Rate my SuperCoach team 2010

[IDIG]

Sorry don't have much time to reply but to infanti..round 1 you're looking at least a couple of donuts. buddy wont be there..burton has gone into surgery and tapscott and tdl arent certainties to play round 1. same goes with shephard...id have a 2nd look at it. trengove should be in there as well.

 

[IDIG]

to mclovin (superbad is an awesome movie). id go masten, and if u could squeeze a few k from somewhere id go shaw..finished last year like a madmen and could be back to his cheap kick best. not sure if wonna is injured and id keep an eye on myers and nicnat (which im sure u r)

 

[thomas_m18]

BACKS
Enright, Fisher, Hodge, (495k to spend on who?), Greenwood, Myers, Sheppard

res. Maguire, Davis

MIDFIELDS
Ablett, Goodes, Vince, Cooney, Dalziell (or masten?), Martin

res. Morabito, Bastinac

RUCKS
Jolly, Naitanui

Res. Lobbe, Fitzpatrick?

FORWARDS
Riewoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Tippett, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Wonnaemeri

res. Gumbleton, Dennis-Lane


help would be appreciated

Firstly, more people should rate. Would be a lot better for everyone.

Defenders

Top 4 seem good. With 495K, I would add Shannon Hurn, who should increase that average. Your last 3 are questionable, I am scratching my head a little. Greenwood and Myers are questionable, I have to say. I would personally, and this sorta contradicts what I said before, but here are the changes I would make.

Greenwood Out - Ladson In
Myers Out - Hunt In
Use spare cash to pick up McPhee or Macdonald. Even though Ladson and Hunt are both quite big risks, I think that both could score well for you. But do what you feel.

Midfielders

Ablett is Ablett. Class. I am unsure about Goodes, I'm not sure where his average will go this year. Consider Selwood, Gibbs, Pendlebury or ROK. I am sure that Goodes will probably be a good choice, but does he have good upside compared to the ones I named? Tell me exactly why Goodes is in that midfield, and I will see if there is a case for him. Bernie Vince is good, don't touch him, and Cooney should have a bigger year. Dalziell v Masten is quite a question, I think NAB Cup form should dictate the answer to that question. I would say Masten right now, but NAB Cup. Martin Good.

Morabito may be expensive on reserves, but if you can have him there, why the hell not?

Rucks
Hmmm, lemme think. Jolly's points will probably rise at Collingwood, but this will depend on how they decide to play Fraser, I guess. Watch the game tonight and see (It won't give a real indication, but see if he fits in at Collingwood).

NicNat? I am not sold. That game against Essendon was without Cox, on Bellchambers. I have Hille, who is about the same price.

If you can afford Warnock on that bench, do it. If not, Jackson Trengove, Ayce Cordy and Wayde Skipper are good choices.

Forwards

This is the best part of your team IMO. I cannot tell you to trade any of those guys, they are all guns. Make sure you have playing backup for Franklin (and maybe Wonna) and you'll be set.

My 2c.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Yeah looks good. Maguire may play, but for whom?

Put Clark at CHB, Patfull on the 3rd fwd and Merrett at FB. He only plays if there is an injury and normally stinks in SC

No probs with your ruck strategy - just a bugger that of Warnock goes OK it'll probably take another trade down elsewhere to make the upgrade worthwhile

Higgins? Not this year, and injury finds him, at some stage.

I know he's out for the first 3 rounds, bur for teams wanting only to win their league I still reckon Judd is essential.

What do you think of this..?

B: Goddard, Shaw, Hodge, Adcock, Krakouer, Hunt, Ladson
(Davis & Roberton)

M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Vince, Sylvia, Trengove, Martin
(Morabito & Banner)

R: Tippet, Warnock
(Lobbe & Trengove)

F:
Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Franklin, Hall, Dangerfield, TDL
(Podsiadly & Rockliff)

 

[thomas_m18]

Ok...first crack at this for the year...would love some feedback

BACKS

1. Goddard, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$613,600
2. Drummond, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$537,900
3. Hodge, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$485,600
4. Kennelly, TPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$320,700
5. Rance, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$276,200
6. Hunt, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$252,300
7. Waters, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$151,100
23. Davis, PPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200
24. Lisle, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200

