Teague believe he is still one of our most dependable players with ball in hand, despite the defensive deficiencies. until that changes, he plays.
He still tackles btw!
He still tackles btw!
Be hard to get rid of Murphy until we can get a midfielder who racks up 25-30 touches and 15km of hard, two-way running...
He’s not the player he was (or looked to be), but for every iffy touch he gets, there’s 5 quality disposals to go with them.
He’s not the player he was (or looked to be), but for every iffy touch he gets, there’s 5 quality disposals to go with them.
JustaBattler
Everyone Looks Better In Blue
- May 31, 2012
- 28,273
- 66,616
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Defensive back six is pretty well set with locks : Weitering|Jones|Saad|Docherty|Plowman - leaving SPS|Marchbank|Newman probably next three fighting for starting 6 spot ( I'd include Williamson in that mix if I didn't have him pencilled in for a wing spot contender).
Forwards are pretty well set with: Levi|Harry|Eddie|Martin|McGovern as my 5 locks leaving: Fisher|Cuningham|Gibbons as the next 3 fighting for a starting 18 spot [ Charlie is a walk up start hopefully by second half of the year ]
Midfield is pretty much set as well with my locks being : Cripps|Murphy|Walsh|Williams|Setterfield|Ed - leaving: a whole bunch of blokes fighting over maybe 2 IC bench spots - I reckon Williamson| Fogarty|Newnes|Gibbons will be ahead of Dow|Stocker| and the younger brigade including Cottrell|Honey|Philp well behind and 'developing'
Will be interesting who gets first go in ruck - but have to say that TDK is a very exciting prospect - has gone past Dow/Lob/ in terms of on field AFL performances - already.
SOJ|Kennedy should be mentioned as fighting it out against McGovern for a third tall rotating mid option and as depth - SOJ would be starting 22 for sure IF he was a couple of meters faster and a better set shot kick - Kennedy's lack of leg speed sees him pretty much behind Setterfield and Ed as an on ball option - maybe ahead of SOJ because he is a better mark and kick as a forward option.
The Club has already stated that Kemp won't be rushed back into football and is being thought of as a defensive player to start with. He and Stocker are the most interesting grunters I will be watching for in '21 with a keen eye on progress - along with Honey.
If I was still living in Melbourne I'd probably be going to as many VFL games as possible - how good is it to have a Carlton VFL team to watch younger blokes develop in - fantastic.
The factor X this year will be how well the side can run out the longer quarters combined with fewer rotations - no doubt in my mind Russell has set up a physical prep program for normal length quarters - and not the shortened game that ended up being played in '20.
tldr?
The OP title is 'best rolling22' and I think Teague pretty much goes with who he had playing last year - adding Saad/Williams and probably Fogarty into the mix. I think the only question mark I have is wether Teague continues to favour a 2 ruck combo with both Pittonet and TDK in the side. Gibbons|Newman|Newnes are unlucky maybe - and Dow/Lob/Stocker are in the same boat as Kennedy for '21 - they have to start showing something sooner rather than later.
Round 1 rolling best 22:
Plowman Jones Marchbank ( for mine)
Docherty Weitering Saad
Murphy Cripps Walsh
TDK Ed Williams
Martin Harry Cuningham
McGovern Levi Eddie
IC: Setterfield Williamson Fisher Fogarty(?)
Hope you all had a great Xmas - we are busty being locked down in Manly atm.
by the end of the year ( injuries aside ) I woudl expect Charlie | Kemp to be in the side along with one of Stocker/Dow. Also wouldn't be surprised if Cuningham is more a mid than a forward by years end.
Can't really get my mind around Simmo not playing anymore.
