Perceived spuds at your club who get a game

[Jako Darling]

Wellingham...apart from our last game. With that stupid sprout looking ponytail rubberband in a grown mans hair thing he has going on...#noidea

He's had an outstanding year. Get off it.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Naitanui - only jumps good

Doesn't find enough of the pill and goes missing for the majority of the game and doesn't influence the match aside from the occasional highlight

And we are bloody stuck with him for another 4 years

 

[Schauermann]

Naitanui - only jumps good

Doesn't find enough of the pill and goes missing for the majority of the game and doesn't influence the match aside from the occasional highlight

And we are bloody stuck with him for another 4 years

He also takes a mark or two. In some games...

 

[The Falcon Strike]

He also takes a mark or two. In some games...

Sure he takes the odd speccy- but 2 or 3 speccies doesn't make you a great player

Needs to learn the game

 

[Toump Ass]

I know he is big, but apart from size Dawes just brings nothing to a game of footy. Whenever I watch you guys he just frustrates me no end. So many times he nearly gets it or kind of makes a half hearted effort pretending to go for the ball. Just leaves me feeling deflated and shaking my head.

Disagree with the bolded. Effort is always there, he's just shit.

 

[BlakeyNoFlakey]

Kersten has been given a spud rating during the 2015 season by Geelong fans. In 2014, there were many who considered Blicavs a spud.

 

[Gongswan]

Heath Grundy
Ted Richards
Dane Rampe
Lewis Jetta, not any more
Keiran Jack
Gary Rohan
Craig Bird
Kurt Tippett

 

[Gongswan]

Billie Smedts

Compared to hte rest of teh potatoes at Carlton, yes. Pretty sure we would have liked to keep him, but how much opportunity was rthere for him at Sydney

 

[Superstar swan]

Tom derickx is the worst footballer to ever make it onto a list....let alone score a 3 year deal from a top4 team!!!

 

[Silvagnis]

Players who have been getting games for a fair while but in reality are holding us back:

Armfield (even though I do love his work ethic, just kicking can let him down)
Ellard
Warnock
Rowe
White

Terrible post. We need to hand out 38 contracts every year. Garlett, Robinson and Waite aren't as committed as four of these players. More talented, but that only takes you so far. Look at Langford, Puopolo and Spangher who have played in a flag. Schoenmakers got a game in a prelim. They'd be spuds at Carlton in the last two seasons. A team is greater than the sum of it's parts.

Clubs wants Henderson and Yarran who are more talented, yet they won't trade for them...

 

[Doctor Feel]

Matthew Suckling. People are finally starting to see this guy's kicking for what it is....an absolute and utter myth.

Combine that with the fact that this putrid muppet has no other weapons in his football arsenal whatsoever and you have one massive potato.

lold.

 

[ioppolo]

Tom derickx is the worst footballer to ever make it onto a list....let alone score a 3 year deal from a top4 team!!!

For his name alone I assume.

 

[underthestars]

Nic Suban
Matt de boer
Danyle Pearce
Zac Clarke
Zac Dawson
Chris May...
oh hold on. At my club?
well...actually no one since Lyon left. Many before. Coincidence perhaps?

 

[master bate]

Terrible post. We need to hand out 38 contracts every year. Garlett, Robinson and Waite aren't as committed as four of these players. More talented, but that only takes you so far. Look at Langford, Puopolo and Spangher who have played in a flag. Schoenmakers got a game in a prelim. They'd be spuds at Carlton in the last two seasons. A team is greater than the sum of it's parts.

Clubs wants Henderson and Yarran who are more talented, yet they won't trade for them...

I'll give you Armfield, Rowe and White. Good soldiers. Capable of taking the knocks whilst the youngsters come through. But Ellard and Warnock, no thanks. Ellard should've retired years ago and Warnock lacks talent and heart.

People will trade for Henderson and Yarran they just don't want to give up too much!