Rate My Team

[tubes82]

This is my team any thoughts would be appreciated
DEF: Goddard, Gibbs, Deledio, Rawlings, Toy, Otten, Heppell (Faulks, Poupolo ,Duigan )

MID: Swan, Judd, Hodge, Selwood, D.Swallow, Anthony (Hibberd, I.Smith,Harris)

RUCK: Sandilands,Petrie (Z.Smith,Bailey)

FWD: Franklin, Riewoldt, Harvey, Roili, Krakouer, Petrie,Prestia (Callinan, Mzungu, Richardson)

Remaining salary cap:34,800

Team overall looks good. I'm not sold on Petrie as a starting second ruck. Better to use him as cover and get either Jamar or Jolly or Mumford if you can afford him.

Harvey seems a bit past it for me. Just my opinion but i think he is to expensive and will drop on last year.


Edit: Just noticed you have Petrie in there twice

 

[Swallow9]

Team overall looks good. I'm not sold on Petrie as a starting second ruck. Better to use him as cover and get either Jamar or Jolly or Mumford if you can afford him.

Harvey seems a bit past it for me. Just my opinion but i think he is to expensive and will drop on last year.


Edit: Just noticed you have Petrie in there twice

swapped harvey for goodes
the second petrie was ment to be Knights

 

[BleasePlease]

hi guys,

need some major advice and feedack and help with my side, took my ages sorting it all out..

this is my team atm

BACKS:
Goddard, Gibbs, Shaw, Grimes, Drummond, Otten, Heppell (Coad, Toy, Duigan)

MIDS:
Swan, Judd, Hodge, Anthony, D.Swallow, Weller ( Atley,Wallis, Callinan)

RUCKS
Sandilands, Petrie (Z.Smith, Bailey)

FWDS
Chapman, Franklin, Goodes, ROK, Sylvia, Knights, Krakour (Matera, Mzungu, I.Smith)

not really too sure about my rookies/first yr players and whether or not they will play..

also i think i may have to many gold coast players, any feedback would be greatly appreciated!!

cheers in advance, BP!!

 

[FwdPocketer]

why is it that just about every team does not have daniel harris in it? surely he is one of the bargain must-haves this year?

Because, hes not. He averaged 74 in his last AFL season and has been slowly declining since 2006. Now in a worse quality side in the Gold Coast I highly doubt hes going to better his numbers from that year. Donkey call.

 

[FwdPocketer]

WOW, you must be really good at this you utter flog.

FO idiot

LOL.
You think the SC'ers that are actually half decent would go on forums looking for advice by posting their team, and all their bargain players for all the amateurs to see and copy? As Crawf said, noobs posting on here takes away the individuality of the game.
Why would you post your team. You're just jeopardising your chances.

FYI. Im feeling Nicoski will have a break out year.

 

[Hot Tiges]

LOL.
You think the SC'ers that are actually half decent would go on forums looking for advice by posting their team, and all their bargain players for all the amateurs to see and copy? As Crawf said, noobs posting on here takes away the individuality of the game.
Why would you post your team. You're just jeopardising your chances.

FYI. Im feeling Nicoski will have a break out year.

Some of us want to win private leagues. Whatever happens overall, happens.. RE Nicoski.. doubt it

 

[conodie05]

LOL.
You think the SC'ers that are actually half decent would go on forums looking for advice by posting their team, and all their bargain players for all the amateurs to see and copy? As Crawf said, noobs posting on here takes away the individuality of the game.
Why would you post your team. You're just jeopardising your chances.

FYI. Im feeling Nicoski will have a break out year.

I don't give a 5hit about taking on the big guns. All I care about is having a team good enough to win me a slab off the w@nkers in my leagues. If getting suggestions off people on here guarrantees me a couple of weeks of not buying pi55 then I'm all for it.


Nicoski will bea bolter this year. Bookmark it.

 

[Covvy]

Backs:
Gibbs, Deledio, Grimes, Drummond, Gram, Brad Sheppard, Otten (Jacobs, Faulks, Duigan)

Mids:
Judd, J.Selwood, Hodge, Trengrove, Masten, Gaff (Swallow, Iles, Green)

Rucks:
McIntosh, Naitanui (Campbell, Smith)

Forwards:
N.Riewoldt, J.Riewoldt, J.Brown, Higgins, Rioli, Fyfe, Callinan (Matera, Mzungu, Darling)

$44,900 left

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Because, hes not. He averaged 74 in his last AFL season and has been slowly declining since 2006. Now in a worse quality side in the Gold Coast I highly doubt hes going to better his numbers from that year. Donkey call.

