Rate my team for 2010 (cont)

[Juddbemetron]

Ill try again..any advice as to which is a better team

OPTION 1:
Backs: Goodard, Carrazzo, Fisher, Mackie, Hodge, Kennely, Ladson (Davis, Trengrove)
Midfield: Bartell, Pendelbury, Selwood, Cooney, Martin, Trengove (Bastinac, Shuey)
Rucks: Kreuzer, Hille (Warnock, Lobbe)
Fowards: Okeefe, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Lecras, Dangerfield, Dennis-Lane (Gumbleton, Tapscott)

OPTION 2:
Backs: Goodard, Carrazzo, Fisher, Mackie, Hodge, Kennely, Ladson (Davis, Trengrove)
Midfield: Bartell, Pendelbury, Selwood, Masten, Martin, Trengove (Bastinac, Shuey)
Rucks: Kreuzer, Hille (Warnock, Lobbe)
Fowards: Okeefe, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell, Dangerfield, Polkinghorne (Dennis-Lane, Tapscott)
+10K

 

[juvenile]

B - Hodge, Fisher, R.Shaw, Harbrow, McPhee, Kenelly, Ladson (Hunt, Maguire)

C - Bartel, Cooney, Watson, Hill, Sloane, Trengrove (Martin, Bastinac)

R - Kreuzer, Charman (Warnock, Lobbe)

F - Riewoldt, Goodes, Harvey, Higgins, Franklin, Warren, Dangerfield (Moore, Dennis-lane)

$600 spare.

What does everyone think?

I think it is fairly solid but the rucks are probably slightly light on but i'm confident in Charman averaging about 65.

 

[CrozaN]

Ill try again..any advice as to which is a better team

OPTION 1:
Backs: Goodard, Carrazzo, Fisher, Mackie, Hodge, Kennely, Ladson (Davis, Trengrove)
Midfield: Bartell, Pendelbury, Selwood, Cooney, Martin, Trengove (Bastinac, Shuey)
Rucks: Kreuzer, Hille (Warnock, Lobbe)
Fowards: Okeefe, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Lecras, Dangerfield, Dennis-Lane (Gumbleton, Tapscott)

OPTION 2:
Backs: Goodard, Carrazzo, Fisher, Mackie, Hodge, Kennely, Ladson (Davis, Trengrove)
Midfield: Bartell, Pendelbury, Selwood, Masten, Martin, Trengove (Bastinac, Shuey)
Rucks: Kreuzer, Hille (Warnock, Lobbe)
Fowards: Okeefe, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell, Dangerfield, Polkinghorne (Dennis-Lane, Tapscott)
+10K

I like Option 1 mate.

Cooney will > Masten.

Hard to say with Lecras V Ziebell. But it could go either way. ATM i would say Lecras wins.

TDS v Polkinghorne is a coin toss really.

So going by that, Option 1!

 

[Du_key]

Hello all,
I've been reading these posts, but haven't got the chance to reply in a while... Being on a computer all day leads me to avoid them during my time off. I thought instead of just listing my team, i'd explain why i have made each pick. It's a bit up in the air, especially with the rookies.

Backs:
Enright
Duffield
Hodge
Drummond
Ellis
Kennelly
Ladson

Shephard
Maguire

There's no Goddard, Gram or Fisher for me (Fisher was very close) for the fact that I don't think any team could double up the defensive season the the Saints had. Goddard is too expensive and should drop in price, and was never looking at Gram. Fisher is interesting due to his drop in DT production from 2008, but my take on it is: 1) He was tagged more than in previous seasons and 2) Gram and Goddard took more ball off of him. Why is any of this going to change?

With this thought, I needed a top of the line defender to anchor the backs and Enright is the man. Grimes might be an interesting choice, but for my 1st DF i'm going to go with someone more proven.

Duffield was in my team from the get-go. He is already proven to be a high scorer, and the soon to be change in position should help his scoring to more than premium status (95 plus). Rebounding defenders are gold.

Hodge is Hodge. Locked.

Drummond is an interesting one, his ceiling is a lot higher than his value but injuries are a major concern. The way I have my team set up I can afford for him to blitz in the first half, and everything else is a bonus. You don't win DT by not taking risks. However, he may not be in there by game time as I expect another lion, Ash McGrath to gain 5-10 more points a game and i'm not sure what may be the preferred option. I look at DT in two ways, pick the players that will improve the most no matter what, and pick the established players in teams that should improve... That should be a given. I think that the Lions may win 2-3 more games than last year, but should win the games they should by a load more than they did last year. DT extras galore.

