Training Pre-season updates 2025.

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Can’t agree re Noble - a fit and firing Markov had pace and more compared to Noble as evidenced by his inclusion in the GF.
Noble was more vulnerable in 1-on-1 situations. Markov’s height and strength was an advantage in able to better contest.

Selectors got it right in my opinion for the overall balance/role at that time.

Having said that, I think Noble is by far the better player. More consistent, more games, rarely dropped.

I’ll miss him.
 
How close is De Goey to full training? Another poor preseason is quite bad news
He’s basically there. Without knowing the exact extent of what was going on last year I think it’s safe to assume it was a lot worse than we were lead to believe. His program for 2025 would have been mapped out probably to the hr when he was in Doha and there’s been nothing to indicate that he’s gone off course at any point (the progressions are obvious). His pre-season to me at least has built impeccably and your statement on the quality has no basis in fact.
 
Noble was more vulnerable in 1-on-1 situations. Markov’s height and strength was an advantage in able to better contest.

Selectors got it right in my opinion for the overall balance/role at that time.

Having said that, I think Noble is by far the better player. More consistent, more games, rarely dropped.

I’ll miss him.
The bolded was the difference. Like you I think Noble is the better overall footballer, but the recruitments of Perryman and Houston highlighted a belief we needed to upgrade that role. Markov and Noble can both be extremely valuable in our pursuit of 17 in 2025 still (even if it isn’t in a traditional on field capacity). Markov brings a lot of cultural intangibles and without Noble departing we don’t have Houston.
 
Noble was more vulnerable in 1-on-1 situations. Markov’s height and strength was an advantage in able to better contest.

Selectors got it right in my opinion for the overall balance/role at that time.

Having said that, I think Noble is by far the better player. More consistent, more games, rarely dropped.

I’ll miss him.

Completely agree with this. We needed Markov's height against Melbourne and GWS in the prelim and there's no way you could make unforced changes to that team at that stage.

Markov leaving his man in the prelim and contesting that ball on the wing, winning it and kicking it to McStay for a goal swung back the momentum. Saved an almost certain goal too.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The bolded was the difference. Like you I think Noble is the better overall footballer, but the recruitments of Perryman and Houston highlighted a belief we needed to upgrade that role. Markov and Noble can both be extremely valuable in our pursuit of 17 in 2025 still (even if it isn’t in a traditional on field capacity). Markov brings a lot of cultural intangibles and without Noble departing we don’t have Houston.
Not just aerial. Late that season we lost to Brisbane when Moore was out. They were getting soft drops at the top of the goal square and killed us front and centre. Noble wasn't covering off his man properly.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Training Pre-season updates 2025.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top