Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[Mr Mosquito]

No and No.

Look elsewhere for upgrades. Or pick another two players to upgrade too.

Mastent to Ball

OR

Waters to Ladson / Hunt / Myers / Nash

 

[J6shSC]

Re: Ladson or Hunt or Greenwood

Beau Waters.

 

[Hoosy]

Mastent to Ball

OR

Waters to Ladson / Hunt / Myers / Nash

I would say Waters to either Ladsonor Hunt as if fit they are guarenteed games. Nash/Myers are not.

My issue is Kenelly or Malceski....who will get the dashing role for more points value?

 

[Mr Mosquito]

I would say Waters to either Ladsonor Hunt as if fit they are guarenteed games. Nash/Myers are not.

My issue is Kenelly or Malceski....who will get the dashing role for more points value?

Malceski.....runs on the board in 2010...cheaper too

 

[russea]

Should i get buddy
iv got gia and enough money to up grade him with gumby and pods on the bench who i think will play rd1 if fit
anythoughts on what i should do

 

[thomas_m18]

Should i get buddy
iv got gia and enough money to up grade him with gumby and pods on the bench who i think will play rd1 if fit
anythoughts on what i should do

I think Buddy's a must have, so go for him if you can.

My Question:

Alex Silvagni, Phil Davis or any $100,200 or less defender?

 

[eugene_tomas]

back defenders is a wait n see mate for round 1 teams your guess would be as good as mine.. i like silvange tho if hes picked

i cant choose between j brown and pav.. what do you guys think??

 

[russea]

I think Buddy's a must have, so go for him if you can.

My Question:

Alex Silvagni, Phil Davis or any $100,200 or less defender?

Um dont see anyone really getting games in that group mabye phil davis because of crows injury list but then silvagni might get a game in freos crap defence so really is up to if u need the extra $k or not

 

[russea]

back defenders is a wait n see mate for round 1 teams your guess would be as good as mine.. i like silvange tho if hes picked

i cant choose between j brown and pav.. what do you guys think??

Um for me pavs a must have superconsistant and will get more of the ball than brownie

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Mitchell & Boyd

Vs

NDS & Pavlich


I'm basically looking for two guys to fill my 2nd & 3rd midfielder spots after Ablett. Happy to take any other suggestions as well....

You have $1,150,000 to spend.... Impress me...

BTW, my other mids are Vince, Dangerfield & Martin

 

[Kanga_01]

Mitchell & Boyd

Vs

NDS & Pavlich


I'm basically looking for two guys to fill my 2nd & 3rd midfielder spots after Ablett. Happy to take any other suggestions as well....

You have $1,150,000 to spend.... Impress me...

BTW, my other mids are Vince, Dangerfield & Martin

My first piece of advice would be to place Dangerfield into the forward line and bring another rookie Mid - so much good value out there and you'll raise some $$.

I'd be going Option 1 - Mitchell and Boyd. Sammy looks in good touch AND should be a big year for the dogs. To be honest i'm not a massive Pav fan for the early parts of the season too, so option 1 for me.

My dilema -

Pendlebury vs Selwood

 

[russea]

Mitchell & Boyd

Vs

NDS & Pavlich


I'm basically looking for two guys to fill my 2nd & 3rd midfielder spots after Ablett. Happy to take any other suggestions as well....

You have $1,150,000 to spend.... Impress me...

BTW, my other mids are Vince, Dangerfield & Martin

Out of those i like the Nds Pav combo

I had a play around
If u moved dangerfield fwd and replace him with a rookie i used trengrove
as ur 2,3,4 mids u could have mitchell, Gibbs, boyd
Or
Have a lower priced rookie i used barlow u could have NDS,Pendles and boyd as ur 2,3,4 mids

I donno its up to u i just thought some of those could help

 

[Ed_Gein]

Mitchell & Boyd

Vs

NDS & Pavlich


I'm basically looking for two guys to fill my 2nd & 3rd midfielder spots after Ablett. Happy to take any other suggestions as well....

You have $1,150,000 to spend.... Impress me...

BTW, my other mids are Vince, Dangerfield & Martin

Swan + Cooney

lthough the NDS + Pav doesn't look half bad either

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

My first piece of advice would be to place Dangerfield into the forward line and bring another rookie Mid - so much good value out there and you'll raise some $$.

