Player X v Y v Z - 2017

[scaryness]

Is trading out a premo mid to spread cash around a sound idea or cutting off your nose to spite yourself?

Thinking of trading down Hannebery who is my M2 Swallow and upgrading Taranto at F5 to a Ryder or Nank, Lloyd at D3 to a Shaw/Docherty etc. or even a def rookie to a Mills or something like that.

 

[Cadillac]

Johannisen, Bont vs Wines, Docherty ?

 

[stevebbb]

Johannisen, Bont vs Wines, Docherty ?

Wines and Doch for me
Wines averaged 107 after the bye last year, Ryder coming in will only help him further
Doch is a God, could go 110++

 

[stevebbb]

Added a couple more options

Vince D2 + Marchbank D4 + Titch M4 + Nankervis F3 + Steele F4 + $15.7k
vs
Rance D1 + Marchbank D4 + O'Meara M6 + Buddy F2 + Ryder F4 + $8.7k
vs
Rance D1 + Macraedie D4 + Titch M4 + Ryder F3 + Roughy F4 + $28.3k
vs
Shaw D1 + Macraedie D4 + Titch M4 + Ryder F3 + Steele F4 + $7.4k

bump

 

[Keg on legs]

bump

I'll go the last option

I like Shaw and I reckon steele can match Roughy. I'm tossing up between Roughy and steele myself and reckon I'll jo steele

 

[Jbomb967]

Callum Mills & J Selwood

OR

S Docherty & J Watson

 

[Riviat]

Florent v Turner

 

[Keg on legs]

Florent v Turner

Turner.


Crappier team in North you'd expect them to play him more

 

[SureBuddy]

N.Roo vs Wingard.

 

[stevebbb]

N.Roo vs Wingard.

Wingard had injury concerns several times last year and had the same in this preseason

Start with NRoo, make the most of his baller Etihad average, and hope Chad can stay fit and find form and bring him after your bye

 

[SureBuddy]

Wingard had injury concerns several times last year and had the same in this preseason

Start with NRoo, make the most of his baller Etihad average, and hope Chad can stay fit and find form and bring him after your bye

Yea roo is tempting at Etihad.
What injuries has Wingard had this preseason? He got a corky in round 2 of JLT, but been fit other than that.

 

[hargy]

JOM vs J. Kelly

 

[stevebbb]

Yea roo is tempting at Etihad.
What injuries has Wingard had this preseason? He got a corky in round 2 of JLT, but been fit other than that.

Yeah just the corkie haha
missed JLT3 though because of it though, so match fitness maybe?

Back your gut

 

[keithrichards]

Dayne Beams vs Marc Murphy?

and one that's possibly been done to death...

O'Meara vs Swallow?

 

[NormaJeanHawk]

Dayne Beams vs Marc Murphy?

and one that's possibly been done to death...

O'Meara vs Swallow?

Beams, Murphy is past it i think
O'meara for me, the game i watched swallow play he looked average and almost lost at times

 

[freddy mercury]

Tommy Mitchell Vs Dusty Martin!? AAAGGGGHHHHHHH

 

[stevebbb]

Tommy Mitchell Vs Dusty Martin!? AAAGGGGHHHHHHH

Titch ez, has 110+ potential
Reckon Dusty will be 100-109 again

 

[Nathan Wilcox]

cripps vs bont vs dusty vs R gray

 

[Nathan Wilcox]

thinking bont or cripps

 

[bananatigz]

S.Martin and Pendles

v

Grundy and JPK

 

[jon0011]

cripps vs bont vs dusty vs R gray

CRIPPS


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[NormaJeanHawk]

cripps vs bont vs dusty vs R gray

Cripps>bont>gray>dusty

 

[Wildrig]

Hickey/Petracca v Grundy/Steele

 

[King_Steele]

Hickey/Petracca v Grundy/Steele

Grundy & Steele.

 

[Significant]

Think this will be my final decision on my team. Let me know what you think a) if all ruckman are playing as their primary ruck and b) if secondary rucks are named for Gawn/Goldy.

Gawn and Marchbank + $100k
v
Goldstein and Marchbank + $160k
v
Grundy and Tuohy
v
Martin and Lloyd
v
Hickey and Rance
v
Ryder and Shaw

Cheers!