Ellis screws everyone year after year, but he's coming off a great pre-season and I could not see a way for him not to be in my team this year.

Kennelly is too cheap to pass up, considering his previous years. Unlike other players that have been injured, he's been able to keep his fitness up during his time in Ireland. Locked.

Same with Ladson, just too cheap to pass up. I like to have as many players as possible playing RND 1, and if there's any dramas i might bury him CHBench.

Shephard has looked the most likely of the cheapies to play this year for the Weagles, won't know till later on so it's speculative.

I'm not as sure as most people that Goose will get a game, but if so he's there as a back up option. If he's not playing round 1 and some rookie is, he's gone. Clark can always take the second tall/resting ruck since he should start at CHB. Burger (if fit) will be No.1. Makes you wonder why Voss in his Football Manager state of mind didn't dispose of Charman in the trading period. I'm less inclined than most to put him in.

Midfield:
Selwood
Watson
Cooney
Cotchin
McVeigh
Martin

Farmer
Bastinac
Of course the midfield is important, but i'm not sure that it is as important as other years. Hard to explain what i'm trying to say but here goes......
Swan, Ablett, Montagna etc will all carve up, but I think that there is actually choices is the FL for captaincy during the first 6-7 weeks, moreso than other years, that will be viable captain choices. And most of the best will drop in price along the way (Lovely to see you Bartel mid year last year ) If you are choosing three high value midfielders, you'd want to hope that at least two of them will be in the top 7 come seasons end. A load of teams i've seen have had two superstars, two 250-350k players that for all accounts may be premuim by the end. Same deal I guess. No-one is wrong until round 22. I've chosen the three players of a premium price that I think may improve the most. That's it. No thinking. No thinking about captains until the team is done. I look at it in the way that you'd be shattered if you've picked a team around Ablett, Swan and they've slipped on a skateboard or something (ala Ottens) and then wasted trades are happening.

Selwood: I did not pick Swan, Ablett, Bartel etc at this price range purely for the fact that he has the most upside of all the high pricers. The problem with this pick is that I cannot see that the Geelong midfield will get more ball than they did last year. Am I the only one not completely sold on this guy? Time will tell, and he might be someone that is very overrated in this whole DT. It actually might be worth your while to scrap it and stick little gazza in your team round 1.

Jobe: Have you seen him with a tag? What tag? The main reason he doesn't kick (i.e DT points) from what i've seen is that he doesn't have the confidence to hit someone lace out. The ball will come to him. He will take marks. If he kicks straight he'll be the bomber with the most DT points by end of year hands down. On a different note, I don't see the value in Masten that a few people seem to talk about. Maybe he screwed me last year, who will know . He doesn't tackle. Jobe does.

Cooney: May be another that will not be in my team by start. There's plenty of value in the guy. But with the DT points that may come out of Ward and Higgins that were his previously, i'm not sure that he's that DT man everyone thinks he is.

Cotchin: For the price and skills he has it's a bit of a no-brainer for me. Definate injury concerns, but if he hits his straps will be worth anywhere from 50k to 125k more than what he's worth. Lower end keeper.

McVeigh: Just you wait and see... Looking fit in PS and will be right in the heart of it come round 1.
The rest of the rookies are a bit of wait and see at this time of year.
I'm def trying to find a spot for Morton and am more than sure that he'll be there come Rnd 1.

Martin, Farmer, Bastinac as the three rookies.

Rucks:
Sandilands
Skipper
Warnock
Lobbe

I don't think there's ever been a ruck position in DT year where so may young cheap players could play quite a few games. Between Skip, Warnock and Lobbe, you'd think at least 2, maybe three of them will get a game. In past years rucks were locked and loaded, this year it'll be a great area to upgrade. Sandi is the only major ruck without a queston mark over him and it the reason he's def in my side. I know that i'll lose points here from having three cheap rucks here, but i think the difference will be negligible by putting it in my FL (arguably the weakest rookie area in DT). This will be a major upgrade position, but I think I can make do till round 7 at least.