MIDFIELDERS
8. Ablett, GPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$744,200
9. Mitchell, SPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$576,300
10. Thompson, SPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$496,200
11. Cooney, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$484,100
12. Kerr, DPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$410,900
13. Trengove, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$174,200
25. Banner, MPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200
26. Bastinac, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$94,200

RUCKS
14. Hille, DPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$311,300
15. White, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$290,100
27. Warnock, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$132,200
28. Trengove, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200

FORWARDS
16. Riewoldt, NPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$600,500
17. Didak, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$558,600
18. Johnson, SPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$473,700
19. Franklin, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$466,700
20. Knights, CPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$441,400
21. Hall, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$366,000
22. Rohan, GPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$154,200
29. Dennis-Lane, TPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$94,200
30. Podsiadly, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$83,400

Foofh. This team is far from there in my opinion.

Defenders

Let's start. Goddard is a good pick, best pick in defense. Drummond is injury prone, you can go ahead and take that risk, or you can bring in Corey Enright, Duffield, Newman, or someone else more stable.

Hodge and Kenelly are good. Rance seems a little iffy to me, I dunno how much his average can rise, I would go for Ladson at that range. Hunt sound good, coming off injury, but should slot back into that defense. Beau Waters is just ahead of Sheppard in my team, and for his price, he is pretty good value.

Midfield

Ehhh, Dunno. Ablett is good, Mitchell sounds good. I dunno about Scott Thompson or Kerr, I have to say that I think trading those two to Vince and Burgoyne would strengthen the team, but I'm just saying. Trengove is good, and I can't flaw Cooney.

Rucks

I think this is definately the weakest area of the team, but they could fire. I am unsure about Jesse White this year, what will he do? I think Hille is good, but White may be shaky. But they could be risks worth taking. Definately keep a close eye on this position

Forwards

Some ugly sights to me here.

Riewoldt is a gun, so he stays. Didak seems a little iffy to me, but that is more personal prejudice than anything, since Didak pisses me off.

Johnson is a no-no in my eyes, dodgy hip, inconsistency. Bring Tippett in.

Franklin is good, as long as you have back up.

Knights? I am a little unsure as to whether he or LeCras is the better bet this year. Research both and make your decision.

Barry Hall is making me cringe a little. He could be very up and down at Bulldogs, they have other ways of scoring without him. Consider Dangerfield or Ziebell

I am hearing huge things about Rohan, but I dunno this year. He should average quite well, and as you're 7th forward, I doubt you expect much. Check NAB Cup.

If you make the changes I suggest, tell me how much money you have left. You could afford an Ottens, maybe even a Kreuzer in the rucks if you traded White.

 

[mclovin32]

Firstly, more people should rate. Would be a lot better for everyone.

Defenders

Top 4 seem good. With 495K, I would add Shannon Hurn, who should increase that average. Your last 3 are questionable, I am scratching my head a little. Greenwood and Myers are questionable, I have to say. I would personally, and this sorta contradicts what I said before, but here are the changes I would make.

Greenwood Out - Ladson In
Myers Out - Hunt In
Use spare cash to pick up McPhee or Macdonald. Even though Ladson and Hunt are both quite big risks, I think that both could score well for you. But do what you feel.

Midfielders

Ablett is Ablett. Class. I am unsure about Goodes, I'm not sure where his average will go this year. Consider Selwood, Gibbs, Pendlebury or ROK. I am sure that Goodes will probably be a good choice, but does he have good upside compared to the ones I named? Tell me exactly why Goodes is in that midfield, and I will see if there is a case for him. Bernie Vince is good, don't touch him, and Cooney should have a bigger year. Dalziell v Masten is quite a question, I think NAB Cup form should dictate the answer to that question. I would say Masten right now, but NAB Cup. Martin Good.

Morabito may be expensive on reserves, but if you can have him there, why the hell not?

Rucks
Hmmm, lemme think. Jolly's points will probably rise at Collingwood, but this will depend on how they decide to play Fraser, I guess. Watch the game tonight and see (It won't give a real indication, but see if he fits in at Collingwood).

NicNat? I am not sold. That game against Essendon was without Cox, on Bellchambers. I have Hille, who is about the same price.

If you can afford Warnock on that bench, do it. If not, Jackson Trengove, Ayce Cordy and Wayde Skipper are good choices.

Forwards

This is the best part of your team IMO. I cannot tell you to trade any of those guys, they are all guns. Make sure you have playing backup for Franklin (and maybe Wonna) and you'll be set.

