List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

[Apex36]

Hawthorn literally had pick 14 already a couple of days ago and they traded it away. Who do they think they’re kidding saying they’re now offering what they got for pick 14 for a 1 pick upgrade

 

[TradeDraft]

If we don’t get Houston we keep Noble

 

[tmpies01]

I genuinely believe Port will let him decide between us and North if they believe both offers are fair. Let’s be honest their offer won’t be much different to ours…

 

[Pistol Night]

Exactly

This is exactly like the Carlton getting pick 14 situation

Twomey, Morris and others immediately jizzed their pants with excitement claiming Carlton were suddenly back in the game before they all actually took a breath and realised it changed absolutely nothing.

As upset as I am to lose Noble and Richards, those two have essentially sacrificed themselves to save Collingwood's trade period and National Draft.

Anyone who boos either of them next year don't deserve to support Collingwood

 

[Pistol Night]

I genuinely believe Port will let him decide between us and North if they believe both offers are fair. Let’s be honest their offer won’t be much different to ours…

Gee that’s a real conundrum for Dan. The G in front of massive crowds every week or Marvel and Tassie

 

[manicpie]

Exactly

This is exactly like the Carlton getting pick 14 situation

Twomey, Morris and others immediately jizzed their pants with excitement claiming Carlton were suddenly back in the game before they all actually took a breath and realised it changed absolutely nothing.

As upset as I am to lose Noble and Richards, those two have essentially sacrificed themselves to save Collingwood's trade period and National Draft.

Anyone who boos either of them next year don't deserve to support Collingwood

I don't boo anyone but I'll be grunting a lot when they leave and play for another club. We can't be thanking the collateral damage

 

[sr36]

Hawthorn literally had pick 14 already a couple of days ago and they traded it away. Who do they think they’re kidding saying they’re now offering what they got for pick 14 for a 1 pick upgrade

Hawks are planning on trading out and then in 13 times to eventually get it to pick 1.

 

[Hugg]

View attachment 2139959

North after pick nine from Essendon

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

I genuinely believe Port will let him decide between us and North if they believe both offers are fair. Let’s be honest their offer won’t be much different to ours…

Classic bet hedging

"Verdict: Likely to Collingwood"

Yeah, but not for a lack of you circus freaks coming up with all manner of scenarios to will a different club into existence.

I swear if we get him, I can't wait for September 27 next year

 

[Hugg]

North after pick nine from Essendon

The age front page

 

[josewales]

Can't see how these are better than our offer
(1) Melbourne F1 and pick 28 this year - so pick 28 substitutes for Noble and GC screw up deal - we won't take 28
(2) Sydney 19 & 20 - nice if GC were chasing multiple draft selections
(3) Dogs F1 - unders to everyone
(4) our F1 and Noble still the best deal as far as I can figure

 

[tmpies01]

Gee that’s a real conundrum for Dan. The G in front of massive crowds every week or Marvel and Tassie

The easiest decision in footy. I will feel so sorry for the bloke if he’s made to go to North. If he has any slight say in this, he will be a Pie.

 

[sr36]

Can't see how these are better than our offer
(1) Melbourne F1 and pick 28 this year - so pick 28 substitutes for Noble and GC screw up deal - we won't take 28
(2) Sydney 19 & 20 - nice if GC were chasing multiple draft selections
(3) Dogs F1 - unders to everyone
(4) our F1 and Noble still the best deal as far as I can figure

We're asking for 23 as well.

 

[Pistol Night]

Can't see how these are better than our offer
(1) Melbourne F1 and pick 28 this year - so pick 28 substitutes for Noble and GC screw up deal - we won't take 28
(2) Sydney 19 & 20 - nice if GC were chasing multiple draft selections
(3) Dogs F1 - unders to everyone
(4) our F1 and Noble still the best deal as far as I can figure

Plus it includes a player they actively want. it’s that simple the ambulance chasers in the media have overthought it worse than Stephen Hawking with anxiety

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

We're asking for 23 as well.

This is where I reckon we get Port directly involved and get them to offer a Future 2nd

Gold Coast wants picks/points for next year

 

[NMBB]

Geez those were the days.

Naughty but funny

 

[Pistol Night]

We're asking for 23 as well.

We’ll end up taking 29 and maybe a later swap

 

[tmpies01]

If all the other offers for 13 are so good like everyone is saying then why are we still in the race for it? I take it as a positive sign that we’re still in discussions with GC.

The threat of keeping Noble should be enough for them to hand it over.

 

[celestial]

Either all clubs have come to a preliminary agreement of an acceptable trade framework, or they have each decided to play chicken and are going to take this right down to the wire and see who blinks first.

 

[TradeDraft]

Can't see how these are better than our offer
(1) Melbourne F1 and pick 28 this year - so pick 28 substitutes for Noble and GC screw up deal - we won't take 28
(2) Sydney 19 & 20 - nice if GC were chasing multiple draft selections
(3) Dogs F1 - unders to everyone
(4) our F1 and Noble still the best deal as far as I can figure

Dan might change his mind and Nominate North

 

[Pistol Night]

If all the other offers for 13 are so good like everyone is saying then why are we still in the race for it? I take it as a positive sign that we’re still in discussions with GC.

The threat of keeping Noble should be enough for them to hand it over.

Because the clubs aren’t hyperventilating knob jockeys like all these journos

 

[sr36]

This is where I reckon we get Port directly involved and get them to offer a Future 2nd

Gold Coast wants picks/points for next year

THey need points for this year too - Richmond traded a heap of theirs away to get Brisbane's pick.

 

[Pistol Night]

Either all clubs have come to a preliminary agreement of an acceptable trade framework, or they have each decided to play chicken and are going to take this right down to the wire and see who blinks first.

Leppa should propose rock, paper scissors for pick 23

 

[VinnieB]

They rated him year 1. Gave him an additional 2 years and a debut.

I wouldn't be discounting the big concussion he had in his debut. Mustn't be easy to just shrug off concussion when surrounded by the Murphy concussion saga

Sorry, I might be talking about the wrong guy. I was talking about AJ.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

THey need points for this year too - Richmond traded a heap of theirs away to get Brisbane's pick.

Well if that's the case then it seems even more straight forward

We give Noble, F1 and 36 for 13 and either 23 or 29