Forwards:
Sylvia
Brown
Higgins
Buddy
LeCras
Gray
Polkinhorne

Gumbelton
Davis

Forwards:
Sylvia: The Demons lineup should be much better than last year, and he stiil averaged a heap last year. I'm picking him for a substantual leap into rarified midfield territory value and by year's end may be the highest priced forward in the game.

Brown: Will dominate this year. Fit, ready to go, been training with the midfielders this year. Will take the 2nd best tall def and play up the ground as the Volt. I'm picking him to get as many DT points, if fit, as St Nick did last year.

Higgins: People say not much upside? Fitter in preseason than last year and looks to be force to reckoned with this year.

Buddy: Everyone's in agreement here from the sounds of things, just matters if cover is available rnd 1. I'm not starting with a donut thank you very much.

Gray: Noone was keping him secret.

LeCras: Could be a huge mistake, or huge win. Looking to spend a bit more time in the midfield this year could be a advantage, of they could be going to a Q-Tip, Nick or Cox centred lineup and will have to play pocket, and get less than he did last year. I'm going with the upside.

Polkinhorne: I expect a big upside from him, as I think Buchanan, Sherman and him will rotate in that pocket. Should be able to be used for an upgrade for Volt later on in the year.

Gumbleton, Davis: Completely depends on rnd 1, but look pretty safe to me.


My team so far:
Backs:
Enright
Duffield
Hodge
Drummond
Ellis
Kennelly
Ladson
Shephard
Maguire
Midfield:
Selwood
Watson
Cooney
Cotchin
McVeigh
Martin
Farmer
Bastinac
Rucks:
Sandilands
Skipper
Warnock
Lobbe
Forwards:
Sylvia
Brown
Higgins
Buddy
LeCras
Gray
Polkinhorne
Gumbelton
Davis

Constructive criticism would be great.

Cheers,
Du_key.

 

[Scootyb]

Hey everyone
This is my first year of dreamteam, after being suckered in by a good mate who i inevitably beat in every aspect of life, and i would like this to be no different.

Heres my team, 30k leftover
(Backs) Enright, Duffield, S.Fisher, Bower, Suban, Harbow, Scarlett (J.Hunt, J. Trengove (Port))
(Mids)- Swan, Gablett, J.Watson, Masten, Palmer, Martin (Shuey, Lewis Jetta)
(Rucks)- Sandilands, Tippett (Vardy, E Prato)
(Forwards)- Fevola, Mayne, Ballantyne, Veszpremi, Dangerfield, Walker (Podsiadly, Dennis-Lane)


My basic reasoning is that possessions and therefore (to my knowledge) dreamteam points will be more heavily gathered in the backline and midfield, hence a 'Blue-Chip' approach to those areas.
In the ruck- sandilands was AA and durable, and tippett can play up forward, any goals further adding to DT points, and making up for a slightly light on forward line.

 

[yogibbear]

Hello all,
I've been reading these posts, but haven't got the chance to reply in a while... Being on a computer all day leads me to avoid them during my time off. I thought instead of just listing my team, i'd explain why i have made each pick. It's a bit up in the air, especially with the rookies.

Backs:
Enright
Duffield
Hodge
Drummond
Ellis
Kennelly
Ladson

Shephard
Maguire

There's no Goddard, Gram or Fisher for me (Fisher was very close) for the fact that I don't think any team could double up the defensive season the the Saints had. Goddard is too expensive and should drop in price, and was never looking at Gram. Fisher is interesting due to his drop in DT production from 2008, but my take on it is: 1) He was tagged more than in previous seasons and 2) Gram and Goddard took more ball off of him. Why is any of this going to change?

With this thought, I needed a top of the line defender to anchor the backs and Enright is the man. Grimes might be an interesting choice, but for my 1st DF i'm going to go with someone more proven.

Duffield was in my team from the get-go. He is already proven to be a high scorer, and the soon to be change in position should help his scoring to more than premium status (95 plus). Rebounding defenders are gold.

Hodge is Hodge. Locked.

Drummond is an interesting one, his ceiling is a lot higher than his value but injuries are a major concern. The way I have my team set up I can afford for him to blitz in the first half, and everything else is a bonus. You don't win DT by not taking risks. However, he may not be in there by game time as I expect another lion, Ash McGrath to gain 5-10 more points a game and i'm not sure what may be the preferred option. I look at DT in two ways, pick the players that will improve the most no matter what, and pick the established players in teams that should improve... That should be a given. I think that the Lions may win 2-3 more games than last year, but should win the games they should by a load more than they did last year. DT extras galore.

