Player X v Y v Z

[WaynesWorld19]

Westhoff v Boak ?

Purely for higher point scoring from here on. Prices and b/e's not an issue

I'm not a fan of either ....can't see Boak as a top 6 fwd

Westhoff has a 3 rnd average, 10 points below his 5 game average ? (93) .....is that due to Ryder coming back ....or his ever changing role as a utility, which makes me nervous

Westhoff scoring at 0.7 ppm

 

[Hai_Newman]

Best mid out of Treloar, Phillips, Zerett, Zorko?

Treloar

 

[Imoster]

Westhoff v Menegola v Heeney

 

[Andrew Birch]

I'm not a fan of either ....can't see Boak as a top 6 fwd

Westhoff has a 3 rnd average, 10 points below his 5 game average ? (93) .....is that due to Ryder coming back ....or his ever changing role as a utility, which makes me nervous

Westhoff scoring at 0.7 ppm

Do you rate Walters above Westhoff & Boak?

 

[Hai_Newman]

Westhoff v Menegola v Heeney

Heeney

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Do you rate Walters above Westhoff & Boak?

Well, i had Walters from R1 .........he's been good as long as he has played midfield minutes ....but I see him as a F5 in my final side

My side has ....Heeney, Gray, Hogan, Walters, Taranto ......T.McD will be the final piece after his Bye

 

[Andrew Birch]

Well, i had Walters from R1 .........he's been good as long as he has played midfield minutes ....but I see him as a F5 in my final side

My side has ....Heeney, Gray, Hogan, Walters, Taranto ......T.McD will be the final piece after his Bye

Walters would be my F6 (although I think he will end up averaging higher than Dev Smith)

McLean, Gray, Sicily, Hogan, Devon, Walters

Feels weird trading him back in though, albeit for 60k less than I traded him out for.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Walters would be my F6 (although I think he will end up averaging higher than Dev Smith)

McLean, Gray, Sicily, Hogan, Devon, Walters

Feels weird trading him back in though, albeit for 60k less than I traded him out for.

Oops ....forgot i had McLean (sitting on bench bye) ......so Taranto will go back to midfield when T. McD comes in ....Walters F6

 

[Andrew Birch]

Oops ....forgot i had McLean (sitting on bench bye) ......so Taranto will go back to midfield when T. McD comes in ....Walters F6

Once I switch Sicily back to Def and upgrade a def rookie to Heeney we're going to have the exact same forward line.

 

[JDavey]

I need at least two forwards, currently weighing up between:
- Buddy (459k)
- Menegola (502k)

Send help

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Send help

Menegola IMO

 

[lids2richo]

Keep Cole or Mirra?

 

[keithrichards]

Oliver vs Treloar

 

[Moustachio]

Oliver vs Treloar

The better the haircut, the worse the DE.

 

[keithrichards]

Keep Cole or Mirra?

Keep Cole for sure

 

[keithrichards]

The better the haircut, the worse the DE.

I’m confused. Both have shocking haircuts

 

[Moustachio]

I’m confused. Both have shocking haircuts

Well that is a matter of taste... But one is a ranga

 

[Hai_Newman]

Oliver vs Treloar

 

[Moustachio]

What will they average for rest of season:

TMc vs Brayshaw

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Keep Cole or Mirra?

Keep Cole ......WC have shown faith & now he's had a weeks rest

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Oliver vs Treloar

Oliver .....rarely lets you down ....now, if he can just kick the bloody ball more

 

[WaynesWorld19]

What will they average for rest of season:

TMc vs Brayshaw

Certainly can see TMcD continuing his current ave .....but MELB is on a "hot streak" ....if they go off the boil, T.McD may drop 10 points on his current ave of 111 .........still solid !

 

[Moustachio]

Certainly can see TMcD continuing his current ave .....but MELB is on a "hot streak" ....if they go off the boil, T.McD may drop 10 points on his current ave of 111 .........still solid !

Hmmm yeah just looking at their fixture they have been on a ridic easy run... Ess Stk Car GCS WBD in last 6. The big win vs Ade was impressive, and their only other win vs decent opponent was Nth.

Remaining fixture is only 4/11 easy mode games... And 3 of those are in ther next 5. Run home have Gee Ade Syd WCE and GWS in their last 6. Hmmm.

 

[BeamsLocke]

Trade out Spargo or TSmith? TSmith is obviously not playing but he has the potential to make more money if he comes back? Is he likely to come back?

 

[Moustachio]

Ok new one:

A) Hurley or

B) Howe/Crisp/TMc/Brayshaw

ie Do I trade Sunday (Bombers play) or Monday (Pies/Dees play)

Dont care about the price, just want the R13 bye def premo who will score the most for rest of season.