My 2c.

thanks for that
Will try and fit in hunt and ladson

i had goodes in midfield to swap into my forward line incase of an injury to either pav, dangerfield, or zeibell. that way i can put in morabito incase there out.
good idea or should i change it?

and cheers ill keep an eye on wonaemirri

 

[thomas_m18]

What do you think of this..?

B: Goddard, Shaw, Hodge, Adcock, Krakouer, Hunt, Ladson
(Davis & Roberton)

M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Vince, Sylvia, Trengove, Martin
(Morabito & Banner)

R: Tippet, Warnock
(Lobbe & Trengove)

F:
Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Franklin, Hall, Dangerfield, TDL
(Podsiadly & Rockliff)

Alright Unknown lemme see.

Backs look solid, very solid. Unsure about Krakouer, but don't know enough to tell you what to do. Only player I would trade to is Kenelly, which could free up cash, but that would give you three players who have been out of the game for a very long time (4 if you count Adcock)

Mids seem alright. Top 3 are class acts, Sylvia sounds as if he should have a big year, and the rookies are the standard now.

Your rucks obviously aren't a huge focus, but Tippett should be big this year, and Warnock will play A LOT.

6 of those 7 forwards are pretty good to me, I am unsure about Hall, good or bad? He is a big, big, big, big, big risk, he may pay off, he may not. Is to be seen really.

 

[thomas_m18]

thanks for that
Will try and fit in hunt and ladson

i had goodes in midfield to swap into my forward line incase of an injury to either pav, dangerfield, or zeibell. that way i can put in morabito incase there out.
good idea or should i change it?

and cheers ill keep an eye on wonaemirri

Hmmmm. I see. You could put O'keefe In there, but both are just as good, so either's fine, I guess.

 

[thomas_m18]

Alright, I have given a huge load, so I wanna see what you guys think about my team now.

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Fisher, Kennelly, Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis

MID: Ablett, Gibbs, ROK, Vince, Trengove, Martin
RES: Shuey, Bastinac

RUCK: Hille, Tippett
RES: Warnock, Lobbe

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Harvey, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Gumbleton(if he is alright)
RES: Dennis-Lane, Tapscott

Be Brutally, Brutally honest.

Please Rate before you post your own, and have a nice day.

 

[PumpyChowdown]

Alright, I have given a huge load, so I wanna see what you guys think about my team now.

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Fisher, Kennelly, Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis

MID: Ablett, Gibbs, ROK, Vince, Trengove, Martin
RES: Shuey, Bastinac

RUCK: Hille, Tippett
RES: Warnock, Lobbe

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Harvey, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Gumbleton(if he is alright)
RES: Dennis-Lane, Tapscott

Be Brutally, Brutally honest.

Please Rate before you post your own, and have a nice day.

Brutally honest? Well, with the exception of you starting rucks and Gumby (never in a million years would I start him, even on the pine), that's a damn fine team. Unfortunately though I think you need to spend a couple more $$ on your rucks, and to do so means you need to compromise elsewhere. Hille is too big a risk to start IMO. But who to sell and who to buy is a huge problem. All in all though, a mighty fine effort!

 

[BleasePlease]

Desperately need feedback guys, im not happy with my side at all.. really struggling to fit everyone in.. Be bruttally honest and let me know what you think..

DEF: Goddard, Hurn, Hodge, Mackie, Waite, Ladson, Jesse Smith (will he play?)
RES: Maguire, Dylan Grimes

pretty happy with the backs, buy will j. SMith play??

MID: Ablett, Vince, Prismall, McVeigh, Burgoyne, Trengove,
RES: Martin, Bastinac

Is my midfield a tad light on??

RUCK: Sandilands, Charman
RES: Warnock, Lobbe

Really struggled with the rucks, think i may need to sacrifice someone to get a petrie or mcintosh in??

FWD: Riewoldt, B.Harvey, Stevie J, Franklin, Hall, Medhurst, Rohan
RES: Tapscott* out for 8 weeks just found out on melb board, have to rethink that choice, Possiadly

please give me some honest feedback, be brutal and help me sort this out????????

 

[thomas_m18]

Brutally honest? Well, with the exception of you starting rucks and Gumby (never in a million years would I start him, even on the pine), that's a damn fine team. Unfortunately though I think you need to spend a couple more $$ on your rucks, and to do so means you need to compromise elsewhere. Hille is too big a risk to start IMO. But who to sell and who to buy is a huge problem. All in all though, a mighty fine effort!

