Rate my Super Coach team part II

[Absolute Gun]

Very Nice glad to see you dont have ablett, he will decline this season coz he has a brownlow now and doesnt need 2 hog the ball as much. for your rookies in midfield i would try get moribito or scully and in the ruck warnock is worth a look. mayby gray for westhoff? it will free up some money and the are similar players. But overall really good work, looks like you put a bit of time into it 7.5/10

Riewoldt Cpt and Del or Selwood Vice.

Thanks

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Ok so i have tweaked my team a little:
In: Podsaidly, Krakouer
Out: Rockliff, Baker

And im thinking of trading Chris Masten for Dalziel (will he be a 22 game player?) or McViegh (has heaps to prove could be improver). Although Masten has been great in pre-season is this the year he blossoms?

BACKLINE
Drummond | Hodge | Kennelly | Krakouer | Malceski | Hunt | Ladson | Jamison | Waters
MIDFIELD
Selwood | Vince | Cooney | Ball | Masten | Trengove | Martin | Morabito
RUCKS
Jolly | Hille | McEvoy | Warnock
FOWARDS
Riewoldt | Brown | Tippett | Hall | Medhurst | Westhoff | Ballantyne | Reid | Podsaidly

Riewouldt Captain and Selwood VC.

Tips will be much appreciated.

 

[thomas_m18]

First time posting on here.. Your thoughts would be much appreciated.

Backs: Duffield, Grimes, Hurn, Lake, Kennelly, Malceski, Waters (Maguire, D.Grimes)
Mids: Swan, Selwood, Mitchell, Armitage, Trengrove, Jetta (Shuey, Moles)
Rucks: Sandi, NicNat
Forwards: Chapman, Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Hall, Ziebell, Rohan (Pods, Rockliff)

Hmmmm, hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.

Defenders

Different defense, I guess. Not having Goddard is suicidal a little risky, but I guess he does cost a lot.

Hurn? Should MAINTAIN his average, dunno what else he could do with it though. Same with Grimes, same with Lake.

Kennelly and Malceski are bargain picks, good picks. Waters is a cheap pick, everywhere.

Mids

Not having Ablett is also suicidal also risky. First 3 look good picks, unsure about Armitage. Looked good so far, but can't help and think there are better choices around. I'd pick Martin over Trengove any day, and Barlow over Jetta.

Rucks

Sandi is good, but can't help but think Hille is a better choice than Nic Nat. But hey, that's just my thinking.

Forwards

Chapman is iffy. I can't help but think he will burn you. Next 4 are good picks (Higgins is VERY underrated). I am tossing up between Ziebell and Medhurst, can't split them. Rohan, if Sydney give him the chance, could be awesome.


Any thoughts on my team?

Thoughts anyone?

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Macdonald, Malceski (think he’s good to go), Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis

MID: Ablett, Swan, Dal Santo, Ball, Barlow, Martin
RES: Bastinac, Shuey

RUCK: Sandilands, Hille
RES: Skipper (should play a lot, without Taylor around) , McCauley (don’t give a crap about 4th ruck, useless to me)

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Brent Harvey, Franklin (think I have adequate coverage, if Gumby/Pods plays), Jarrad Waite, Hall (hoping he fires,) Rockliff
RES: Gumbleton (will probably start round 1 unless Pods impresses before then), Podsiadly

The main change since last time is that I have downgraded quite a few players, meaning I had enough cash to bring Harvey in for Dangerfield.

Makes my forwards look better, but...

 

[Defina18]

Hey everyone, Just wanting some feedback/advice on my current supercoach team. Cheers lads.


Backs: Drummond, Bock, Hodge, Carazzo, Malceski, Hunt, Waters
(P.Davis, M.Maquire)

Midfield: G.Ablett, Dal Santo, J.Selwood, L.Ball, Trengrove, D.Martin
(Barlow, Banner)

Rucks: Ottens, Hille
(Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards Riewoldt, R.O'Keef, Franklin, LeCras, Tippet, B.Hall, G.Rohan
(Gumbleton, Podsliadly)

 

[bean dailey]

Feedback and rating would be much appreciated!

Backs - Goddard Enright Duffield Waite Malceski Hunt Ladson - Waters Maguire

Mids - Ablett Pendlebury Mitchell M McVeigh Trengove Shuey - Banner Barlow

Rucks - Sandilands Naitanui - Skipper Roughead

Forwards - Riewoldt Davis Pavlich Franklin Dangerfield Ballantyne Rockliff - Hitchcock Tarrant

 

[adam10]

Hey everyone, Just wanting some feedback/advice on my current supercoach team. Cheers lads.