I'd be going Option 1 - Mitchell and Boyd. Sammy looks in good touch AND should be a big year for the dogs. To be honest i'm not a massive Pav fan for the early parts of the season too, so option 1 for me.

My dilema -

Pendlebury vs Selwood

I'm not as confident as you are of these rookies. I have Martin, Barlow, Jetta. I think that's the best of them.

Out of those i like the Nds Pav combo

I had a play around
If u moved dangerfield fwd and replace him with a rookie i used trengrove
as ur 2,3,4 mids u could have mitchell, Gibbs, boyd
Or
Have a lower priced rookie i used barlow u could have NDS,Pendles and boyd as ur 2,3,4 mids

I donno its up to u i just thought some of those could help

Yeah. Fair call. But still, happy to keep Dangerfield in the mids as a MPP and I have ROK & Harvey in the fwd line.

Swan + Cooney

lthough the NDS + Pav doesn't look half bad either

Nope. Swan won't keep up last year and Cooney goes missing a bit IMO.

 

[thomas_m18]

Bock and Alex Silvagni or Enright and Phil Davis (can't afford Drummond, 1k too expensive)

 

[Hot Tiges]

Bock and Alex Silvagni or Enright and Phil Davis (can't afford Drummond, 1k too expensive)

Enright and Silvagni? Bock has had an interrupted pre-season. Not sure if Davis is going to play much. Silvagni will surely be elevated with Grover and Scott Thornton moved to the LTI.

Warnock & Waters vs Skipper & Hunt/Schoenmakers. Have the 1st option at the moment. Not overly convinced on Waters. Hunt looks good so far and Schoenmakers surely will average more then 50+ this year...thoughts/ideas? Both ruck options here are for a bench spot and defender is for 7th spot.

 

[Impromptu]

Gray or Zibell?

and

Hayes, Dal Santo or Pendlebury?

Gray and Dal Santa Clause

Goddard and Ballantyne VS Enright and Murphy

Enright and Murphy (or Hall)....

I can't believe so many different permutations and combinations....but

Waite v Hall
Goodwin v Newman

 

[marshie_blues]

Waite v Hall
Goodwin v Newman

Waite - i think if he is right he may start slow but will average more over the whole season
and
Newman - good SCer always consistent should score as well this year as always

 

[mdippa]

Selwood or NDS?

 

[IWantToBeGlass]

Flick a coin. I got NDS but another flip could end up with Selwood.

Hall & Malceski (& Waters on bench)

vs.

Tippett & Waters (& Maguire on bench)

 

[esorhali]

depend on your Ruck combo, if you plan to utilise MPP I would go Tippett & Waters however Hall and Malceski could pay off bigtime. I have Tippett, Hall and Malceski in my side.

No one has mentioned S. Johnson (possibly over injury)

I currently have Johnno and Harvs in fwd line. Any comments?

S.Johnson & Harvey v Higgins & Giansircusa

Or do ya go say ROK or Didak with say Hall or Ziebel

Cheers

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

depend on your Ruck combo, if you plan to utilise MPP I would go Tippett & Waters however Hall and Malceski could pay off bigtime. I have Tippett, Hall and Malceski in my side.

No one has mentioned S. Johnson (possibly over injury)

I currently have Johnno and Harvs in fwd line. Any comments?

S.Johnson & Harvey v Higgins & Giansircusa

Or do ya go say ROK or Didak with say Hall or Ziebel

Cheers

Don't mention Johnno.. Cruelled me big time last year....

I've recently come around to Harvey. Has made my fwd line along with ROK, Roo & Buddy.

Gia looks to be a bargain. Hard to split him and Higgins IMO.

I've gone off Ziebell in favour of Dangerfield. Just think more upside in him. Hall has the obvious risks but hasn't Rocket said he'll be rested during the year??? That makes him even less appealling IMO.

I'd take;
Harvey & Gia/Higgins.
ROK & Zeibell

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Flick a coin. I got NDS but another flip could end up with Selwood.

Hall & Malceski (& Waters on bench)

vs.

Tippett & Waters (& Maguire on bench)

One thing I know is your mad not to have the Eski in your starting back 7.

 

[Clutch]

im having trouble choosing in the backline between:

Waite and Macdonald, what are thoughts on both

 

[Moonwalker]

Mayne vs. Ballantyne vs. Macaffer

I'm more inclined to take a punt on Macaffer but I'm unsure what his pre-season has been like since the NAB fixture results have been down. Mayne's 3rd year should be a break-out though.