Ellis screws everyone year after year, but he's coming off a great pre-season and I could not see a way for him not to be in my team this year.

Kennelly is too cheap to pass up, considering his previous years. Unlike other players that have been injured, he's been able to keep his fitness up during his time in Ireland. Locked.

Same with Ladson, just too cheap to pass up. I like to have as many players as possible playing RND 1, and if there's any dramas i might bury him CHBench.

Shephard has looked the most likely of the cheapies to play this year for the Weagles, won't know till later on so it's speculative.

I'm not as sure as most people that Goose will get a game, but if so he's there as a back up option. If he's not playing round 1 and some rookie is, he's gone. Clark can always take the second tall/resting ruck since he should start at CHB. Burger (if fit) will be No.1. Makes you wonder why Voss in his Football Manager state of mind didn't dispose of Charman in the trading period. I'm less inclined than most to put him in.

Midfield:
Selwood
Watson
Cooney
Cotchin
McVeigh
Martin

Farmer
Bastinac
Of course the midfield is important, but i'm not sure that it is as important as other years. Hard to explain what i'm trying to say but here goes......
Swan, Ablett, Montagna etc will all carve up, but I think that there is actually choices is the FL for captaincy during the first 6-7 weeks, moreso than other years, that will be viable captain choices. And most of the best will drop in price along the way (Lovely to see you Bartel mid year last year ) If you are choosing three high value midfielders, you'd want to hope that at least two of them will be in the top 7 come seasons end. A load of teams i've seen have had two superstars, two 250-350k players that for all accounts may be premuim by the end. Same deal I guess. No-one is wrong until round 22. I've chosen the three players of a premium price that I think may improve the most. That's it. No thinking. No thinking about captains until the team is done. I look at it in the way that you'd be shattered if you've picked a team around Ablett, Swan and they've slipped on a skateboard or something (ala Ottens) and then wasted trades are happening.

Selwood: I did not pick Swan, Ablett, Bartel etc at this price range purely for the fact that he has the most upside of all the high pricers. The problem with this pick is that I cannot see that the Geelong midfield will get more ball than they did last year. Am I the only one not completely sold on this guy? Time will tell, and he might be someone that is very overrated in this whole DT. It actually might be worth your while to scrap it and stick little gazza in your team round 1.

Jobe: Have you seen him with a tag? What tag? The main reason he doesn't kick (i.e DT points) from what i've seen is that he doesn't have the confidence to hit someone lace out. The ball will come to him. He will take marks. If he kicks straight he'll be the bomber with the most DT points by end of year hands down. On a different note, I don't see the value in Masten that a few people seem to talk about. Maybe he screwed me last year, who will know . He doesn't tackle. Jobe does.

Cooney: May be another that will not be in my team by start. There's plenty of value in the guy. But with the DT points that may come out of Ward and Higgins that were his previously, i'm not sure that he's that DT man everyone thinks he is.

Cotchin: For the price and skills he has it's a bit of a no-brainer for me. Definate injury concerns, but if he hits his straps will be worth anywhere from 50k to 125k more than what he's worth. Lower end keeper.

McVeigh: Just you wait and see... Looking fit in PS and will be right in the heart of it come round 1.
The rest of the rookies are a bit of wait and see at this time of year.
I'm def trying to find a spot for Morton and am more than sure that he'll be there come Rnd 1.

Martin, Farmer, Bastinac as the three rookies.

Rucks:
Sandilands
Skipper
Warnock
Lobbe

I don't think there's ever been a ruck position in DT year where so may young cheap players could play quite a few games. Between Skip, Warnock and Lobbe, you'd think at least 2, maybe three of them will get a game. In past years rucks were locked and loaded, this year it'll be a great area to upgrade. Sandi is the only major ruck without a queston mark over him and it the reason he's def in my side. I know that i'll lose points here from having three cheap rucks here, but i think the difference will be negligible by putting it in my FL (arguably the weakest rookie area in DT). This will be a major upgrade position, but I think I can make do till round 7 at least.

