TheClokes
Cancelled
Why is Chris Judd rated the best player in the league, and Adam Goodes isn't?
What has Judd got that Goodes hasn't got?
What has Judd got that Goodes hasn't got?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Question concerning Judd and Goodes
- Thread starter TheClokes
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Where do we start?????
Because if Judd is the best in the league the best Goodes can be is 2nd best (can't have two players who are the 'best'). He probably isn't 2nd best and is more like maybe top 10.
I rate Goodes ahead of Judd... It does not mean I devalve Judd.
Goodes is a freak.
Best Player in the AFL goes to J. Brown (Brisbane) - Super fresk ...
I was wondering where all the Judd threads had disappeared to, thankfully for this thread has revived it 
- Banned
- #6
This always happens to players that play on through injury.....they fight and fight to play even though they are in pain and theres one thing they know.....there reputation as a footballer will take a belting.....
Judd and to a lesser note Ball, have copped this all year.
Judd is a 2 time All-Australian
Brownlow Medalist
Norm Smith Medalist
TEAM CAPTAIN!!!
And he turns 24 in 2 days!!!
Hes only going to get better.....
The guys injured, give him a go.....yes Goodes is a good player, pardon the pun.....but at there best.....Goodes doesn't even come close!!!
Judd and to a lesser note Ball, have copped this all year.
Judd is a 2 time All-Australian
Brownlow Medalist
Norm Smith Medalist
TEAM CAPTAIN!!!
And he turns 24 in 2 days!!!
Hes only going to get better.....
The guys injured, give him a go.....yes Goodes is a good player, pardon the pun.....but at there best.....Goodes doesn't even come close!!!
Judd's got LRT's Norm Smith Medal.
Goodes has a beard and two girlfriends..he also gets to live in the most beautiful city in the country..and he gets to play for the best footy club in the country...he also doesnt need to associate with druggies.
Goodes has a beard and two girlfriends..he also gets to live in the most beautiful city in the country..and he gets to play for the best footy club in the country...he also doesnt need to associate with druggies.
This separates them .....
Goodes also has 2 AA's but can flash 2 Brownlow's also.
TEAM CAPTAIN !!!
also one of those incredibly important Rising Star awards.
..and Judd hasnt even come close to making the indigenous team of the century !
Twigley is better than whatever the two birds Goodes has. I don't even know who they are but Twigley would still be better than them.
- Banned
- #14
Thats a bit of a low blow Bollox.....
Do u honestly think that your club or any AFL club for that matter doesn't have at least a few "Party Drug" takers???
Be honest now.....
Sydney the most beautiful city in the country?! you cant be serious, thats the funniest thing I've heard along with Sydney being the best footy club, you really brought the jokes out in that post
- Banned
- #17
Twigley is old pork these days...she isnt ageing well and will soon be looking to fix her short term mammary loss.
Goodes has a healthy turnover of Eastern Suburbs Princesses...the type u dont see much of on the production lines in Geelong.
- May 5, 2006
- 62,757
- 70,116
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Chris Judd is better than Adam Goodes, and arguably the best player in the league.
Hope that answers your query.
- Sep 10, 2006
- 20,982
- 23,029
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Liverpool FC
I would argue the opposite. I think Goodes is more damaging at his best than Judd is however Judd has been much more consistent than Goodes (when he isn't injured anyway).
Consistency counts for a lot in my book so I would probably have Judd ahead (just) at this stage.
Judd only has one Brownlow, Goodes doesn't have only one. There's a start
Seriously though, how dare any of you question Judd's greatness and suggest a challenger to the throne!!Judd only has one Brownlow, Goodes doesn't have only one. There's a start
Every second day there's a new challenger.
Look at all these WC fans telling us how much better Judd is. Atleast we know it wouldn't be biased
Similar threads
- Poll
