Player Comparison Thread - Part 3
- Thread starter SELFCONFESDAFLNERD
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Not sure about pav just because he is playing in Freo and they might tank (NO THEY WOULD NEVER. No one tanks in the AFL, it is not and issueSJ, or pav if your looking for value (which your not)
) but either than that baring injury i dont think i really makes a differance who i pick?
I would almost just pick ROK, if money and value is not an issue.
Not sure about pav just because he is playing in Freo and they might tank (NO THEY WOULD NEVER. No one tanks in the AFL, it is not and issue
i have no doubt freo along with west coast and melbourne will be tanking in the next few rounds but what does that have to do with pavlichs scores.
doubt it, theres way of tanking than rather than resting players. Strategic moves such as putting kids on superstars and so on. dont think pavlich will miss another game this year unless actually injured.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
Jolly or Sandi - depending on my trading strategy - money isn't an issue
I know Sandi is averaging more - but his rd 22 game against Geelong scares as his track record at KP is poor
I know Sandi is averaging more - but his rd 22 game against Geelong scares as his track record at KP is poor
- Banned
- #560
Any answers, people? This is my biggest decision in Dream Team yet.
Taylor
Community Leader
- Moderator
- #561
I don't know about Medhurst, I get the feeling that you're giving up a bit there to pick up Ablett or Montagna and I don't subscribe to the idea that as long as the total points work out then you're onto a winner, I think both selections need to warrant their worth. So I'd go Lenny Hayes if it allows you to pick Rioli and not think of it the other way around.
Medhurst was injured at the start of the year wasn't he? Hasn't been in the team a whole lot, and you want to bring that into your dream team. He could be a liability.
Then again, he could explode into premium form as his team step up into the top four.
Medhurst was injured at the start of the year wasn't he? Hasn't been in the team a whole lot, and you want to bring that into your dream team. He could be a liability.
Then again, he could explode into premium form as his team step up into the top four.
out of those three probably stokes. he was averaging high 90's up until round 10 when he was dropped/injured. Just dont think medders has it in him this year and cyril could also be a good option but hasnt really fired since coming back from injury yet.
so stokes just in front of cyril.
- Banned
- #563
Eesh, the trade button is right infront of my eyes with Stokes but I simply can't click. Stokes scored only 67 while Cyril scored a nice 90 this week. I have a feeling Cyril has fired up while I think Stokes could go anywhere. Not to mention, I'm not entirely sure on Stokes' job security.
outofthegloom
Senior List
Go with your gut then!
crooklyn dodgers. m'k?
Draftee
what are people's thoughts on the best pick up out of these cheap forwards playing this weekend:
nick salter (PA) - 122k (listed in the 25)
callum wilson (WCE) - 75.3k
james sellar (Adel) - 106.5k
tom rockliff (Bris) - 106.6k
michael walters (Fre) - 86.6k
i'm trying to downgrade higgins to make way for gablett. cheers
nick salter (PA) - 122k (listed in the 25)
callum wilson (WCE) - 75.3k
james sellar (Adel) - 106.5k
tom rockliff (Bris) - 106.6k
michael walters (Fre) - 86.6k
i'm trying to downgrade higgins to make way for gablett. cheers
Crooklyn Dodgers. None appear to present much to me personally.
I think any of them could be dropped at any times.
Lower sides probably more secure so the likes of Salter, Wilson or Walters would be my first imo.
GrandBlue - Im not sold on any of those 3. Id prefer a Pavlich/Didak/Goodwin/Franklin etc why are you trading in one of those 3? they seem to be very low end keepers IMO and at this stage I would only look to trade in some strong keepers.
I think any of them could be dropped at any times.
Lower sides probably more secure so the likes of Salter, Wilson or Walters would be my first imo.
GrandBlue - Im not sold on any of those 3. Id prefer a Pavlich/Didak/Goodwin/Franklin etc why are you trading in one of those 3? they seem to be very low end keepers IMO and at this stage I would only look to trade in some strong keepers.
- Banned
- #567
I already have Pavlich and Buddy. I needed to make a big downgrade in order for me to do the Rich -> Hayes trade and in the end, I got Cyril. I know it might turn out to be a bad descision but I just wasn't sold on having Rich as a keeper and I've been wanting Hayes all year. Alternativey, I could have gone Higgins -> SJ or anyone below 417k but at least now, I have a complete team.
...Oh dear... This is my first year DTing so I have a lot to learn and I just realized I could have done Higgins -> Goodwin and Rich -> S.Thompson or something. I should never let greed blind me again.
fatmungus
Senior List
- Feb 19, 2009
- 209
- 0
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Looking at Sandilans or M. Clark as a replacement for Cox.
Sandilands has:
Port Melb Essendon Geelong
Clark has:
Essendon Bulldogs Port Swans (Jolly)
I would go clark due to his from but him vs. Jolly in the final is
. Sandilands has an easier run home but freo vs. Cats in final also .
So hard. So so hard.
Sandilands has:
Port Melb Essendon Geelong
Clark has:
Essendon Bulldogs Port Swans (Jolly)
I would go clark due to his from but him vs. Jolly in the final is
. Sandilands has an easier run home but freo vs. Cats in final also .So hard. So so hard.
Looking at Sandilans or M. Clark as a replacement for Cox.
Sandilands has:
Port Melb Essendon Geelong
Clark has:
Essendon Bulldogs Port Swans (Jolly)
I would go clark due to his from but him vs. Jolly in the final is
So hard. So so hard.
Sandi pants dominates Geelong, scored a 120+ against them last year and 110 agaisnt them this year, and a 65 in between which was probably when Ottens was playing.
Both are in dominating form so i think both will score well for you but personally i think sandilands as he has the easier run home as you said.
Jay van Berlo v Leigh Adams
Need to downgrade Sidebottom. Who will play more games?
It's a tough one. I haven't a clue really. VB is rookie priced which will help with an upgrade next week.
Need to downgrade Sidebottom. Who will play more games?
It's a tough one. I haven't a clue really. VB is rookie priced which will help with an upgrade next week.
iluvparis
Import Whisperer
- Apr 1, 2005
- 50,055
- 40,654
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Calgary Flames, Man Utd
Pav then - SJ more likely to be 'rested'
All good options all have hit form of late, its a really tough decision i am in the same situation. Ive decided to go Didak, had a look at the run homes/averages against opponents and so on and it still evened out everywhere. So went with the gut in the end. Mind you I already have BJ and Harvey.
The only thing worrying me off Didak is the tags that he has been receiving, added with the fact that his past 2 scores have mostly come out of junk time..