Fairly poor call there.

He's scoring in his last season had to do with limited opportunity.

He'll play 80% game time and average over 20 possies (most contested). He'll average 75-80 and make at least 250-300k

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Backs:
Gibbs, Deledio, Grimes, Drummond, Gram, Brad Sheppard, Otten (Jacobs, Faulks, Duigan)

Mids:
Judd, J.Selwood, Hodge, Trengrove, Masten, Gaff (Swallow, Iles, Green)

Rucks:
McIntosh, Naitanui (Campbell, Smith)

Forwards:
N.Riewoldt, J.Riewoldt, J.Brown, Higgins, Rioli, Fyfe, Callinan (Matera, Mzungu, Darling)

$44,900 left

At least change the lot i have in bold.
They are either injury prone or they are overpriced for what they will offer. They will not be keepers and they are too expensive to be cash cows.

Even Grimes and Riolo have had their fair share of injuries but the reward is there if you take the risk

 

[pjay79]

First draft, new to supercoach, any feedback on this team?

BACKS: Goddard, Gibbs, Deledio, Mackie, Tarrant, Otten, Heppel (Toy, Faulks, Duigan)

MIDFIELD: Selwood, Hodge, Pendlebury, Scully, Swallow, Gaff (Mzunga, Smith, Wallis)

RUCKS: Mumford, Cox (Warnock, Petrie)

FORWARDS: Franklin, Pavlich, Reiwoldt J, Jurrah, Gumbleton, Knights, Krakouer A (Ablett N, Lamb, Skinner)

$63400 LEFT.

Many thanks,

PJ.

 

[FwdPocketer]

Some of us want to win private leagues. Whatever happens overall, happens.. RE Nicoski.. doubt it

Sorry not Nicoski I meant Brett Peake

 

[FwdPocketer]

Fairly poor call there.

He's scoring in his last season had to do with limited opportunity.

He'll play 80% game time and average over 20 possies (most contested). He'll average 75-80 and make at least 250-300k

Interesting. But surely you'd take Swallow and a couple others ahead of him (Gaff, Mzungu) just through purely the fact that we've seen what Harris can do, and the rookies have more potential (maybe) to make cash and are picked by the excitement of the unknown. Just my theory. But will be interesting to see how he goes.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Interesting. But surely you'd take Swallow and a couple others ahead of him (Gaff, Mzungu) just through purely the fact that we've seen what Harris can do, and the rookies have more potential (maybe) to make cash and are picked by the excitement of the unknown. Just my theory. But will be interesting to see how he goes.

No reason why you can't have Harris, Swallow and Gaff in the midfield with Mzunga in the FWD line.

I'm picking him up knowing what he can, and that is score consistently over 80. Therefore turning his $115k odd into ~$400k

 

[Rayzorwire]

I realise that there is a bit of risk involved, but I'm quietly confident in most of them coming off.

That's all that matters RT, gotta back your judgement.

 

[Rayzorwire]

Lake is out for about 2 months.

Unless something happened in the last few days that I missed, Eade said Lake was ahead of schedule and would be very likely to play rd.1.

 

[your a hack]

made a few changes to my side think it looks pretty stong but then again who doesnt thin they picked the best team..

BACKS
gibbs deledio broughton grimes drummond otten heppel
sub
toy puopolo duigan
Midfield
Murphy pendlebury bartel mitchell gaff harris
Subs
Conca atley I smith
Rucks
Cox Petrie
Subs
z smith r campbell
forwards
chapman riewoldt franklin pavlich tippet higgins krakouer
Subs
mzungu prestia dowling​

Let me know what use think open to all suggestions​

 

[Hot Tiges]

made a few changes to my side think it looks pretty stong but then again who doesnt thin they picked the best team..

BACKS
gibbs deledio broughton grimes drummond otten heppel
sub
toy puopolo duigan
Midfield
Murphy pendlebury bartel mitchell gaff harris
Subs
Conca atley I smith
Rucks
Cox Petrie
Subs
z smith r campbell
forwards
chapman riewoldt franklin pavlich tippet higgins krakouer
Subs
mzungu prestia dowling​

Let me know what use think open to all suggestions​

Looks pretty good.. Watch the fitness of Grimes, Otten and in particular, Drummond.. all not guaranteed a full season. No Goddard? risky. Mids, No Swan? Pendlebury is just as good. Had him and Murphy last year and didn't disappoint. Not sold on getting Mitchell in. Bartel should be a good pick. No D Swallow? Rucks, No Sandi? Hope Cox can do the business for you. Don't think Robbie Campbell is going to get much game time. Bit like Brad Miller at Tiges.. insurance policy. Fwds looks strong. Tippett with MPP with Petrie is good. Higgins is risky but why not.. stays fit he avgs 10 points then last year.. You could get away with starting Mzungu I reckon if ya want.. Good team, different team..

