-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X or Player Y
- Thread starter docker_champ29
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
bump
The_Air_Up_There
All Australian
- Sep 15, 2009
- 641
- 4
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Cale Morton vs Adam Cooney
Just A Guess
Rookie
Please do not ask a question without answering another. Otherwise this thread becomes a waste of time.
but in saying that:
Hargrave, Cooney, Goodes and Hille for mine.
Tippet v Gray
Scottydude
Senior List
I have got MASSIVE wraps on Tippet this year, he should increase his average further and as the crows improve they will get him the ball even more. Alot of hype about gray going to the midfield but im not sure about him yet. Both in my team though!
Kevin McAllister
Debutant
- Nov 24, 2009
- 63
- 16
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
Judds Jiants
Rookie
- Feb 7, 2009
- 48
- 0
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Goodes is set to smash it this year average 125 in the last 3 games when he played at CHF on the other hand selwood doesnt get 22 games therefore he could be hurting you in the backline where as gilbee and gray will play 22 games in there respective sides bar injury. With gray moving into the midfield i can see his score rising by 10-15 ppg and gilbee has always been around the 70-75 mark. therefore i would choose gilbee and gray but if you could fit goodes in i would becuase i have a feelng he is about to explode
Joel Mcdonald (Melbourne) vs Hurn (West Coast)
Joel Mcdonald (Melbourne) vs Hurn (West Coast)
Gilbee (80avg) & Gray (80) = 160
S. Selwood (70) & Goodes (100) = 170
so Selwood and Goodes but these averages could be far from the truth.
Hurn I think will average about 80 this year and MacDonald probably mid 70's.
Next up: Gumbleton & Higgins or Gray & Polak
Definitely Gumbleton/Higgins however if possible i would also try to fit in Gray in ur team. More midfield time should equal more touches/tackles equating to higher dt scores. I can see him averaging 90+ and can turn out to be the Higgins of last year. Higgins should be quality this year and can take the next step into the "elite" class. In addition the bulldogs should get better this year therefore equating to greater scores. I currently have gumby but not confident with him at all due to his injury ravaged past. Dont rate Polak as a dter
Ward vs Mackay vs Swift vs Masten rank from 1-4 plz
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
??????
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
1 - masten, swift
3 - ward
4 - mackay
i swear to you that im not being biased
gram vs enright
higgins vs JB vs goodes
Enright hands down
1) Goodes - due to durability
2) JB - due to price and having a whole heap of initial games at the gabba
3) Higgins - would be number 1 if he was durable
Pendles vs Cooney + 60k?
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
pendles
i think he can step it up a notch this year
cooney is far better in supercoach
cooney will almost always get the number 1 tag
wherease pendles is competing for the tag with ball, didak, and swan
although i think pendles is better than all those three, he should still get the main tag less than cooney does
* Enright has been super durable in the past and a very consistent DT scorer. IIRC he only scored under 70 only once last year but lacks the big 100+ scores. If you're looking for a good 80+ score week in week out then Enright wins hands down.
* Gram averaged 101 in the last 12 rounds so there is definetly some upside left in him. But the problem is he hasn't backed it up yet with another good average. 91, 78, 74 and 79 in the past 4 years so could fall back into a 70's average.
Enright for me
* Higgins will be a star in the future but there are reoccuring injury concerns. Has the potential to average 100+ if fully fit.
* Brown has been a DT gun for most of his career but has probably just past his best. I'd expect an average between 95-100.
* Goodes is going to be a year older next year but I don't think that will stop him from averaging big. Averaged 129 in the last month of the season and I think he is capable of averaging 100+ this year.
+1 Goodes for me
Next up: Josh Hunt or Matthew Broadbent
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
broadbent for me* Enright has been super durable in the past and a very consistent DT scorer. IIRC he only scored under 70 only once last year but lacks the big 100+ scores. If you're looking for a good 80+ score week in week out then Enright wins hands down.
* Gram averaged 101 in the last 12 rounds so there is definetly some upside left in him. But the problem is he hasn't backed it up yet with another good average. 91, 78, 74 and 79 in the past 4 years so could fall back into a 70's average.
Enright for me
* Higgins will be a star in the future but there are reoccuring injury concerns. Has the potential to average 100+ if fully fit.
* Brown has been a DT gun for most of his career but has probably just past his best. I'd expect an average between 95-100.
* Goodes is going to be a year older next year but I don't think that will stop him from averaging big. Averaged 129 in the last month of the season and I think he is capable of averaging 100+ this year.
+1 Goodes for me
Next up: Josh Hunt or Matthew Broadbent
showed some good signs in the games he played last year
will play only midfield and will get plenty of oppurtunity
hunt coming off a major injury and at best will only average
55 - 60
more upside in broadbent but safer spot for hunt
still id take the punt on broadbent and hope he has a few decent games in a row so you can cash him in
I could average 55 playing for Geelong the way they share the ball around. Hunt will average a bit more than that i'd say- based on past seasons i'd put him at mid 60's. I will be watching Broadbent very closely in the NAB cup and i think that will ultimately decide his fate. At best he could play as a 7th defender all year averaging 75-80 playing a similar role to what Nathan Krakouer did last year off half back, even push into the midfield. At this stage though, with his job security and cheaper price, Hunt has his nose in front. But I will probably end up selecting them both. Now for..
McVeigh (Ess) vs Masten
McVeigh for mine. I think he is nearly the best valued player in DT this year. Masten, i can't see him averaging over 80...McVeigh, I cna see him getting back to over 85.
Grey vs Ziebiel?
- Dec 4, 2005
- 723
- 4
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Heath Shaw or Gilbee?
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
make sure you post about the person before you before asking a question yourself
Galacticos
Senior List
with not many other gun midfielder in the port team, you would expect theres a chance for boak to get tagged next year. although very soft, cale morton has a good dream team game and is expected to improve his average in an improving melbourne side (since they cant get any worse
) and he probably wont get injured cose he doesnt go in contests.gia or pav?
Hard one here due to the fact both have break out seasons looming...
ZIEBELL = positives are he will get pleanty of opportunitiies throughout the year. He will play an important roll in a young midfield and could avergae 80+... Coming off a broken leg though could be a minor concern.
GRAY = Will definatly get more midfield time and the ablity to go forward and kick a goal too. Not to many things to say in the negatives other then the fact he is $40,000 more expensive...
MY VERDICT = Go both if salary cap lets you because you will be rewarded with nice scores before trading up for GUNS! If you need to go with one i would choose Gray... more upside and scoring potential form mine.
JONO BROWN OR PAVLICH
- Status