Thanks for that. I think my team looks solid, but I will probably have to start gumby round 1 becaue of Franklin.

Ummm, David Hille. I picked him because I was hoping he could go back to his pre-injury self. I was hoping he could be a force again. I don't really know what to trade to, do you have any ideas of good ruckman?

Again, thanks for the rate.

 

[Hondo]

Unfortunately though I think you need to spend a couple more $$ on your rucks, and to do so means you need to compromise elsewhere. Hille is too big a risk to start IMO. But who to sell and who to buy is a huge problem.

There's a couple of other mid-field rookies he could look at

 

[Hondo]

Desperately need feedback guys, im not happy with my side at all.. really struggling to fit everyone in.. Be bruttally honest and let me know what you think..

DEF: Goddard, Hurn, Hodge, Mackie, Waite, Ladson, Jesse Smith (will he play?)
RES: Maguire, Dylan Grimes

pretty happy with the backs, buy will j. SMith play??

MID: Ablett, Vince, Prismall, McVeigh, Burgoyne, Trengove,
RES: Martin, Bastinac

Is my midfield a tad light on??

RUCK: Sandilands, Charman
RES: Warnock, Lobbe

Really struggled with the rucks, think i may need to sacrifice someone to get a petrie or mcintosh in??

FWD: Riewoldt, B.Harvey, Stevie J, Franklin, Hall, Medhurst, Rohan
RES: Tapscott, Possiadly

please give me some honest feedback, be brutal and help me sort this out????????

I'll give you the same advice I gave the last team and I keep seeing the same thing. I don't think you need all those $400Kish players in your midfield when there are some good rookies to choose from. With the spare cash you could fix your rucks.

I think you'll be looking pretty strong after that

 

[thomas_m18]

There's a couple of other obvious mid-field rookies he could look at

I thought about trading in Cunnington or Morabito in, but I can't see that huge an upside to them, at least not as big an upside as Martin or Trengove.

Here are the changes I made:

Harvey Out - LeCras In
Maguire Out - Lisle In (purely cash, I may consider a Morabito trade. Comments, guys?)
Hille Out - Ottens In.

How does that look?

EDIT: Wait, no, scrap that.

Ottens Out - Sandilands In
O'Keefe Out - Burgoyne In

But then that leaves my mids open.

 

[Hondo]

I thought about trading in Cunnington or Morabito in, but I can't see that huge an upside to them, at least not as big an upside as Martin or Trengove.

Here are the changes I made:

Harvey Out - LeCras In
Maguire Out - Lisle In (purely cash, I may consider a Morabito trade. Comments, guys?)
Hille Out - Ottens In.

How does that look?

I dunno really. Ottens / Le Cras sort of = Hille / Harvey I reckon. I think you may as well stick with what you've got or have a look with bringing in Morabito like you say.

 

[thomas_m18]

Look at the new edit, and tell me what you think of that.

 

[Hondo]

Look at the new edit, and tell me what you think of that.

I think that fixes your rucks and Burgoyne could well be great value

 

[PumpyChowdown]

Look at the new edit, and tell me what you think of that.

Looking at your original team; I'd drop Harvey, and put Tippett in the forward line - can MPP him for Lobbe if need be. You've freed up about $70k and then you should be able to afford HMac in the ruck (seems to have slipped off everyone's radar this year - fools!). I'd still look to trade Hille, but that's just my opinion. If you think he'll come back to '08 form keep him, if not, I'd be looking at I. Maric, M. Seaby, The Big Mummy or Jesse White for a similar price.

 

[russea]

hey any thoughts would be great

Backs:Goddards,Enright,Adcock,hargrave,Sheppard,kennelly,Hun t(Davis,Maguire)
Mids:Abblett,Montagna,Vince,Cooney,Trengrove,Martin(Moribitt o, Bastinac)
Rucks:Sandi,Hille(Warnock,Cordy)
Forwards:Riewoldt,Gia,Tippet,Pav,Dangerfield,M.Williams ,Gumbleton(Denis-lane,Podsiadly)

 

[elk007]

Hi Guys

New to this forum! I've been following the discussion for the last couple of days and thought I'd add my Team to the mix for discussion.