 

[Hot Tiges]

Unless something happened in the last few days that I missed, Eade said Lake was ahead of schedule and would be very likely to play rd.1.

Still wouldn't pick him to start with.. Great upgrade target

 

[nofeet]

Backs:

1: Bryce Gibbs $508,300
2: Brett Deledio $495,900
3: Corey Enright $477,500
4: Lindsay Gilbee $456,700
5: Jack Grimes $428,200
6: Andy Otten $185,100
7: Dyson Heppell $153,600

Midfield:

8: Dane Swan $617,300
9: Chris Judd $576,700
10: Joel Selwood $573,200
11: Scott Pendlebury $537,900
12: David Swallow $188,600
13: Daniel Harris $125,700

Rucks:

14: Aaron Sandilands $554,799
15: Darren Jolly $388,400

Forwards:

16: Paul Chapman $566,500
17: Nick Riewoldt $529,900
18: Matthew Pavlich $483,300
19: Adam Goodes $458,900
20: Drew Petrie $216,000
21: Andrew Krakouer $200,600
22: Isaac Smith $103,600

Bench:

23: Shaun McKernan $110,200
24: Matthew Watson $103,600
25: Paul Puopolo $103,600
26: Tendai Mzungu $110,200
27: Shaun Atley $108,600
28: Mitch Wallis $103,600
29: Zac Smith $117,700
30: Tom Derickx $103,600
31: Viv Michie $103,600
32: Jack Darling $103,600
33: Ian Callinan $91,700

$13,400 left. Give us a rating out of 10.

 

[Rayzorwire]

Still wouldn't pick him to start with.. Great upgrade target

It's a tougher call with Lake than many are making out IMO.

Eade will certainly play him if he's anywhere near fit, his style of points gathering is not as as affected by being a bit off full fitness as most other players (last year he was knocking out massive scores with a mattress strapped to his leg plus a couple of other injuries to go with it), and the Dogs have a pretty juicy first three rounds where they could kill off games by half-time and just be playing kick to kick in the 2nd-half.

There's even a chance Eade will play him FF early on and with the opposition they're up against, he might be leading the Coleman after the first three rounds.

He's too good a scorer to totally dismiss IMO.

 

[Double the Fist]

LOL.
You think the SC'ers that are actually half decent would go on forums looking for advice by posting their team, and all their bargain players for all the amateurs to see and copy? As Crawf said, noobs posting on here takes away the individuality of the game.
Why would you post your team. You're just jeopardising your chances.

FYI. Im feeling Nicoski will have a break out year.

None of us who are posting here give a shit you turkey. Each year this thread, who has lots of interested people, have to read shit that people like yourself post.
Dry up and piss off if you have nothing to add Mr Expert!

tool

 

[Double the Fist]

Fairly poor call there.

He's scoring in his last season had to do with limited opportunity.

He'll play 80% game time and average over 20 possies (most contested). He'll average 75-80 and make at least 250-300k

Pez, thats what I was thinking too.

 

[MR ESNDEN]

Please rate my team

Goddard - Gibbs - Deledio - Enright - Otten - Heppel - Duigan

Coad - Toy - Jacobs
_______________________________________________

Swan - Judd - Montagna - Hodge - Swallow(GC) - Gaff

Harris - Wallis - Smith
________________________________________________

Sandilands - Fraser

Petrie - Dercikx
________________________________________________

Riewoldt N - Franklin - Didak - Riewoldt J - Knights - Krakouer - Mzungu

Richardson - Callinan - Darling


Thanks in advance

 

[Waitingfor17]

A few quick questions

S.Burgoyne vs R.Griffen - Who should I go for? Don't have any other Hawthorn or Bulldog Midfielders in my starting team.

P.Bower - Havn't seen much love for him here. Had injury interupted season last year but before that scored well and will proably play more of a third man role in the back half.

Interstaters - Im not too familier with all the non-victorian club players. Few people have Andy Otten in their team.What's his story? Is he a gurarented starter? Is Broughten a consistent scorer? is he a safe bet?

Gibbs - A lot of people have Gibbs in the back half. Last year he was playing more loose man in defence and wont get as many cheap touches this year as he has been earmarked for a midfield start. But then could go the other way and by having Judd and Murphy in there could free him up more.

New Players - Will players like Heppel,I.Smith,Gaff and Atley be getting regular game time. Are they good for starters or as emergancies?