Forwards:
Sylvia
Brown
Higgins
Buddy
LeCras
Gray
Polkinhorne

Gumbelton
Davis

Forwards:
Sylvia: The Demons lineup should be much better than last year, and he stiil averaged a heap last year. I'm picking him for a substantual leap into rarified midfield territory value and by year's end may be the highest priced forward in the game.

Brown: Will dominate this year. Fit, ready to go, been training with the midfielders this year. Will take the 2nd best tall def and play up the ground as the Volt. I'm picking him to get as many DT points, if fit, as St Nick did last year.

Higgins: People say not much upside? Fitter in preseason than last year and looks to be force to reckoned with this year.

Buddy: Everyone's in agreement here from the sounds of things, just matters if cover is available rnd 1. I'm not starting with a donut thank you very much.

Gray: Noone was keping him secret.

LeCras: Could be a huge mistake, or huge win. Looking to spend a bit more time in the midfield this year could be a advantage, of they could be going to a Q-Tip, Nick or Cox centred lineup and will have to play pocket, and get less than he did last year. I'm going with the upside.

Polkinhorne: I expect a big upside from him, as I think Buchanan, Sherman and him will rotate in that pocket. Should be able to be used for an upgrade for Volt later on in the year.

Gumbleton, Davis: Completely depends on rnd 1, but look pretty safe to me.


My team so far:
Backs:
Enright
Duffield
Hodge
Drummond
Ellis
Kennelly
Ladson
Shephard
Maguire
Midfield:
Selwood
Watson
Cooney
Cotchin
McVeigh
Martin
Farmer
Bastinac
Rucks:
Sandilands
Skipper
Warnock
Lobbe
Forwards:
Sylvia
Brown
Higgins
Buddy
LeCras
Gray
Polkinhorne
Gumbelton
Davis

Constructive criticism would be great.

Cheers,
Du_key.

A lot of words... not much real explanation.

Tell us who was/were the player(s) that you "fitted in" to get in the salaray cap. I think you're midfield rookies are questionable. As are your forward rookies. Mainly because you were probably scrapping every $1k off them to get the rest how you wanted, when most of your upside is in your rookies. Granted $150k rookies can be a waste of $50k/$60k but there are quite a few tempting options.

First actual criticism is I don't think Cotchin is 'the man' as he plays for Richmond. There are many other better offers with more support, blocking, people that pass the ball to them around the same price or cheaper.

Also, no riewoldt and no goddard is a bold move.

 

[Du_key]

Scootyb,

Not bad for someone that has not played DT before, You're right on the money about midfield being the area with the most points.
but i'll throw you a few pointers:

The backs are traditionally an area where players go down like the opposite of the last movie I watched... So you want your backs to be stable to an extent. There's a little rule that 3rd year players are the ones that "break out" and have the most upside. However, in the backs this year there's heaps of people that could become high scoring players. While Scarlett is a great player, he won't get you many points. I'd suggest a Muston or Kennelly as a cheap option.

You've also got to remember that the scores for Swan and Ablett are based on the games last year. You'll need a captain option and both of those are EXCELLENT captain options. However, I'll bet my crappy car that there is not a time in this season that these players will not be at a lower price than what they are now. Choose one and hope for the best. There's a time and place to buy most of the players you want.

Your forward line is very weak, not slightly light on There's a few good picks in there, but as a whole it's not going to match up to many other teams. For this year my plan is to skimp on some other areas, and load up a forward line. There's a HUGE difference between the 1st and 50th highest scoring forward. If you see round 1 and there's three rookies playing in the forward line, don't be afraid to let them start for you.

You should think that every player you pick will be better than last year.

By following these little rules, you're not going to win, but you're not going to come last.... I'd suggest having a look through the forums and see what players are getting picked, why they are getting picked, and then throwing a few roughies out into your team. I love your Jobe pick, he's in my team atm too.

I'm no expert in the matter, but I hope this helps in some way.

Cheers,

 

[Du_key]

Yogi,

Thanks for the constructive criticism.

The reason that I wrote what I wrote was to get an insight into why I picked the players that I picked, as opposed to a load of people that see a listed team on here, change one or two players and say "this is my team" without actually having a real think about it.