Forwards are pretty well set with: Levi|Harry|Eddie|Martin|McGovern as my 5 locks leaving: Fisher|Cuningham|Gibbons as the next 3 fighting for a starting 18 spot [ Charlie is a walk up start hopefully by second half of the year ]
Midfield is pretty much set as well with my locks being : Cripps|Murphy|Walsh|Williams|Setterfield|Ed - leaving: a whole bunch of blokes fighting over maybe 2 IC bench spots - I reckon Williamson| Fogarty|Newnes|Gibbons will be ahead of Dow|Stocker| and the younger brigade including Cottrell|Honey|Philp well behind and 'developing'
Will be interesting who gets first go in ruck - but have to say that TDK is a very exciting prospect - has gone past Dow/Lob/ in terms of on field AFL performances - already.
SOJ|Kennedy should be mentioned as fighting it out against McGovern for a third tall rotating mid option and as depth - SOJ would be starting 22 for sure IF he was a couple of meters faster and a better set shot kick - Kennedy's lack of leg speed sees him pretty much behind Setterfield and Ed as an on ball option - maybe ahead of SOJ because he is a better mark and kick as a forward option.
The Club has already stated that Kemp won't be rushed back into football and is being thought of as a defensive player to start with. He and Stocker are the most interesting grunters I will be watching for in '21 with a keen eye on progress - along with Honey.
If I was still living in Melbourne I'd probably be going to as many VFL games as possible - how good is it to have a Carlton VFL team to watch younger blokes develop in - fantastic.
The factor X this year will be how well the side can run out the longer quarters combined with fewer rotations - no doubt in my mind Russell has set up a physical prep program for normal length quarters - and not the shortened game that ended up being played in '20.
tldr?
The OP title is 'best rolling22' and I think Teague pretty much goes with who he had playing last year - adding Saad/Williams and probably Fogarty into the mix. I think the only question mark I have is wether Teague continues to favour a 2 ruck combo with both Pittonet and TDK in the side. Gibbons|Newman|Newnes are unlucky maybe - and Dow/Lob/Stocker are in the same boat as Kennedy for '21 - they have to start showing something sooner rather than later.
Round 1 rolling best 22:
Plowman Jones Marchbank ( for mine)
Docherty Weitering Saad
Murphy Cripps Walsh
TDK Ed Williams
Martin Harry Cuningham
McGovern Levi Eddie
IC: Setterfield Williamson Fisher Fogarty(?)
Hope you all had a great Xmas - we are busty being locked down in Manly atm.
by the end of the year ( injuries aside ) I woudl expect Charlie | Kemp to be in the side along with one of Stocker/Dow. Also wouldn't be surprised if Cuningham is more a mid than a forward by years end.
Can't really get my mind around Simmo not playing anymore.
- Nov 3, 2020
- 3,030
- 11,214
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Sandringham Zebras
Good stuff, personally would play SPS in front of Cunners. Seeing you don't have anyone fit for the defensive rotation on the bench (Willo as mentioned to play as a winger), SPS is vital for team structure and balance in my opinion. Otherwise all good.
- Jul 7, 2018
- 1,771
- 6,212
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Agreed. I see SPS in that last spot on the bench ahead of Fogarty but otherwise I see it pretty much the same.
Good to see such quality outside of the 22 pushing for spots. Hopefully with a meaningful reserves competition we’ll see blokes knocking on the door with strong performances every week.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
He’s tackling now is fairly ordinary, good as a youngster but it’s got worse as the career has gone on...
I remember when tackling was a bonus and for most players getting the ball and doing something with it was the most important attribute.
Elmer_Hauser
Celtics 8-2
Call me controversial, but I firmly believe that at this stage, there is room for both Pittonet and TDK.
I do not believe TDK has yet the physical attributes and endurance to be a full time Rickman, I like rotating him in the forward line too, he is a bloody workhorse, whose follow up work such as chasing/tackling etc, is simply wonderful.
And Pitto is far too good a player to waste in the VFL.
I do not believe TDK has yet the physical attributes and endurance to be a full time Rickman, I like rotating him in the forward line too, he is a bloody workhorse, whose follow up work such as chasing/tackling etc, is simply wonderful.
And Pitto is far too good a player to waste in the VFL.
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #300
"It's really not that difficult".
Similar threads