Backs: Drummond, Bock, Hodge, Carazzo, Malceski, Hunt, Waters
(P.Davis, M.Maquire)

Midfield: G.Ablett, Dal Santo, J.Selwood, L.Ball, Trengrove, D.Martin
(Barlow, Banner)

Rucks: Ottens, Hille
(Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards Riewoldt, R.O'Keef, Franklin, LeCras, Tippet, B.Hall, G.Rohan
(Gumbleton, Podsliadly)

****ing Shit team.

 

[thomas_m18]

Hey everyone, Just wanting some feedback/advice on my current supercoach team. Cheers lads.


Backs: Drummond, Bock, Hodge, Carazzo, Malceski, Hunt, Waters
(P.Davis, M.Maquire)

Midfield: G.Ablett, Dal Santo, J.Selwood, L.Ball, Trengrove, D.Martin
(Barlow, Banner)

Rucks: Ottens, Hille
(Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards Riewoldt, R.O'Keef, Franklin, LeCras, Tippet, B.Hall, G.Rohan
(Gumbleton, Podsliadly)

****ing Shit team.

Wait, what? "****ing Shit team." What's so bad?

EDIT: Sorry, you're probably trollan. Carry on then

 

[foleyisagun]

thomas_m18, you have a got side but seems inconsistent. like the forward line, hate the defense. rucks and mids decent but wouldnt be having ball in SC.

my team:

backs: goddard newman enright hodge gilbee greenwood maguire
webberley silvagni

mids: ablett selwood cooney cotchin trengove martin
banner moles

rucks: sandilands naitanui
skipper lobbe

forwards: goodes riewolds pavlich tippett murphy dangerfield rockliff
hitchcock roberts

cheers for any advice

 

[Mirsin]

thomas_m18, you have a got side but seems inconsistent. like the forward line, hate the defense. rucks and mids decent but wouldnt be having ball in SC.

my team:

backs: goddard newman enright hodge gilbee greenwood maguire
webberley silvagni

mids: ablett selwood cooney cotchin trengove martin
banner moles

rucks: sandilands naitanui
skipper lobbe

forwards: goodes riewolds pavlich tippett murphy dangerfield rockliff
hitchcock roberts

cheers for any advice

Not bad at all. Your almost there! You could use a bit more beefing up in the midfield. Ive said it a few times that you cannot depend upon Goodes to produce the scores he had last year in the forward line. May not be far off, but will definatly drop in price. Down-grade him and use the spare cash to upgrade Cooney or Cotchin. Pick up Goodes again later in the season.

 

[foleyisagun]

Downgrading Goodes is a good idea in theory, however i would have to downgrade him to someone like Waite to make enough cash to upgrade Cooney or Cotchin to someone subtantially better than them. Given they are both set to go up in price and score well, maybe its better just to cop Goodes' price fall and keep them both?

 

[thomas_m18]

thomas_m18, you have a got side but seems inconsistent. like the forward line, hate the defense. rucks and mids decent but wouldnt be having ball in SC.

When you say you hate my defense, does that mean it's bad, or do you just hate it?

Traded Ball for Cooney, Dal Santo for Selwood, Waite for Dangerfield (that earlier team must've been wrong)

 

[foleyisagun]

When you say you hate my defense, does that mean it's bad, or do you just hate it?

Traded Ball for Cooney, Dal Santo for Selwood, Waite for Dangerfield (that earlier team must've been wrong)

well, apart from Hodge and Drummond, and possibly Bock, no one in that defense is going to give you consistent scores. Carazzo is a SC dud, whilst the others will be inconsistent and won't score too well anyway. I'd look at taking money from your forward line and puting it into ur defence

 

[thomas_m18]

well, apart from Hodge and Drummond, and possibly Bock, no one in that defense is going to give you consistent scores. Carazzo is a SC dud, whilst the others will be inconsistent and won't score too well anyway. I'd look at taking money from your forward line and puting it into ur defence

Oh, Oh, Oh.

You read the other guys team.

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Macdonald, Malceski (think he’s good to go), Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis

MID: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Cooney, Barlow, Martin
RES: Bastinac, Shuey

RUCK: Sandilands, Hille
RES: Skipper (should play a lot, without Taylor around) , McCauley (don’t give a crap about 4th ruck, useless to me)

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Brent Harvey, Franklin (think I have adequate coverage, if Gumby/Pods plays), Dangerfield, Hall (hoping he fires,) Rockliff
RES: Gumbleton (will probably start round 1 unless Pods impresses before then), Podsiadly

That is my team.

