Player Comparison Thread - Part 3
- Thread starter SELFCONFESDAFLNERD
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Very interesting.
Not sold on Haynes and his soft tissue injuries to be honest.
Kornes would be the solid safe option.
but Lewis
Very interesting one for me as ive also been researching him a bit this week as well. I think he could average 10ppg more than Kornes..
What sticks out for me is that from just watching him play, he is a gut runnerwhich holds him in good stead for DT. Gets involved with play mostly forward of the ball so is a chance for a goal a game. Also is one of those guys that will break wide and take the +6 on the wing. If I was a bit behind the pack ranking wise I would go with Lewis
Not sold on Haynes and his soft tissue injuries to be honest.
Kornes would be the solid safe option.
but Lewis
Very interesting one for me as ive also been researching him a bit this week as well. I think he could average 10ppg more than Kornes..
What sticks out for me is that from just watching him play, he is a gut runnerwhich holds him in good stead for DT. Gets involved with play mostly forward of the ball so is a chance for a goal a game. Also is one of those guys that will break wide and take the +6 on the wing. If I was a bit behind the pack ranking wise I would go with Lewis
I highly, highly doubt it.
Loud Eagle
Senior List
I doubt he could average 10 more than kane...... and anyway lewis is bound to miss at least 4 games through injury /suspension compared to kane who hasnt missed a game in like 5 seasons and hasnt averaged less than 90 in like 4 years so even if lewis did average more he probibly wouldnt have as high total points scored.
Averaging 95 thus far. 95 plus is easily achieved by him, which makes him a good choice (particularly when you include his durability).
Having trouble deciding between Lockyer or Enright.
I already have quite a few Geelong players in my team, so am a bit reluctant to add another. Lockyer is averaging more, but this is due to him having a few really good games around the start of the season.
I already have quite a few Geelong players in my team, so am a bit reluctant to add another. Lockyer is averaging more, but this is due to him having a few really good games around the start of the season.
You can never have too many Geelong players
rich to hayes or bartel??
Riewoldt or Stevie J?
- Mar 20, 2007
- 30,098
- 28,433
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Will probably be answering the same question myself
But being the tightass for cash i am, will go SJ
But being the tightass for cash i am, will go SJ
- Banned
- #542
Lenny Hayes or Joel Corey? I was going to make an upgrade before the Lockout but I just figured whatever, I should still be able to get either of them easily.
i dont think you can go wrong with either of them , but i would go corey just because he is durable and you know what you are getting were as hayes is more injury prone but is having a boss last 10 weeks so..... flip a coin.
- Banned
- #544
Appreciate the feedback. Was having trouble on this because I know Corey is durable and his scoring is very reliable, not to mention, I don't have too many Geelong players. I plan on doing this trade later on however.
The one I'm badly thinking of now is who's the best forward on the market? After Didak's huge 156 against Freo I'm very tempted to get my hands on him but I'm not entirely sure. I definitely could get him if I downgraded Warren and upgraded Thomas but he's only been scoring massive 140s with Collingwood's ball magnet Pendlebury out. Didak's probably going to start getting tagged as well so I'm not sure about Didak. If I don't get him in the end, I'll probably get Riewoldt for consistancy but I guess it all depends on what goes on at the end of the round.
Didak vs Riewoldt vs SJ vs ROK
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
Want to bring in Hayes next week, was going to upgrade Beams, which meant i was starting Foley and having Anthony on the bench.
Thinking now of upgrading Foley and starting Anthony
Ultimately the decision will be - assuming both play - who would score more
Anthony or Foley?
Thinking now of upgrading Foley and starting Anthony
Ultimately the decision will be - assuming both play - who would score more
Anthony or Foley?
I'd go Cornes.
I have Goddard, Lockyer, Hodge, Cornes & Drummond
I need one more back to replace Adock.
I don't really care about price, I just want the player who will average the highest especially in the last four weeks.
Was looking at (in order of preference ATM): Duffield, Fisher, Enright, Bock, Hargrave
Was originally keen on Enright but I don't really like Geelongs draw over finals. I want more StKilda players and like the look of Fisher but he has been below par this year and I'm not overly convinced...
Any thoughts?
fisher, duffield or enright are all good options. fisher looks to have hit some form, and with maxy hugdhton coming back it might free him up even more. id be leaning towards fisher.
SandyMcManus
Team Captain
Getting rid of Adcock... 5 trades left and 83K but I want to keep my money for an upgrade to Hayes next week. Wondering who to grab out of Lockyer, Ryder, Cornes etc.. Tough decision
I have Goddard/Fisher/Enright/Scotland/Grimes/Broughton and want to replace Jed..
I have Goddard/Fisher/Enright/Scotland/Grimes/Broughton and want to replace Jed..
makingmemark
Team Captain
Jesus, that has really got me thinking about Chornes.
I traded him out at Rd11 and hate trading someone back in.
But he's only 308K, which is the 4th highest average of a defender and third if you take out Bowden.
He's had his surgery, how's his body now?? Risk v Reward again!
I traded him out at Rd11 and hate trading someone back in.
But he's only 308K, which is the 4th highest average of a defender and third if you take out Bowden.
He's had his surgery, how's his body now?? Risk v Reward again!
