im thinking swallow too
they are both clearance machines, but yeah, i reckon swallow has more upside, and more potential to score (both goals in games, and SC points)
-
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X vs Player Y Thread
- Thread starter Super Hans
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
they are both clearance machines, but yeah, i reckon swallow has more upside, and more potential to score (both goals in games, and SC points)
Swallow, simply because he's a tackle machine, gets his own ball and kicks goals. Slightly better scorer than Dom Cassisi. But two very similar players in all stats.
ROK, Personally I'm staying away from key forwards, this day and age, goals for One player can be hard to come by. Did anyone get 10 goals last year?
I'd go with Judd, more explosive and has greater potential to score big. Having said that, I have both in my team.
Didak vs. Enright/Broughton/Gilbee/Newman/Fisher
Judd for that reason above, Hodge will be targetted with heavy tags. I think its harder to tag Judd. I'd be inclined to go for S Burgoyne, he's always struggled with tags. If Hodgey gets a tag, he's free to roam.
Broughton (only cos I had him last year and like his game) Scored real well. Fisher in at #2.
OK
S Hill, T Cotchin, J Trengove, J Scully, R Palmer, D Rich, C Masten, D Martin. Which TWO would you select from the above?
GotTheGoodes
Bloods
- Moderator
- #103
I remember sitting there at Etihad last year (with my Essendon supporting g/f) watching LeCras kick a couple... And remember my (Richmond supporting) brother calling me up in fits about the coming of Roo v 2....
I'm with you RE: Key Fowards too. I have Roo and that's it. The rest are the likes of Goodes/RoK (mpp), Rioli, Tippett etc.
As for the 2 I'd personally be going Hill & Cotchin. Been hearing good things about Cotchin's preseason...
Mark Le Cres?
LOL but I did mean by key forwards J Brown, N Riewoldt, L Franklin etc.
Mark Le Cras was just on fire that day, kicked like most of the goals from the boundry line. what was it? Like 13.1?
I do have Pavlich in my team, but he is floating up the ground. Goodsey playes all over too.
I still think though everyone is raving about Riewoldt being a must have. But I think those types of forwards might struggle for consistency this season.
- Mar 28, 2008
- 3,141
- 444
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Gilbert, Judd, Bartel.
I reckon we've seen the best of Gilbee. Judd is an out and out gun. A lot of man love for Selwood but he may cop the first tag this year....
ByTheBeardOfZeus
Rookie
Foley vs A. Davey for a potentially bargain midfield spot.
Foley is slightly cheaper, but clearly prone to injury.
Thanks
Foley is slightly cheaper, but clearly prone to injury.
Thanks
J riewoldt did
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Conca. Besides which, Swallow and Harris are both better GC midfield options than Bennell.
Hodge and Ward. I think ward is due for a break out year and hodge is.... well.... hodge. Pity you cant put him in your defence.
No issue there with Boyd. But with no Ablett, bartel will get more attention. And Shuey is a little too injury prone for my liking.
I'd say A.davey. for the reason you said above.
mine is
adcock vs x ellis
cheers
4 players I had last year and 4 that disappointed me.. Sorry I can't choose one of the options lol
Selwood (Mids ) Petrie (Ruck) Hale (Fwds) + 125k
vs
Montagna (M) Jolly (R) Petrie (F) + 3.3k
bit stumped on this one..
GotTheGoodes
Bloods
- Moderator
- #117
Ooooh, that's a tough one mate.
You got the MPP in the rucks? (i.e. Tippett J). If so then the obvious choice I would think would be Petrie (F). I've got Jolly in my ruck at the moment and am starting to think Tippett FWD & Goldstien 2nd ruck (with Tippett J MPP) will save me some cash and give me some flexibility too.
I'm liking Selwood (post-ablett) over Montagna (post media circus) too.
Strictly out of those 2 options tho I'd go the 1st simply thanks to Selwood & the extra cash.
Hearing that J Tip possibly won't play much is a bit of a waste on the bench I'm guessing. Freaking tough.. eats up all my money with the jolly move.
Petrie or Warnock? MPP not a consideration.
Think Warnock is going to have a big season but Petrie is considerably cheaper.
Think Warnock is going to have a big season but Petrie is considerably cheaper.
Warnock as Petrie is a risk with his foot, I also thought that Warnock had a strong finish to last season. Watch the pre season form though.
Pavlich + Ward + Broughton
Sylvia + Anthony + Grimes
Higgins + Boak + Grimes
Aw Knighta21, you of all people know that LeCras kicked 12J riewoldt did
Convenient Amnesia mate?
LeCras's dozen embarrasses Essendon
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/07/17/2956794.htm
kreuze control
Team Captain
the 1st combo is probs the safest bet id take the 2nd one purely as it has the most upside.
scully vs. conca?
dlanod
Moderator
- Sep 14, 2006
- 53,662
- 85,160
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- GWS; CCMariners; NQCowboys; Ravens
- Moderator
- #123
Or because he'd already been mentioned...? And then clarified to speak of key forwards specifically?
Mark Le Cres?
J riewoldt did
Alternatively don't mind the actual conversation and continue on your point scoring rampage.
Strahany
Premiership Player
Franklin vs Rioli vs Didak
Cash is not an issue and I have no other Collingwood or Hawthorn fowards either on the field or in reserve.
Thoughts?
Cash is not an issue and I have no other Collingwood or Hawthorn fowards either on the field or in reserve.
Thoughts?
- Status
Similar threads
