Player X v Y v Z

[Jiska]

Duncan vs GAJ vs Gaff vs Bont

Pick one.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Duncan vs GAJ vs Gaff vs Bont

Pick one.

In terms of potential, risky though.

GAJ > Toss the 3 way coin for the rest.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Duncan vs GAJ vs Gaff vs Bont

Pick one.

Safe v Risk ?......steady scoring v volatile scoring ?

Duncan (safe) v Bont (volatile) v GAJ (risk)

If you have sufficient trades go GAJ .....3 game 116 ave with the known risk

If short on trades go Duncan .....remarkable consistency, all bar 1 score a min 94+ ...plus a POD (2% of teams)

Duncans / Ablett last 3 games (for leagues) .....HAW, FREO, GCS

 

[Jiska]

In terms of potential, risky though.

GAJ > Toss the 3 way coin for the rest.

Safe v Risk ?......steady scoring v volatile scoring ?

Duncan (safe) v Bont (volatile) v GAJ (risk)

If you have sufficient trades go GAJ .....3 game 116 ave with the known risk

If short on trades go Duncan .....remarkable consistency, all bar 1 score a min 94+ ...plus a POD (2% of teams)

Duncans / Ablett last 3 games (for leagues) .....HAW, FREO, GCS

6 trades left. Wanted to go Ryan to Hoff as M9/F7 which left me Treloar to one of these four.

The more I think about it, the more I think the smarter move is just Treloar to Danger and use only the one trade with 200k in the bank

 

[Andrew Birch]

6 trades left. Wanted to go Ryan to Hoff as M9/F7 which left me Treloar to one of these four.

The more I think about it, the more I think the smarter move is just Treloar to Danger and use only the one trade with 200k in the bank

Don't you go jinxing Danger now, he's having a crap season as it is!

 

[Moustachio]

Not sure its minor sadly

Not sure about these rumors as doing both hammies so utterly bizarre, plus he got rub-down which they would avoid for a period if they thought he pulled it (supposed to ice).

 

[Wellsy35]

Well, Treloar over Jelly was a hell of a bust! Stand to lose 50 points and probably a trade over shoddy reasoning - already had Cogs and no Collingwood players so figured going Treloar was spreading the load and not relying on GWS' midfield too much.

No money in the kitty and 2 trades left (FMSCL ), so need a cheaper option for him looks like.

Selwood, Zorko, Gaff?

 

[Moustachio]

I like ward as a pod. Giants to come with a wet sail from here on in

Have not heard this expression... They gonma be travelling upside down??

 

[Moustachio]

Not sure its minor sadly

Hmmm nvm just catching up on Eddy statement, sounds pretty dire.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Well, Treloar over Jelly was a hell of a bust! Stand to lose 50 points and probably a trade over shoddy reasoning - already had Cogs and no Collingwood players so figured going Treloar was spreading the load and not relying on GWS' midfield too much.

No money in the kitty and 2 trades left (FMSCL ), so need a cheaper option for him looks like.

Selwood, Zorko, Gaff?

Selwood imo.

 

[Andrewy]

Have not heard this expression... They gonma be travelling upside down??

...or...

 

[Andrewy]

Hmmm nvm just catching up on Eddy statement, sounds pretty dire.

 

[Wellsy35]

Selwood imo.

Would having Danger, Menegola and Selwood make my team too Geelong heavy though?

 

[J_GUNstall19]

Crisp vs Ryan vs Howe

maybe add Hurley in there as well

 

[Wellsy35]

Crisp vs Ryan vs Howe

maybe add Hurley in there as well

On recent form:

Crisp > Ryan > Hurley > Howe (too up and down for me)

 

[Axly]

Higgins vs Sidebottom

 

[lids2richo]

Higgins vs Sidebottom

Hard to choose between a mid and a forward but probably Sidey. Don't know how Treloar out for a long term will affect him though?


For mine,

Hurley vs Webster (suppose to be back this week)

 

[Judd_Magic]

Would having Danger, Menegola and Selwood make my team too Geelong heavy though?

Nah, don't think so mate.

Other years we have been able to have 3 guns from the same team and it's worked out fine .ie. Pendles, Swan, Beams and Ablett, Selwood and Chapman.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Higgins vs Sidebottom

Higgins as North rely on him more than the Pies rely on Sidebottom imo.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Well, Treloar over Jelly was a hell of a bust! Stand to lose 50 points and probably a trade over shoddy reasoning - already had Cogs and no Collingwood players so figured going Treloar was spreading the load and not relying on GWS' midfield too much.

No money in the kitty and 2 trades left (FMSCL ), so need a cheaper option for him looks like.

Selwood, Zorko, Gaff?

I know he's not a "sexy" pick, but JPK's last 8 games 125, 151, 73, 108, 109, 102, 118, 112 = 112.3 ave. Historically scores much better post byes. Worth considering at 529k. 7% ownership POD

 

[ROOINYOU]

Hurley V Howe.
Hurls more consistent, Howe higher ceiling..
???

 

[lids2richo]

Hard to choose between a mid and a forward but probably Sidey. Don't know how Treloar out for a long term will affect him though?


For mine,

Hurley vs Webster (suppose to be back this week)

Just realised with dpp I can also get a forward instead. With very limited trades I want to go for durability as well as scoring.

So Hurley v Webster v Buddy v Westhoff v DeGoey?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hurley V Howe.
Hurls more consistent, Howe higher ceiling..
???

Anyone else?

Howe is up and down.
Hurley playing for a accountable role.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Anyone else?

Howe is up and down.
Hurley playing for a accountable role.

gotta be around that price.
already have Laird,Yeo,Simpson,Sicily,Savage.
my other options Shaw,Jonas,Rance and that ugly campaigner Hurn

 

[bbco49]

Best forward or defender for under $478k?

Thinking one of Walters, De Goey, J Howe, Webster, Hurley