-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X or Player Y (Part 3)
- Thread starter Lakey91
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Oct 16, 2008
- 10,658
- 6,375
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Went with Pav CP. Was happy with the 92, especially when he was on 33 at half time.
Pretty sure he's the one I'll go with, just wish Hargraves could show somethng... ANYTHING to make me think that he is worth bringing into my side
- Oct 16, 2008
- 10,658
- 6,375
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Who to get as a cash cow, Pods or Rocky?
- Oct 16, 2008
- 10,658
- 6,375
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Haha, in the perfect world i would, but while Gumby is getting a game every week it would be a pointless trade.
ShowdownDomination
Senior List
Looking for a bit of cash, should I downgrade Ballantyne or Hall?
duff_man41
Rookie
I'd downgrade hall i recon balla has got alot of upside this year, hall will peak at about 305 i'd trade him then.
I'm ugrading who should i go too judd, hayes, selwood or anthony?
I'm ugrading who should i go too judd, hayes, selwood or anthony?
Downgrading one of Hall or Dangerfield to Pods this week.
Who should I go? I was thinking Hall as he doesn't look like getting past 60 but Dangerfield has been pretty poor the last couple of weeks too.
Who should I go? I was thinking Hall as he doesn't look like getting past 60 but Dangerfield has been pretty poor the last couple of weeks too.
- Banned
- #785
Honestly, flip a coin mate. Barry should clean up against teams with weak backlines so do your research.
Jarred Brennan or Dale Thomas?
Jarred Brennan or Dale Thomas?
Papa Juggs
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #786
I will not trade Barry.
Consider him a midprice special even while scoring 50s as he has already cracked a ton.
One interesting stat to consider is the maggots (umps) have not seen fit to give Barry a single free kick all year. Maybe everybody is playing squeaky clean on him and he's not had so much as a finger in the back all year but somehow I doubt that.
Consider him a midprice special even while scoring 50s as he has already cracked a ton.
One interesting stat to consider is the maggots (umps) have not seen fit to give Barry a single free kick all year. Maybe everybody is playing squeaky clean on him and he's not had so much as a finger in the back all year but somehow I doubt that.
chopperduck
Brownlow Medallist
I dont think he has had a lot of the ball to get any free kicks. The only time he got a lot was when he scored his 100 and that was a 4th qtr special as the dogs were running all over the other team and kicking it right onto Hall's chest when he had a couple of meters seperation on his opponent.
- Sep 26, 2004
- 47,775
- 64,715
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #788
Mayne vs Dangerfield as a downgrade to Rockliff.
Mayne has lower scoring potential than Danger but he also has a lower B/E. Mayne may reach his B/E as it is around his average but Dangerfield's is around 100 which he will struggle to reach.
Definitely trading 1 of them.....the question is which one?
Mayne has lower scoring potential than Danger but he also has a lower B/E. Mayne may reach his B/E as it is around his average but Dangerfield's is around 100 which he will struggle to reach.
Definitely trading 1 of them.....the question is which one?
I could be wrong but isnt Podsially going to be put back onto Geelonsg Rookie list once Mitch Brown recovers from his broken leg, meaning that he will not be able to play?
stoja
Team Captain
looking to trade wright for one of rockliffe or pods
already have hitchcock and gumby
is this worthy of a trade?????????????????????????
already have hitchcock and gumby
is this worthy of a trade?????????????????????????
Motlop on LTI will fix that Main Man... And by round 11 I believe they could choose to permanently elevate him...
Someone who knows for sure could confirm this.
Someone who knows for sure could confirm this.
pillager
Club Legend
Correct!
duff_man41
Rookie
Judd, Sewlood or Hayes?
Hayes. Selwood's struggling with the #1 tag and Hayes is simply a better DTer then Judd.
Brennan IMO. He's flourishing as a permanent mid.
Which two of Vince, Hayes, Mitchell and Gibbs?
Any of the last 3 imo.
Mine is Martin/Chappy vs (Mitchell/KornesCorey/Hayes)/Balla vs don't do anything
duff_man41
Rookie
i dont think id get martin now, he isnt getting enough of the pill, so id go the second option but i think chapman is a good option if his hammy's can hold up. Hayes and Corey have the most upside, as they have had major price drops, but do you think hayes age will start to affect his dt scores, and they will start to rest him a bit more to protect his health?
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
gibbs or hayes?
getting rid of ball and have up to 427k to spend. these 2 look the better prospects that i could see as there both great premiums but not a lot seperates them. thoughts?
getting rid of ball and have up to 427k to spend. these 2 look the better prospects that i could see as there both great premiums but not a lot seperates them. thoughts?
Papa Juggs
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #800
Why are people getting rid of ball???
What was your strategy????
If he doesn't get 100 every week in the first 4 games you need to waste a trade???
I had Kade Simpson last year and traded him off early because he scored a 60. He came out the next week and scored 130.
Don't jump the gun. He can still go up more in value I reckon.
What was your strategy????
If he doesn't get 100 every week in the first 4 games you need to waste a trade???
I had Kade Simpson last year and traded him off early because he scored a 60. He came out the next week and scored 130.
Don't jump the gun. He can still go up more in value I reckon.
- Status
