Player X vs Y

[Hairy Lager]

Cotch at 490k this week or libba at 540ishk in a couple of weeks?
Who's better value?

Leaning towards libba being worth the extra 50k...

Oh yeah!! There is the answer I've been looking for, libba I'll wait for, Gray next week.

 

[soyy]

Tossing up between JPK and Ward as my last upgrade. I already have 3 swans so leaning ever so slightly towards Ward. What do you guys think?

I'm tossing up between these two also. Both similar price, both consistent, both high ceilings. However I have Parker as my only other swan and am leaning towards JPK just because he's in the better team. I don't think you can go wrong either way with these two, just go with your gut.

My other decision this week is who out of Shenton and Langdon do I trade out this week. The other will go for Mitchell when he comes back and bottoms out. If I trade Shenton I will have Langdon as Def cover, if Langdon goes I'll have no Def cover until I trade in Mitchell in a few weeks. Thoughts everyone?

 

[saintbatty]

If your plan it to trade both Langdon and Shenton, then Langdon should go first before he loses $, whereas Shenton still has a little growing in value to go.

 

[The_Steadier]

Yeah I'd go Libba. Providing Griffen isn't out for too long as having Griff in the side helps Libbas scoring

I agree- libba actually scored pretty well last week given the absolute mare he had- only 12 touches and 3 FA, 0 FF... still peeled off 60 something- the way he plays is built for SC scoring.

Once he gets 100 games under his belt he'll be unstoppable.

 

[SSwans2011]

Trade out McGovern or Tex? The other one will be gone in the next two weeks.

 

[toxic]

Trade out McGovern or Tex? The other one will be gone in the next two weeks.

depends for who and why?

what are there break evens?

 

[SSwans2011]

depends for who and why?

what are there break evens?

Upgrading one of them to Buddy is my current idea. Other one will be upgraded to Gray in a week or 2.

McGovern - 54. (vs. Sydney - might man up on Tippett or another key forward.)
Tex - 69. (vs. GWS)

 

[toxic]

Upgrading one of them to Buddy is my current idea. Other one will be upgraded to Gray in a week or 2.

McGovern - 54. (vs. Sydney - might man up on Tippett or another key forward.)
Tex - 69. (vs. GWS)

Tex more likely to go huge V GWS this week.

So if one has to go its McG

however i read somewhere that the forecast was monsoon for swans v eagles, mite make buddy not as attractive but don't quote me on the weather aspect

 

[SSwans2011]

Tex more likely to go huge V GWS this week.

So if one has to go its McG

however i read somewhere that the forecast was monsoon for swans v eagles, mite make buddy not as attractive but don't quote me on the weather aspect

Yeah, I heard that too. Might take Dusty, but I'm not sure if that will leave me with enough money for Gray next week. I know the difference in Buddy and Dusty is pretty tight, but that 15k or so might be important.

That's what I thought in regards to the Tex, McGovern. I was going to trade Tex until I saw that the Crows has GWS.

 

[aflcliche]

Dal Santo or Cotchin in for Gaff or Daisy?

 

[SSwans2011]

Dal Santo or Cotchin in for Gaff or Daisy?

Cotchin in, Daisy out.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Simpson and Gray

v

McVeigh and Roughead/Hawkins

 

[The_Steadier]

Simpson and Gray

v

McVeigh and Roughead/Hawkins

The first one by a mile

 

[Jiska]

Kersten vs Sweet Jesus? Ignore DPP, purely scoring consistency at F7.

Gingy krk004 Kadog @anyone else?

 

[Hairy Lager]

Kersten vs Sweet Jesus? Ignore DPP, purely scoring consistency at F7.

Gingy krk004 Kadog @anyone else?

Kersten, position is his for the taking.

 

[Kadog]

Kersten vs Sweet Jesus? Ignore DPP, purely scoring consistency at F7.

Gingy krk004 Kadog @anyone else?

For scoring consistency & JS I'd say Kersten. Hard to gauge HC off one game.

 

[Jiska]

How about Rockliff vs JPK?

 

[Hairy Lager]

How about Rockliff vs JPK?

Who are your other premo mids, if all consistent scores with no swing type scores
go the riskier option, if the opposite go the other...or as I like to say if you're gonna
be a bear, be a grizzly bear!!!

 

[Kadog]

How about Rockliff vs JPK?

Ohhh tough one.

Rocky by a nose hair

 

[GAsnr]

Ohhh tough one.

Rocky by a nose hair

If it makes a difference, JPK will be 5-10k cheaper than Rocky next week . That pretty much evens them out in terms of nose hair density.

 

[Jiska]

Who are your other premo mids, if all consistent scores with no swing type scores
go the riskier option, if the opposite go the other...or as I like to say if you're gonna
be a bear, be a grizzly bear!!!

GAJ, Pendles, Jelwood, Fyfe, Beams, Goddard, Swallow

Rocky can obviously go big, but he can go small too. JPK you just lock in for 110-130 every week.

 

[Hairy Lager]

GAJ, Pendles, Jelwood, Fyfe, Beams, Goddard, Swallow

Rocky can obviously go big, but he can go small too. JPK you just lock in for 110-130 every week.

You need a excitement machine to spice up your SC mids, welcome Rocky...5 solids there
already + Rocky.

 

[GAsnr]

You need a excitement machine to spice up your SC mids, welcome Rocky...5 solids there
already + Rocky.

The stress must add a whole new level to the SC game.

GAJ, Pendles, Jelwood, Fyfe, Beams, Goddard, Swallow

Rocky can obviously go big, but he can go small too. JPK you just lock in for 110-130 every week.

And with that, I know who I'd settle on.

 

[Benson FC]

Rockliff vs Fyfe...

My pro's for Fyfe: great run home, consistent, star
Cons: could be rested.. Not much else

My pro's for rockliff: going exclusively for league wins, and of the top 4 in my 3 leagues, no one has rocky, everyone has Fyfe
Cons: can be up and down

What's BF's thoughts? Am I looking too much into this POD factor?

 

[Benson FC]

Rockliff vs Fyfe...

My pro's for Fyfe: great run home, consistent, star
Cons: could be rested.. Not much else

My pro's for rockliff: going exclusively for league wins, and of the top 4 in my 3 leagues, no one has rocky, everyone has Fyfe
Cons: can be up and down

What's BF's thoughts? Am I looking too much into this POD factor?

My mids as they stand at the moment