I'd pick these two only becuase we know how good they can be.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X or Player Y (Part 3)
- Thread starter Lakey91
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I'd pick these two only becuase we know how good they can be.
Thats a fairly tough choice.
I like Ball, however Ziebell and Medhurst worry me a bit, just as much as both Harvey and Higgins durability.
Ball should play 22 games and a young Ziebell should also barring injury. I think i would go with that combination. Have you considerd Sam Wright or Barry Hall? Both real prospects
Dimitri_Mishkin
Team Captain
You have the best name ever
TheStinger
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 23, 2009
- 12,748
- 1,352
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Penguins, Aston Villa, Adel Utd.
It is the way I was leaning. Just a bit worried about McVeigh's health and Kerr's brain explosions.
Whats wrong with Mcveigh's health? I think he is really on the right track
I've already got Bazza and I really don't know enough about Wright. Is he someone that will play the full 22 games?
TheStinger
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 23, 2009
- 12,748
- 1,352
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Penguins, Aston Villa, Adel Utd.
Last year was a disaster for him, injury wise.
Plus he is suspended round 1.
Last year he was mentally unable to cope with the pressure after his mishap. I think he is more focused and motivated this year, coming with a vengance so i don't see a worry for his health. His injuries really came after his disgression which really roughed up his confidence.
He is great price and ill be damned if he isn't worth the risk
- Feb 15, 2010
- 292
- 1
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Banned
- #260
for those of you whinin over the back line here is the perfect backline
grimes
broughton
duffield
hodge
mackie
kennelly
waters
mcguire
nason
won't break the bank, u have 5/7 "keepers" with kennelly and waters both potentially 80 point ave players.
no goddard, he will go down, not up in price.
no enright. he has never scored ave 100 or over, his nab challenge was lucky.
duffield/broughton: both 95-100 point players this year. both showed they are playing even better than last year.
hodge and mackie and grimes: grimes is a gun will get +99, hodge and mackie are both well priced and veterans and get the job done.
grimes
broughton
duffield
hodge
mackie
kennelly
waters
mcguire
nason
won't break the bank, u have 5/7 "keepers" with kennelly and waters both potentially 80 point ave players.
no goddard, he will go down, not up in price.
no enright. he has never scored ave 100 or over, his nab challenge was lucky.
duffield/broughton: both 95-100 point players this year. both showed they are playing even better than last year.
hodge and mackie and grimes: grimes is a gun will get +99, hodge and mackie are both well priced and veterans and get the job done.
I would go with ball and medhurst both playing in a likely top four side.
Selwood has had a ripper pre season though.
Mine is:
Ball vs Andrew Walker (+45k)
Walker should get early games and if over his injury from last year should have a great yr going on pre season form. Ball is a bit more expensive and will play 22 for the yr and has also had a good pre season.
Ball. For sure.
ROK hands down for me.
Out of the other two, they are both very similar scoring DT players and have the tendency to become a little inconsistent, for this reason i'd personally stear clear. But if it came down to it, i'd go Gilbee for the pure fact he plays for the Doggies who are going to explode this year.
Hall +$73,000 or Franklin?
oohaahmarklecras
Senior List
hey guys just a quick one
hargrave vs. r.shaw vs. carrazzo
thanks
hargrave vs. r.shaw vs. carrazzo
thanks
Hargrave for me on that one......others will let you down....
Masten OR Trengove + 140k???? - for 4th mid spot (should average somewhere similar)
When i put it that way its almost silly to get masten, right??? - hmm, do i starting 3 rookies in mids...... it sure solidifys whole other team (140k helps)
thoughts please,
Masten OR Trengove + 140k???? - for 4th mid spot (should average somewhere similar)
When i put it that way its almost silly to get masten, right??? - hmm, do i starting 3 rookies in mids...... it sure solidifys whole other team (140k helps
)thoughts please,
SORRY IF THIS HAS BEEN DONE!
Hille or Naitainui
Hille or Naitainui
oohaahmarklecras
Senior List
Hargrave for me on that one......others will let you down....
Masten OR Trengove + 140k???? - for 4th mid spot (should average somewhere similar)
When i put it that way its almost silly to get masten, right??? - hmm, do i starting 3 rookies in mids...... it sure solidifys whole other team (140k helps
thoughts please,
thanks
im in the exact same position and i have no idea! i dont like the thought of having 3 rookie mids, its just too much for me... but that 140k means i can get rid of kennelly or get an extra premo forward or back!
i guess you gotta weigh up is it worth paying 140k more for masten who has better job securuty and is more experienced, which really is the only difference.
sorry that wasnt very decisive, im still unsure myself
thanks
im in the exact same position and i have no idea! i dont like the thought of having 3 rookie mids, its just too much for me... but that 140k means i can get rid of kennelly or get an extra premo forward or back!
i guess you gotta weigh up is it worth paying 140k more for masten who has better job securuty and is more experienced, which really is the only difference.
sorry that wasnt very decisive, im still unsure myself
In the exact situation as you!!! - pretty funny (im sure thousands others are too)
Trengove must have job security + best 22 status!!! - just imagining rd 1 trengove scoring same as masten or even worse more - whatta waste of 140k
- what to do, ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh?anyone....
In the exact situation as you!!! - pretty funny (im sure thousands others are too)
Trengove must have job security + best 22 status!!! - just imagining rd 1 trengove scoring same as masten or even worse more - whatta waste of 140k
anyone....
seriously considering
masten > scully as i already have trengove and martin starting...this would free up a lot of cash..
ziebell > pav possibly
One which i cant decide on...
NicNat or Hille
RedFeather
Senior List
J. Brown/Sylvia & Kennelly vs Dangerfield & R. Shaw
I'd go Hille. Will play a bit of ruck and full-forward this year.
I'd go Hille. Will play a bit of ruck and full-forward this year.
Sandilands + Ziebell vs Tippet + Giansiracusa/Harvey/Higgins
Can't go wrong with either but I'd go for Boyd.
- Status
