Player X v Y v Z

[Red Syrah]

Well, Treloar over Jelly was a hell of a bust! Stand to lose 50 points and probably a trade over shoddy reasoning - already had Cogs and no Collingwood players so figured going Treloar was spreading the load and not relying on GWS' midfield too much.

No money in the kitty and 2 trades left (FMSCL ), so need a cheaper option for him looks like.

Selwood, Zorko, Gaff?

zorko my choice

 

[Red Syrah]

Best forward or defender for under $478k?

Thinking one of Walters, De Goey, J Howe, Webster, Hurley

Howe overall but can be inconsistent

 

[toxic]

I know he's not a "sexy" pick, but JPK's last 8 games 125, 151, 73, 108, 109, 102, 118, 112 = 112.3 ave. Historically scores much better post byes. Worth considering at 529k. 7% ownership POD

Is it he who always seems to have a massive 2nd half of the year

 

[Red Syrah]

Jelly v pendles (no treloar) v Neale v Jpk

 

[Judd_Magic]

and that ugly campaigner Hurn

Here2tellyouwhy your thoughts?

 

[J_GUNstall19]

I'd say

Best forward or defender for under $478k?

Thinking one of Walters, De Goey, J Howe, Webster, Hurley

Webster imo, if possible wait another week he'll be a lot cheaper

 

[Wellsy35]

zorko my choice

What's your reasoning over the others?

 

[Red Syrah]

What's your reasoning over the others?

Not sure in the impact of GAJ on selwood and think zorko has a higher ceiling than gaff though also lower floor.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Crisp v Howe to complete my defence....

 

[Axly]

Higgins as North rely on him more than the Pies rely on Sidebottom imo.

Vs Pendles ?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Vs Pendles ?

Probably Pendles.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Crisp v Howe to complete my defence....

Crispy is a good option in the backline this year imho.

 

[Jiska]

I know he's not a "sexy" pick, but JPK's last 8 games 125, 151, 73, 108, 109, 102, 118, 112 = 112.3 ave. Historically scores much better post byes. Worth considering at 529k. 7% ownership POD

Bit of a myth.

2017: 99.3 after, 105.6 before
2016: 120 after, 102 before
2015: 117 after, 103 before
2014: 105 after, 123 before
2013: 97 after, 113 before
2012: 119 after, 121 before

 

[Andrew Birch]

Bit of a myth.

2017: 99.3 after, 105.6 before
2016: 120 after, 102 before
2015: 117 after, 103 before
2014: 105 after, 123 before
2013: 97 after, 113 before
2012: 119 after, 121 before

Ok recent history then

4 out of the last 6

 

[joop]

Jelly or Danger??????

 

[Red Syrah]

5 trades left before this weeks trades:

which one for final upgrade:

1. Fritsch at d6 for a couple of weeks then trade to webster (via TMAC or Sicily)
2. Fritsch > anyone (jelly, neale, yeo, lloyd)
3. Holman > sub $514K (phillips, pendles, franklin, gray)

 

[Red Syrah]

Jelly or Danger??????

tough one.

Jelly if his groin holds up and he continues form
Danger for consistent 100's with the odd 130 thrown in

 

[Jiska]

Jelly or Danger??????

Jelly

5 trades left before this weeks trades:

which one for final upgrade:

1. Fritsch at d6 for a couple of weeks then trade to webster (via TMAC or Sicily)
2. Fritsch > anyone (jelly, neale, yeo, lloyd)
3. Holman > sub $514K (phillips, pendles, franklin, gray)

Holman to Gray

 

[Longbombswans]

Pendles and Budwah VS Neale and de Goey?

 

[DT_35]

Gray, Dev, Buddy or De Goey?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Pendles and Budwah VS Neale and de Goey?

Neale and De Goey.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Gray, Dev, Buddy or De Goey?

Buddy.

 

[Jiska]

Pendles and Budwah VS Neale and de Goey?

Neale and De Goey. Easily.

Gray, Dev, Buddy or De Goey?

Def not Dev. De Goey by a fair way.

 

[DT_35]

Neale and De Goey. Easily.


Def not Dev. De Goey by a fair way.

Why def not Dev?

 

[lids2richo]

J.Smith & Hurley/De Goey vs a non-playing rookie & Gray/Westhoff?

J.Smith would be my D7 with Ridley my D8 otherwise I'd have Ridley and a non-scorer if getting Gray/Westhoff