The problem with listing rookies at this time is the fact that they have done NOTHING to show that they are ready for AFL level. I could list both Scully and Trengove but I have no idea if they will play. The rookies that I have listed could easily play round 1 with the exception of maybe Farmer. Bastinac looks the goods, as other people round his price mark eg Jetta. The point was not to list the rookies as they will be the players that change the most, and if all the more expensive rookies play you should be able to accomodate them (Plan B). And Cotchin is not part of plan B. I'm not happy with my midfield as much as the rest of my team, I was alluding to that in my last post. And that's where a load of money can be made to allow for these high pick rookies. We'll have more of an idea in a month.

I actually wasn't scraping dollars off those rookies to put them in in the forward line, if anything I'd be tempted to throw Posidaly in depending on injuries. Or anywhere for that matter. It was just the way it happened. By having a three "rookie" ruck system it's left me a lot of money spare to upgrade as i see fit.

You're right in risking not having either Volt or Goddard in the starting lineup, but I can't take either of them for the reasons as stated before, that they will both drop in price at some stage. I'm on my sword with Enright and Duffield, and Higgins and Brown to fit either of them in. And in my honest opinion, I think all 4 of them will have better seasons than last year.

 

[Signd Sealed Saint]

Not much talk on Jimmy Bartel this year. Great captain option, will get u guaranteed 100+ every week. Cheaper than Ablett/Swan, doesn't need a heap of touches to reach the ton. Great option to me.

 

[yogibbear]

I'm not happy with my midfield as much as the rest of my team

Flipside criticism. Your midfield is awesome. Selwood, Cooney, McVeigh (suspended rnd 1?), Cotchin (potential gun, but lacks support necessary...maybe), Watson.

Sooooo much better than the boring old Ablett, Swan, Dal Santo, Montagna rubbish that gets posted on here with crappy forwards/backs/rucks.

If anything i was merely pointing out that Cotchin doesn't represent that much value (in my opinion) as say a Masten/Mackay/Ward or a Shuey/other rookie or a whole bunch of others.

What i would do with your team... if you like the overall structure and risks you're taking (which could easily pay off) is drop cotchin to a trengove/banner/morabito/shuey and then use the cash on gumby/davis as required to cover buddy rnd 1. OR get one of Riewoldt/Goddard. (I'd pick riewoldt if i had to pick 1)

Oh btw you'd hate my team... it's tragically bad. But it's set. Quite a deviation from what it was a week or so ago.

 

[Baz the barbarian]

Hello all, just wondering if you could give some feedback on this team.
i Have $57,200 left in the bank.
Cheers!

 

[Scootyb]

Scootyb,

Your forward line is very weak, not slightly light on There's a few good picks in there, but as a whole it's not going to match up to many other teams. For this year my plan is to skimp on some other areas, and load up a forward line. There's a HUGE difference between the 1st and 50th highest scoring forward. If you see round 1 and there's three rookies playing in the forward line, don't be afraid to let them start for you.

I'm no expert in the matter, but I hope this helps in some way.

Cheers,

Thanks heaps mate, i realised when reading only a few other forward lines that mine didnt really cut it, so my adjustments so far...

Out Veszpremi- not sure how many games he'll get and was basically a familiar, low priced pick to populate the forward line.
Downgraded Vardy- not much point wasting 15k on a rookie ruckman over a fellow rookie one- will not be gamebreakers
swapped Scarlett for kennelly. My reasoning for Scarlett was that he would be a mainstay, and zero scores kill DT rounds. But after Kennelly's hiatus he could comeback and easily raise in value- he was a running, playmaking backman after all.

This opened up enough money for roughead.

Will do some further tweaking as i'm sure everyone will, and again appreciate your help

 

[Baz the barbarian]

Hello all, just wondering if you could give some feedback on this team.
i Have $57,200 left in the bank.
Cheers!

just upgraded thompson to bartel

 

[yogibbear]

just upgraded thompson to bartel

You'll likely cop 1 or 2 zeros up forward round 1, otherwise same old same old as most other teams. Move along.

Waters and Gumby are both risky but could pay off. Lots of money in the midfield... not my thing. Could be your thing though.

 

[Lazarus]

@Baz:

Get rid of Rich and put Martin on the ground. Use the extra dough to upgrade your defense, which IMO is a bit weak.

Also, I'd get rid of Rusling. Seems to always be injured.

 

[Bombers_Insider]

what improvements can i make on my team?
Cash left $2,300

 

[Fishy617]

how much cash u got left over?

