Player Comparison Thread - Part 3
- Thread starter SELFCONFESDAFLNERD
- Start date
- Tagged users None
force65
Team Captain
pav....he is more consistent and therefore less likely to fall in price meaning that it will be harder to pick him up in the later stages
although pav has been injured so might start slow
Bock v Lockyer
Can't see Bock playing forward much this year, but I'm also not sure whether or not Lockyer will return to his high-scoring, marking linkup role. Lockyer has more upside and has durability on his side, which is tempting.
Can't see Bock playing forward much this year, but I'm also not sure whether or not Lockyer will return to his high-scoring, marking linkup role. Lockyer has more upside and has durability on his side, which is tempting.
O'Keefe, bit more consistent. Brown had 3 scores under 40 last year.
Still tinkering with my fwd line so...
Skipworth vs. Lucas
and
Hentschell vs Krakouer
Thoughts please
I don't have faith in Lockyer's ability to return to his 100 avg of 07 and see both players probably finishing the season on par. This won't mean much to those who are going for the overall prize, but those only concentrating on the league, I believe Bock might be a more consistent player week in week out, whereas Lockyer might give you the odd big score followed by a significantly lower score. Bock's durability over the past 2 seasons is very good.
I have the same problem as you at the moment! I decided to go with Franklin just because he is an absolute gun. i disagree that pav wont go down in money as usually his first 5 or so rounds are pretty slow. I think that Franklin may struggle against Geelong except he will bounce back when the hawks play the swannies
not looking forward to that game as a swans supporter!
- Feb 28, 2009
- 37,699
- 34,892
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Atletico
J Riewoldt + Goodwin + 32k
or
N Krakouer + Deledio + 59k
or
J Riewoldt + SJohnson/N Brown + 20k
The extra cash in the second option would probably go to upgrading Drummond to someone around the 350-380k price, otherwise it would be spare cash
or
N Krakouer + Deledio + 59k
or
J Riewoldt + SJohnson/N Brown + 20k
The extra cash in the second option would probably go to upgrading Drummond to someone around the 350-380k price, otherwise it would be spare cash
Dalziell, Gibbs, Wells, Dale Thomas
VS
Kornes, Swan, Mackay, O'Keefe
VS
Kornes, Dalziell, Mackay, Any fwd under 420k (Didak, Gian, S Johnson, Chapman)
Keep in mind Wells and Mackay are the 5th midfielder.
Hadn't changed my team from option 1 until i saw maybe my 5th midfielder could be a player whose going to get a bit of cash like Mackay.
VS
Kornes, Swan, Mackay, O'Keefe
VS
Kornes, Dalziell, Mackay, Any fwd under 420k (Didak, Gian, S Johnson, Chapman)
Keep in mind Wells and Mackay are the 5th midfielder.
Hadn't changed my team from option 1 until i saw maybe my 5th midfielder could be a player whose going to get a bit of cash like Mackay.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Adam, I'd go option 2, but with Gibbs instead of Swan and a premium forward instead of O'Keefe.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
2nd option IMO.
Definitely 2nd option. Even if it was the most expensive one I'd say 2nd option.
chrisknights
Senior List
Suban vs Broughton for ruck reserve, are either a lock for freo
- Oct 9, 2003
- 47,001
- 46,220
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Eagles (NFL), Suns (NBA)
Backs: Any 2 out of Milburn, PBurgoyne, Lockyer. I have the first 2 in at the moment
Forwards: Any 2 out of Pav, Chappy, Goodwin. I have the first 2 in at the moment.
Forwards: Any 2 out of Pav, Chappy, Goodwin. I have the first 2 in at the moment.
- Oct 9, 2003
- 47,001
- 46,220
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Eagles (NFL), Suns (NBA)
ROK and Cok for me.
Thanks. Mackay safe to keep his spot at Adelaide?
I can also do
Gablett, Gibbs, Mackay, O'Keefe with an extra 10 grand left
VS
Dalziell, Gibbs, Wells, Dale Thomas
VS
Kornes, Gibbs, Mackay, Premium Fwd
The Gablett option is good considering i don't know which premium fwd i would choose out of Didak, Giansiracusa, S Johnson, Harvey and Chapman. I can't see them being so much better than O'Keefe.
Dalziell, Wells, Gibbs and Dale Thomas? Any reasoning?
I'm so split on these ones and found if i did the option of Gablett, Gibbs, Mackay and O'Keefe
I have enough cash to make Joel Selwood to Dalziell.
GoNickGill
Debutant
Hey I'm tossing up between Ziebell vs Hentschel, what do ppl reckon?
Also, I was going to pick 2 of Anthony/Beams/Robinson for my midfield bench, who do you think are more likely?
Also, I was going to pick 2 of Anthony/Beams/Robinson for my midfield bench, who do you think are more likely?
As people have wrote before, Hentschel if hes on the field for you, Ziebell if its for the bench.
Baring injuries, Ziebell will score more but Hentschels spot in the side is safer (Can't forget the Laidley factor!)
I have gone for Anthony and Robinson, sold on Anthony (Despite the Laidley factor) but not sure on Robinson VS Beams. Collingwoods best 22 does not have Beams in it whilst Robinson has a better chance of squeezin in.
Caught red handed stormer!
Ok so i had a fair bit of money on the bench but if i get rid of it
I had -
Tom collier in backs to cover Hill, raines
Hentschel in forwards to cover Yarran, Skipworth.
Now -
Suban in backs
Brown in forwards.
The second option has allowed me to go. Gibbs => Kornes, Lovett => Gia
Strong cover + Gibbs + Lovett v Av cover + Kornes + Gia.
I had -
Tom collier in backs to cover Hill, raines
Hentschel in forwards to cover Yarran, Skipworth.
Now -
Suban in backs
Brown in forwards.
The second option has allowed me to go. Gibbs => Kornes, Lovett => Gia
Strong cover + Gibbs + Lovett v Av cover + Kornes + Gia.
chrisknights
Senior List
Suban vs Broughton for ruck reserve, are either a lock for freo
