Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[Headless]

Tough one re: Stanton and Watson. What's the rest of your midfield like? I would go with Stanton probably, but only just! I had Watson last year, and he never let me down. Played some really good quarters, especially.

Here is my midfield and forward line:

C: Ablett; Dal Santo; (SPACE); Trengove; Martin; Barlow (Shuey; Bastinac)
F: Riewoldt; O'Keefe; Gray; Tippett; Hall; Dangerfield; (SPACE) (Hitchcock; Gumbleton)

So my question is this:

Luke Ball and Relton Roberts (starting), or:
Mitch Robinson and Ben Warren?

Thanks!

 

[Spudregus_87]

First option by the length of the Flemington.

Westhoff (PA) or Rockliff?

Rockliff

One last decision to make

Stanton $507 (Huge NAB Challenge scores including a 195)

or

Watson $540 (consistant scores of 100)

Watson. Stanton Always produces big NAB Cup scores. Jobe will step up with the captaincy this year.



Vince and LeCras
or
Selwood and Ziebell (and $75k)???

 

[Spudregus_87]

Tough one re: Stanton and Watson. What's the rest of your midfield like? I would go with Stanton probably, but only just!

Here is my midfield and forward line:

C: Ablett; Dal Santo; (SPACE); Trengove; Martin; Barlow (Shuey; Bastinac)
F: Riewoldt; O'Keefe; Gray; Tippett; Hall; Dangerfield; (SPACE) (Hitchcock; Gumbleton)

So my question is this:

Luke Ball and Relton Roberts (starting), or:
Mitch Robinson and Ben Warren?

Thanks!

Can you go with Ball and Rockliff? That would be my choice...

 

[Headless]

That I can. I'm not sold on Rockliff, though. I'm also a pretty big fan of Robinson. With Rockliff not playing, it would mean that I would have to start Hitchcock or Gumbleton..

 

[zan5hin]

Goddard and Gram or Goodwin and Shaw?

 

[hellfire]

Tough. I think Goddard is a must, but don't like Gram for SC. Shaw is set for a big year, Goodwin on the decline though? I might lean marginally to option one, because Goddard is a captain option.

Sandilands + Franklin

vs.

Kreuzer + Pavlich + a little bit of cash.

Even though Buddy is missing R1.

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Buddy & Sandi. Who's your back up for Buddy?

P. Burgoyne V Trengove?

 

[PunchFromBhind]

suban or raines

 

[hellfire]

Buddy & Sandi. Who's your back up for Buddy?

P. Burgoyne V Trengove?

Gumbleton or Hitchcock at this stage, not too fussed though, not really going for the money just a league win.

Didn't Burgoyne retire? Or do you mean Shaun?

 

[zan5hin]

Tough. I think Goddard is a must, but don't like Gram for SC. Shaw is set for a big year, Goodwin on the decline though? I might lean marginally to option one, because Goddard is a captain option.

Sandilands + Franklin

+
vs.

Kreuzer + Pavlich a little bit of cash.

Even though Buddy is missing R1.

What if you already have Ablett, Swan, Selwood and Riewoldt and ROK as captain options?

Sandilands and Franklin - but I would pick Gia or Tippett.

Kreuzer will play forward more than rucking which will affect his output I guess.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Quick one.

With Rockliff not playing who is the best forward bench option out of -

Carl Peterson (Hawks)

Relton Roberts (Tigers)


Leaning towards Peterson. Whats his job security like?

 

[Spudregus_87]

Goddard and Gram or Goodwin and Shaw?

Goddard & Gram. Normally I'd say wait til BJ drops under 600k, but that might be too long to wait. Goodwin's old and I'm not convinced on Shaw.

Sandilands + Franklin

vs.

Kreuzer + Pavlich + a little bit of cash.

Even though Buddy is missing R1.

Sandi & Buddy (as long as you have Gumby or Hitchy as cover)

P. Burgoyne V Trengove?

Trengrove. By the time Burgoyne comes back you will have missed out on the $250k Trengrove owners would've made.


Vince and LeCras
or
Selwood and Ziebell (and $75k)???

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

suban or raines

Fwiw I went with Suban

Gumbleton or Hitchcock at this stage, not too fussed though, not really going for the money just a league win.

Didn't Burgoyne retire? Or do you mean Shaun?

The Burgoyne that went to the Hawks lol.

 

[Spudregus_87]

Quick one.

With Rockliff not playing who is the best forward bench option out of -

Carl Peterson (Hawks)

Relton Roberts (Tigers)


Leaning towards Peterson. Whats his job security like?

Peterson. Especially while Hawthorn have all their injuries. I don't know how safe his spot will be once these guys come back (AFL website):

Cyril Rioli (groin) test
Jarryd Roughead (knee) test
Brad Sewell (fractured collarbone) 4 weeks
Wayde Skipper (hamstring) 6 weeks
Cameron Stokes (knee) indefinite
Brendan Whitecross (hip) indefinite
Clinton Young (hip) 3 weeks

Had never heard of Roberts until I watched the Footy Show last night lol

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

I'm a bit worried having Trengove, Martin and Dangerfield all starting. Should I replace one of them with S. Burgoyne?

 

[russea]

I'm a bit worried having Trengove, Martin and Dangerfield all starting. Should I replace one of them with S. Burgoyne?

Mabye, IMO those 3 arent bad picks

 

[russea]

Quick questions before lock out

Gumby or Cam Hitchcock to start on field

and

Gia V gray (I would pick grey but there is an injury consern, and if he doesnt play I guess i'll have to play both gumby and hitchcock anyway)

 

[paulige]

Scully or banfield.

Banfield 80k cheaper.

 

[Spudregus_87]

Vince and LeCras
or
Selwood and Ziebell (and $75k)?

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Quick questions before lock out

Gumby or Cam Hitchcock to start on field

and

Gia V gray (I would pick grey but there is an injury consern, and if he doesnt play I guess i'll have to play both gumby and hitchcock anyway)

Gumby and Gia

 

[russea]

Scully or banfield.

Banfield 80k cheaper.

I think Scully, But if you dont have martin or trengrove there the two to get

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Vince and LeCras
or
Selwood and Ziebell (and $75k)?

2nd option

Podsiadly V TDL V Sibosado V Weedon?

Is Scully only a midfield option?

 

[russea]

Vince and LeCras
or
Selwood and Ziebell (and $75k)?

I definatly like the selwwod ziebs option more the extra $K is just a bonus

 

[paulige]

I think Scully, But if you dont have martin or trengrove there the two to get

Already got them both. cheers, I'll stick with scully

 

[Roy boys]

boak, kerr or masten. Thoughts ?