 

[Bombers_Insider]

how much cash u got left over?

whoops forgot to add that part .$2,300 , just updated it

 

[longytap]

what improvements can i make on my team?
Cash left $2,300

Good side, can't see any obvious floors in it. personally i think Watson and Hurley are more SC players, but good effort.

 

[A Bit High]

Current side -

B - Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Symes, S.Thompson, M.Brown, Kennelly - Trengrove, Davis

M - Ablett, Dal Santo, Selwood, McVeigh, Trengrove, Martin - Shuey, Bastinac

R - Sandilands, Charman - Warnock, Lobbe

F - Riewoldt, Goodes, Higgins, Ziebel, Reimers, J.Moore, Dangerfeild - Dennis-Lane, Tapscott

1,100 left in bank

I did contemplate an idea of having Tippett, Nic Nat, Charman and Lobbe as my rucks. All potential cash cows.

Thoughts on my side and ruck idea anyone.

 

[Rothy_D]

What do you guys think of my team?

Backs: Carrazzo, Fisher, McPhee, Hodge, Kenelly and Broadbent. (Davis, Trengrove)

Mids: J Selwood, A Cooney, B Green, C Masten, J Trengrove, D Martin. (Shuey, Bastinac)

Ruck: Sandilands, Ottens. (Warnock, Lobbe)

Fwds: J Brown, M Pavlich, N Riewoldt, L Franklin, J Ziebell, P Dangerfield, B Hall. (Gumbleton, T Dennis Lane)

Im unsure of M Broadbent, B Green and B Hall.

Any advice for my team?

 

[Axel.]

what improvements can i make on my team?
Cash left $2,300

Yeah great team, great balance everything. Just keep an one out for Drum.

Current side -

B - Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Symes, S.Thompson, M.Brown, Kennelly - Trengrove, Davis

M - Ablett, Dal Santo, Selwood, McVeigh, Trengrove, Martin - Shuey, Bastinac

R - Sandilands, Charman - Warnock, Lobbe

F - Riewoldt, Goodes, Higgins, Ziebel, Reimers, J.Moore, Dangerfeild - Dennis-Lane, Tapscott

1,100 left in bank

I did contemplate an idea of having Tippett, Nic Nat, Charman and Lobbe as my rucks. All potential cash cows.

Thoughts on my side and ruck idea anyone.

Not too sure on Moore and M.Brown but the rest is good.

What do you guys think of my team?

Backs: Carrazzo, Fisher, McPhee, Hodge, Kenelly and Broadbent. (Davis, Trengrove)

Mids: J Selwood, A Cooney, B Green, C Masten, J Trengrove, D Martin. (Shuey, Bastinac)

Ruck: Sandilands, Ottens. (Warnock, Lobbe)

Fwds: J Brown, M Pavlich, N Riewoldt, L Franklin, J Ziebell, P Dangerfield, B Hall. (Gumbleton, T Dennis Lane)

Any advice?

Comment on someones team then post yours.

 

[A Bit High]

Axel - agree with Brown & Moore but was struggling to find possible replacements.

Have replaced Moore with Mayne and meant to do that before I posted. With Brown I am looking to him as a cash cow.

What did you think about my ruck proposition??

 

[Axel.]

Axel - agree with Brown & Moore but was struggling to find possible replacements.

Have replaced Moore with Mayne and meant to do that before I posted. With Brown I am looking to him as a cash cow.

What did you think about my ruck proposition??

Ah good job in getting Mayne.

For rucks i'd downgrade Sandi for Kreuzer/Tippett and with the money left over upgrade Charman. But you have a good emergency with Warnock.

 

[snubbs]

What do you guys think of my team?

Backs: Carrazzo, Fisher, McPhee, Hodge, Kenelly and Broadbent. (Davis, Trengrove)

Mids: J Selwood, A Cooney, B Green, C Masten, J Trengrove, D Martin. (Shuey, Bastinac)

Ruck: Sandilands, Ottens. (Warnock, Lobbe)

Fwds: J Brown, M Pavlich, N Riewoldt, L Franklin, J Ziebell, P Dangerfield, B Hall. (Gumbleton, T Dennis Lane)

Im unsure of M Broadbent, B Green and B Hall.

Any advice for my team?

Nice team. Love the forward line. Unsure on ottens and green however. other than that, a very solid effort imo

what do you guys think of my team