 

[foleyisagun]

ohh sorry mate.

that is actually a much better team. only query is whether macdonald is worth it from the start. Having Hille and Harvery both coming back from injury is also a risk. otherwise great team

 

[Mirsin]

Downgrading Goodes is a good idea in theory, however i would have to downgrade him to someone like Waite to make enough cash to upgrade Cooney or Cotchin to someone subtantially better than them. Given they are both set to go up in price and score well, maybe its better just to cop Goodes' price fall and keep them both?

Goodes for Harvey (Kangaroos, avg 95) gives you an extra $107,900. That plus Cooney ($484,100) is $592,000! Judd, Selwood, Mitchell, Gibbs or Boyd are under that. I would recommend Mitchell as he is in good form . . . that and im a Hawks supporter.

 

[_RT_]

Posted my team earlier today and have spent the afternoon chopping and changing it a little so would appreciate any feedback.

Backs: Goddard Enright Hodge Stewart Malceski Hunt Farmer Waters Maguire
Mids: Swan Mitchell Deledio Armitage Trengove Martin Barlow Banner
Rucks: Sandilands Seaby Warnock Lobbe
Forwards: Riewoldt ROK Franklin Giansiracusa Hall Dangerfield Ballantyne Moore Rockliff

$26,500 leftover

Notes:
I think Stewart could be a real sleeper in the backline averaged 70 through NAB games which is 16 above last season, Farmer Waters Maguire will be rotated as 7th back depending on who is picked and in form. I know Seaby has been a poor scorer in the past but no-one has really scored well playing second fiddle to Cox but with him taking over 1st ruck at the Swans I believe he is excellent value. Barlow will only remain if he gets elevated, if not I have other options in mind, same goes with Moore & Rockliff if both are named round 1 they'll stay but I'm also keeping an eye on a couple of other rookie listed players who are in line for elevation.

So with that in mind feel free to tear my team to shreds.

 

[russea]

Oh, Oh, Oh.

You read the other guys team.

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Macdonald, Malceski (think he’s good to go), Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis

MID: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Cooney, Barlow, Martin
RES: Bastinac, Shuey

RUCK: Sandilands, Hille
RES: Skipper (should play a lot, without Taylor around) , McCauley (don’t give a crap about 4th ruck, useless to me)

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Brent Harvey, Franklin (think I have adequate coverage, if Gumby/Pods plays), Dangerfield, Hall (hoping he fires,) Rockliff
RES: Gumbleton (will probably start round 1 unless Pods impresses before then), Podsiadly

That is my team.

Defence looks good not sure on macdonald though....but could be a bargin pick

mids strong like them all

Rucks starting 2 are the sane as mine so

Fwds are good all strong and good coverage for buddy

so a very nice team but not as good as mine and ur gonna get smashed in the league and u no it

 

[russea]

repost just looking for diffrnt views

My newest team and i think im done any thoughts???

backs:Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Adcock, Malcheski, Hunt, Waters (Maguire, Silvagni)
Mids:Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Mitchell, Martin, Barlow (Banner,L.Jetta)
Rucks:Sandi, Hille (Warnock, Skipper)
Fwds:Riewoldt, Pav, Gia,Tippet, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rockliff (Gumby, Pods)

as always if u rate mine im sure to rate urs. Cheers

 

[joelselwood]

repost just looking for diffrnt views

My newest team and i think im done any thoughts???

backs:Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Adcock, Malcheski, Hunt, Waters (Maguire, Silvagni)
Mids:Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Mitchell, Martin, Barlow (Banner,L.Jetta)
Rucks:Sandi, Hille (Warnock, Skipper)
Fwds:Riewoldt, Pav, Gia,Tippet, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rockliff (Gumby, Pods)

as always if u rate mine im sure to rate urs. Cheers

No one is ever finished with their team mate!

Few comments. Firstly no H in malceski. Midfield star studded (bit biased!), but Barlow is an interesting one as a starter, continuing nab cup form as he is seems unlikely, though I'll probably be wrong. Personally don't know about gia.. seems to have a blinder then hide away for a few weeks. Good risks in ziebell, medhurst, waters and hille, if anything I would say there may be too many risks but who knows. Best of luck!

To be honest I have no idea about my team! Comments appreciated

BACKS: Drummond, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Malceski, Waters (Roberton, Davies)

MIDS: Pendlebury, Bartel, Watson, Vince, Greenwood, Martin (Jetta, Banner)

RUCKS: Sandilands, Warnock (Lobbe, Skipper)

FWDS: Riewoldt, Pavlich, S.Johnson, Franklin, LeCras, Dangerfield, Rockliff (Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly)

47K to spend

Thanks guys .

