Player X vs Y

[gh172]

I'd take a chance with Wright.

Shiels or Thomas?

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

 

[GPW1]

Rockliff or Barlow?

Barlow doesn't seem to get mentioned too much.

 

[GOAUS!]

I'd take a chance with Wright.

Shiels or Thomas?

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

Haven't looked too much into Shiels but I reckon Daisy has a higher ceiling.

Rockliff or Barlow?

Barlow doesn't seem to get mentioned too much.

Rockliff in a heartbeat. Not even sure whether Barlow will be a top 10 mid this year.

Tyson (M5) and Higgins (F6) vs. Macrae (M5) and Rohan (F6).

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Haven't looked too much into Shiels but I reckon Daisy has a higher ceiling.



Rockliff in a heartbeat. Not even sure whether Barlow will be a top 10 mid this year.

Tyson (M5) and Higgins (F6) vs. Macrae (M5) and Rohan (F6).

Tyson & Higgins, although by the tiniest of margains. I think with the lack of forward rookies Higgins is a valuable pick. Tyson & Rohan spend money elsewhere? food for thought.

 

[GOAUS!]

Tyson & Higgins, although by the tiniest of margains. I think with the lack of forward rookies Higgins is a valuable pick. Tyson & Rohan spend money elsewhere? food for thought.

Yeah I'm just worried about those rookies.

 

[Test Tickle]

Yeah I'm just worried about those rookies.

My Fwd and Def rookies are where they belong, on the bench!

 

[GOAUS!]

Pavlich vs Zorko vs Gunston vs Gray.

 

[SugarRayRichard]

Pavlich vs Zorko vs Gunston vs Gray.

Pavlich. We know what he is capable of...

Hicks VS Grundy VS McIntosh

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Pavlich vs Zorko vs Gunston vs Gray.

I'll ask for others opinions on that also.

For me im not sold on Pav not a risk im willing to take unless i can get convinced. Zorko im 50/50 (will he play midfield?). Gunston i like although can he take a step forward in his SC scoring this year? i think he can. Gray i dont know why but i really like him... full pre-season more midfield time, although im not confident on this.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Pavlich. We know what he is capable of...

Hicks VS Grundy VS McIntosh

Neither of them. Probably Hickey if i was too choose one.

 

[Kitty_Lover]

Hey All....long time, first time.... Wanting to get some thoughts on the forwards.... Currently leaning away from Buddy.... Thoughts on:

Buddy v Gunston v Hawkins

Cheers in advance

 

[Big Fozza]

Hey All....long time, first time.... Wanting to get some thoughts on the forwards.... Currently leaning away from Buddy.... Thoughts on:

Buddy v Gunston v Hawkins

Cheers in advance

Hard to compare those 3. Hawkins in different price bracket. imo gunston is the safest choice. Buddy could do anything. Hawkins could easily get back to his 2012 form and be close to a keeper

Sent from my GT-I9507 using Tapatalk

 

[Rack Watts]

Barlow doesn't seem to get mentioned too much.

Barlow for dreamteam, Rockliff for SC.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Pavlich [F5] & Rohan [F6] v Caddy [F5] & Higgins [F6] & 40k

 

[NormaJeanHawk]

Pavlich [F5] & Rohan [F6] v Caddy [F5] & Higgins [F6] & 40k

caddy, think his numbers will increase as he gets used 2 more midfield and game time.
McVeigh and aish vs cotchin b.martin?

 

[kangaroos3]

Just trying to get an idea of who everyone thinks are the best forwards for F3 and F4.

I'm struggling for these two spots also!!

 

[timtamWB]

caddy, think his numbers will increase as he gets used 2 more midfield and game time.
McVeigh and aish vs cotchin b.martin?

McVeigh and Aish. Cotchin and McVeigh roughly the same, Aish streets ahead of B. Martin.

 

[timtamWB]

Pavlich [F5] & Rohan [F6] v Caddy [F5] & Higgins [F6] & 40k

I'd go Caddy and Higgins, I just hate the look of Rohan in the team.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

I'd go Caddy and Higgins, I just hate the look of Rohan in the team.

Cheers, agreed.

 

[NormaJeanHawk]

McVeigh and Aish. Cotchin and McVeigh roughly the same, Aish streets ahead of B. Martin.

there goes my 5-0-5 setup

 

[GOAUS!]

I'll ask for others opinions on that also.

For me im not sold on Pav not a risk im willing to take unless i can get convinced. Zorko im 50/50 (will he play midfield?). Gunston i like although can he take a step forward in his SC scoring this year? i think he can. Gray i dont know why but i really like him... full pre-season more midfield time, although im not confident on this.

Only one I'm not picking out of that is Gray. I'm seriously considering Gunston over Pav who I currently have in the team.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Only one I'm not picking out of that is Gray. I'm seriously considering Gunston over Pav who I currently have in the team.

I have had them all, have Gunston now.

 

[Bristol]

Jarryd Roughead vs. Chad Wingard

 

[Yoda_]

Jarryd Roughead vs. Chad Wingard

Roughead hands down

 

[Yoda_]

Cotchin or Deledio?

Mundy or Barlow?

Cunnington or Ziebell? (just for lolz)