It's only a draft - I think my forward line is a bit weak maybe! Need some suggestions with it overall.

DEFENDERS
Goddard, R Shaw, Hodge, Gilbee, Kennelly, Hunt, Trengrove
Emg: P Davis, Lisle

MIDFIELDERS
Abeltt, Pendlebury, J Selwood, Cooney, Burgoyne, D Martin
Emg: Morabito, Banner

RUCK
Sandilands, Natinui
Emg: Warnock, Lobbe

FORWARDS
Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Hawkins, R Murphy, G Rohan, Gumbleton
Emg: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

Any suggestions / refinements?

 

[russea]

Hi Guys

New to this forum! I've been following the discussion for the last couple of days and thought I'd add my Team to the mix for discussion.

It's only a draft - I think my forward line is a bit weak maybe! Need some suggestions with it overall.

DEFENDERS
Goddard, R Shaw, Hodge, Gilbee, Kennelly, Hunt, Trengrove
Emg: P Davis, Lisle

MIDFIELDERS
Abeltt, Pendlebury, J Selwood, Cooney, Burgoyne, D Martin
Emg: Morabito, Banner

RUCK
Sandilands, Natinui
Emg: Warnock, Lobbe

FORWARDS
Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Hawkins, R Murphy, G Rohan, Gumbleton
Emg: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

Any suggestions / refinements?

Not a bad team for a draft
not sure of trengrove starting in defence mabye try B.sheppard
Uv done fine with ur mids and rucks are good to
Forwards not to bad mabye find a replacement for hawkins and Rob murphy could be a 50-50 im not sure
Franklins out first week but DL can fill that spot

Overall about a 7/10 with a few improvements could be a very strong side

 

[pants01]

getting a lot out of eveyone's comments, love your work. here's my first crack at it, comments appreciated

Back: Goddard, Hodge, Hurley, Kenelly, Hunt, Ladson, Gillies (Goose & Waters)
Mid: Ablett, Hayes, Selwood, Cross, McVeigh, Trengrove (Martin & Bastinac)
Ruck: Hill, Charman - cheap, whats all thoughts on him? (Warnock & Skipper)
Fwd: Riew, Didak, Franklin, Tippet, Murphy, Staker, Burton (Wonna & Dennis-Lane)

cheers guys

 

[BowerTower]

Here's mine. Still got a bit of shuffling to do once after I see some more NAB cup form and the teams for Rd 1. Got about $20k in the bank but would prefer to start with a bit more so I can do some upgrading once some of my kids balloon in value. Plan is to majority of my upgrading through the midfield as there doesnt seem to be much value to be had elsewhere.

Keen to get some thoughts, especially on my benches for the backline, rucks and forwards.

BACK (Locks): C Enright, L Hodge, T Kennelly
BACK (Unsure): J Waite, S Stevens, R Ladson, B Walters, B Shepphard

MID (Locks): G Ablett, A Cooney, A Walker, D Martin, A Morabito, J Trengrove
BACK (Unsure): S Burgoyne, T Scully

RUCK (Locks): None
RUCK (Unsure): A Sandilands, J Charman, R Warnock, M Lobbe

FWDS (Locks): N Riewoldt, R O'Keefe, C Sylvia, L Franklin, J Roughhead, J Kennedy
FWDS (Unsure) R Murphy, A wonaemirri, G Rohan

 

[russea]

getting a lot out of eveyone's comments, love your work. here's my first crack at it, comments appreciated

Back: Goddard, Hodge, Hurley, Kenelly, Hunt, Ladson, Gillies (Goose & Waters)
Mid: Ablett, Hayes, Selwood, Cross, McVeigh, Trengrove (Martin & Bastinac)
Ruck: Hill, Charman - cheap, whats all thoughts on him? (Warnock & Skipper)
Fwd: Riew, Didak, Franklin, Tippet, Murphy, Staker, Burton (Wonna & Dennis-Lane)

cheers guys

Theres a few problems with a few players
Put Waters on the ground trade out Gillies for mabye a Phil Davis and upgrade Hille for mabye Kruze. Hurls is out for the first 2 weeks dons banned him for hitting that cabbie
I like warnock a bit better than charman but keep charman as a back up
Burtons done his knee out for atleast 6 weeks
And lastly Buddys out for rd 1 but DL could do the job for a week

Take this help and post ur changes and we'll see how uv done