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Oh, Oh, Oh.

You read the other guys team.

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Macdonald, Malceski (think he’s good to go), Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis

MID: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Cooney, Barlow, Martin
RES: Bastinac, Shuey

RUCK: Sandilands, Hille
RES: Skipper (should play a lot, without Taylor around) , McCauley (don’t give a crap about 4th ruck, useless to me)

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Brent Harvey, Franklin (think I have adequate coverage, if Gumby/Pods plays), Dangerfield, Hall (hoping he fires,) Rockliff
RES: Gumbleton (will probably start round 1 unless Pods impresses before then), Podsiadly

That is my team.

good Overall but just a few tips IMO
-Harvey is gunna b 32 soon and looks 'tired' 2 me he is becoming susceptible 2 injury, i had him untill i did some research.
- Cotchin is not 100% and is doubtful to play more than 15 games i think,. especially at the business end.
- I dont think Ablett is worth it at the moment he wont b such a hog this year becuase he finally got his brownlow
- If you can i would go Shuey for Morabito
-Cooney is a top buy has had his 1st full preseason ever and is over his brownlow hangover plus the dogs should be strong
-Finally McDonald tends 2 be a bit of a punch player and tends to have some poor games although he has hig effictivness maybe a swap Knelley or Jamison can free up some cash.

What do you guys think of my team?

BACKLINE
Drummond | Hodge | Kennelly | Krakouer | Malceski | Hunt | Ladson | Jamison | Waters
MIDFIELD
Selwood | Vince | Cooney | Ball | Masten | Trengove | Martin | Morabito
RUCKS
Jolly | Hille | McEvoy | Warnock
FOWARDS
Riewoldt | Brown | Tippett | Hall | Medhurst | Westhoff | Ballantyne | Reid | Podsaidly

Riewouldt Captain and Selwood VC.

Tips will be much appreciated.

 

[Spider Eater]

repost just looking for diffrnt views

My newest team and i think im done any thoughts???

backs:Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Adcock, Malcheski, Hunt, Waters (Maguire, Silvagni)
Mids:Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Mitchell, Martin, Barlow (Banner,L.Jetta)
Rucks:Sandi, Hille (Warnock, Skipper)
Fwds:Riewoldt, Pav, Gia,Tippet, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rockliff (Gumby, Pods)

as always if u rate mine im sure to rate urs. Cheers

Can you squeeze Lobbe in as your 4th ruckman, just to give you that option of switching Tippett into the ruck (of course you'd need stronger deph in the forwards to cover this move aswell)... otherwise why not just pick Tippett as a ruckman and pick a forward equal to Hille's value... surely a 300k forward will score more points overall than a 300k ruckman.

I also think you could be risking a 0 in your backline and forward line with Waters/Maguire/Silvagni (will Silvagni be upgraded from the rookie list?) &
Rockliff/Gumby/Pods so be sure to keep an eye out that those guys play round 1.

On the positive side I must say I think you have selected your premiums really well & have a high scoring team their.

 

[Spider Eater]

No one is ever finished with their team mate!

Few comments. Firstly no H in malceski. Midfield star studded (bit biased!), but Barlow is an interesting one as a starter, continuing nab cup form as he is seems unlikely, though I'll probably be wrong. Personally don't know about gia.. seems to have a blinder then hide away for a few weeks. Good risks in ziebell, medhurst, waters and hille, if anything I would say there may be too many risks but who knows. Best of luck!

To be honest I have no idea about my team! Comments appreciated

BACKS: Drummond, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Malceski, Waters (Roberton, Davies)

MIDS: Pendlebury, Bartel, Watson, Vince, Greenwood, Martin (Jetta, Banner)

RUCKS: Sandilands, Warnock (Lobbe, Skipper)

FWDS: Riewoldt, Pavlich, S.Johnson, Franklin, LeCras, Dangerfield, Rockliff (Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly)

47K to spend

Thanks guys .

Solid for the main part I think.
Rucks seems a bit week, especially if Sandi or Warnock miss I don't think Lobbe or Skipper are going to come in and score enough to make up a for a 0 & I'm still unconvinced about starting with Rockliff and Waters on the ground but you might know better then me about them.
Glad to see someone with Stevie J, seems to do his best work early in the year so you might be rewarded.

 

[Spider Eater]

What do you guys think of my team?

