GiantForce
Club Legend
- Apr 24, 2011
- 1,314
- 4
- AFL Club
- GWS
The question is whether the extra $$$ you'll have to pay for Tyson/Coniglio is worth it instead of going Shiel and Treloar.
This situation differs from the Gold Coast where early in the pre season (This situation changed quickly after a few pre season games) it was talked about going guys like Lock/Weller over Swallow. However we knew back then that Lock/Weller weren't at the pointy end of the draft if eligible (Unlike Shiel/Treloar. Shiel would be a Top 3 pick this year and Treloar pushing Top 5). Not to mention the likely hike in prices all round + a likely higher premium on these high picks. Last year we were looking at a difference of around 60K between the high pick and the kids who had already been at the Gold Coast a year, but for that extra 60K, you got a whole lot more points. This year though, Shiel and Treloar could easily outscore Tyson, Coniglio, and going of Fanplanner, they'd be ALOT cheaper (70-100K)
This situation differs from the Gold Coast where early in the pre season (This situation changed quickly after a few pre season games) it was talked about going guys like Lock/Weller over Swallow. However we knew back then that Lock/Weller weren't at the pointy end of the draft if eligible (Unlike Shiel/Treloar. Shiel would be a Top 3 pick this year and Treloar pushing Top 5). Not to mention the likely hike in prices all round + a likely higher premium on these high picks. Last year we were looking at a difference of around 60K between the high pick and the kids who had already been at the Gold Coast a year, but for that extra 60K, you got a whole lot more points. This year though, Shiel and Treloar could easily outscore Tyson, Coniglio, and going of Fanplanner, they'd be ALOT cheaper (70-100K)