BACKLINE
Drummond | Hodge | Kennelly | Krakouer | Malceski | Hunt | Ladson | Jamison | Waters
MIDFIELD
Selwood | Vince | Cooney | Ball | Masten | Trengove | Martin | Morabito
RUCKS
Jolly | Hille | McEvoy | Warnock
FOWARDS
Riewoldt | Brown | Tippett | Hall | Medhurst | Westhoff | Ballantyne | Reid | Podsaidly

Riewouldt Captain and Selwood VC.

Tips will be much appreciated.

Your team would be a perfect candidate to have Lobbe as your 4th ruckman so for injuries or players just not performing you can switch Tippett into there and play a Rockliff of your forward bench, especially if he carries his form into the season... & I see you don't have him but consider him as he scored 145 in NAB round 1 and had 28 touches and a goal V's Carlton in the NAB challenge game.

Overall your team is strong, your selection of Jamison interests me and I was thinking Westhoff might have a breakout year so your gambles could really pay off if your right.

 

[_RT_]

repost just looking for diffrnt views

My newest team and i think im done any thoughts???

backs:Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Adcock, Malcheski, Hunt, Waters (Maguire, Silvagni)
Mids:Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Mitchell, Martin, Barlow (Banner,L.Jetta)
Rucks:Sandi, Hille (Warnock, Skipper)
Fwds:Riewoldt, Pav, Gia,Tippet, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rockliff (Gumby, Pods)

as always if u rate mine im sure to rate urs. Cheers

I have a similar lineup in the backline differences being Adcock & Silvagni, not sure he'll play early as he is a rookie and Barlow looks like getting the nod. Like the idea of 4 rookies in the midfield as it allows for more money being spent at the top end. Hille could be boom or bust, will be interesting to see if he plays this week against the Tigers as most sides will be fielding sides close to their round 1 lineups, if he is in you've got a winner, if not it might not hurt to have a plan b lined up. Forward line looks good, only query would be to make sure that Rockliff Gumby & Pods are named round 1.

To be honest I have no idea about my team! Comments appreciated

BACKS: Drummond, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Malceski, Waters (Roberton, Davies)

MIDS: Pendlebury, Bartel, Watson, Vince, Greenwood, Martin (Jetta, Banner)

RUCKS: Sandilands, Warnock (Lobbe, Skipper)

FWDS: Riewoldt, Pavlich, S.Johnson, Franklin, LeCras, Dangerfield, Rockliff (Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly)

47K to spend

Thanks guys .

Waite isn't someone I'd go nowhere near, knee reco players invariably struggle first year back. Greenwood is a surprise in the midfield but could pay off with more midfield time looking likely. Warnock is another shock as second ruck, I hope you haven't fallen for the cheap price because he has been injury prone the last 2 seasons and could hurt you big time. As mentioned above make sure your 7, 8 & 9th forwards are named for round 1 especially your emergencies with Franklin suspended round 1.

Now here is my team reposted from the previous page:
Backs: Goddard Enright Hodge Stewart Malceski Hunt Farmer Waters Maguire
Mids: Swan Mitchell Deledio Armitage Trengove Martin Barlow Banner
Rucks: Sandilands Seaby Warnock Lobbe
Forwards: Riewoldt ROK Franklin Giansiracusa Hall Dangerfield Ballantyne Moore Rockliff

$26,500 leftover

Notes:
I think Stewart could be a real sleeper in the backline averaged 70 through NAB games which is 16 above last season, Farmer Waters Maguire will be rotated as 7th back depending on who is picked and in form. I know Seaby has been a poor scorer in the past but no-one has really scored well playing second fiddle to Cox but with him taking over 1st ruck at the Swans I believe he is excellent value. Barlow will only remain if he gets elevated, if not I have other options in mind, same goes with Moore & Rockliff if both are named round 1 they'll stay but I'm also keeping an eye on a couple of other rookie listed players who are in line for elevation.

So with that in mind feel free to tear my team to shreds.

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Your team would be a perfect candidate to have Lobbe as your 4th ruckman so for injuries or players just not performing you can switch Tippett into there and play a Rockliff of your forward bench, especially if he carries his form into the season... & I see you don't have him but consider him as he scored 145 in NAB round 1 and had 28 touches and a goal V's Carlton in the NAB challenge game.

Overall your team is strong, your selection of Jamison interests me and I was thinking Westhoff might have a breakout year so your gambles could really pay off if your right.

Yeah i had Rockliff But im a bit weary coz brisbane have not been fielding a full team and he my not get that same opportunity but i might swap him for reid and free up 68K and vince, tippet and westhoff will have huge seasons in my eyes. And jamison will step up he was on fire before getting injured last season but had a strong pre-season. Setanta will go in the fwd line and he will step up in defence.