Game Day Rd 23 - Port @ Optus

[Sweetback]

We are thereabouts against the top four sides. Just need another decent midfielder, stop the turnovers and playing players like Banners

 

[MadMundy]

what horse s**t. Judd, Daicos.

but I’m not talking about elite. I want to see SOMETHING

Did you miss the part where I said "Outside of anomalies"

Judd and Daicos go into that category, they're anomalies, they're not the norm.

 

[FreoGirl]

That was horrible in every way

 

[The Lobbster]

that’s not true. What did you think about Amiss? Nick Daicos, Fyfe? not everyone develops at the same rate but really need to see something soon

You’ve just named a dual Brownlow medallist, one of the best 2nd year players the game has seen for a while along with one of the best 2nd year key forwards the game has seen for a while. Not a particularly fair comparison


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Lach72]

You’ve just named a dual Brownlow medallist, one of the best 2nd year players the game has seen for a while along with one of the best 2nd year key forwards the game has seen for a while. Not a particularly fair comparison


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

yeah whatever…I’m not seeing anything from these two currently suggesting they have it…

that has to change or we’re ****ed

 

[vidwhal]

Amiss

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

I think elite is the wrong term to use. Complete. Johnson and Erasmus are incomplete players at 20 and will need more time to become more complete players.
Amiss is also incomplete and certainly hasn't earnt the elite tag at this stage.
Playing past expectations helps tho. He's got great qualities already but he ain't elite yet.

 

[Freomaniac]

Johnson a star absolutely. Erasmus could be another Blakely/Schammer though.

Byron schammer came from west Adelaide in the SANFL. I liked him but his final 2 or 3 seasons... Horrible kick.

Connor Blakeley was ok, just inconsistent

 

[Kapow!!!]

There were a lot of negative things to focus on: But that final 2 and a half minutes we just allowed Port to hold off and keep possession uncontested to run out the clock was one of the most damning indictments of coaching I've seen. If the players are still peeling off and not taking an opponent in order to keep a structure up the ground in that situation then the messages from the coaches box are either seriously wrong or seriously miscommunicated.

Either way, terrible.

 

[apuchar]

Worse than Henry at what?

Everything.

 

[Freomaniac]

Make Cox a key forward again.

Who would play as a tall defender? Bring Tobe Watson and Taylin Duman back lol

 

[Jeba]

Good game by emmett pity it was a lose. Been through that shit myself, well done young man.

 

[Freomaniac]

Horrible game but the result was expected

 

[s_wd6]

One thing about Emmett is he needs to be less selfish in front of goal. Couple times, especially the one towards the end, he could’vehanded it off too a player in a better position.

But other than that love his aggression

 

[pK75]

Good game by emmett pity it was a lose. Been through that s**t myself, well done young man.

Emmett was the only ray of sunshine from that goal kicking s**tfest.
Schultz, Brayshaw, Serong, Treacy all missing very gettable set shots killed us.

Edit add young to the list

 

[Purple Jesus]

Everything.

Let’s just ignore his career high 12 clearances shall we.

 

[apuchar]

Let’s just ignore his career high 12 clearances shall we.

He was horrible. Gets away with murder on here. The last thing we could afford was him playing Russian roulette against a superior and much faster and skilful midfield.

 

[bigpav]

Ken Hinkley the Evil Emperor in Star Wars. This was the Empire Stikes Back. Next year we’ll roll them

 

[Dockeroo]

Did you miss the part where I said "Outside of anomalies"

Judd and Daicos go into that category, they're anomalies, they're not the norm.

A reasonable comparison for Johnson and Erasmus is
1. Brayshaw and Cerra at the end of year two
2. Serong and Young at the end of year two.

In comparison to both those duos, I think overall they are definitely behind quite a bit.
Personally I think Johnson is the more likely prospect than Erasmus at this stage.
He’s at least shown flashes of genuine class though not much today. Interestingly they both could be more natural goalkickers than the earlier duos, but that wouldn’t be too hard either.
Erasmus concerns me the most, I’m getting strong Paddy Dow vibes from him at this stage of his career.

 

[Lach72]

A reasonable comparison for Johnson and Erasmus is
1. Brayshaw and Cerra at the end of year two
2. Serong and Young at the end of year two.

In comparison to both those duos, I think overall they are definitely behind quite a bit.
Personally I think Johnson is the more likely prospect than Erasmus at this stage.
He’s at least shown flashes of genuine class though not much today. Interestingly they both could be more natural goalkickers than the earlier duos, but that wouldn’t be too hard either.
Erasmus concerns me the most, I’m getting strong Paddy Dow vibes from him at this stage of his career.

yep. The lad can’t kick…



Amiss and Van Rooyen on the table

 

[blue shark]

yep. The lad can’t kick…



Amiss and Van Rooyen on the table

Wait till the end of next year, then we
can judge over a broader scale.
Some players need 50 AFL games to break out.
Erasmus is that Forward/mid not his fault he only gets to play centre.
Johnson on a wing/mid it’s about the
rotations and JLo plays them off the
bench.

 

[freo_leo29]

Liked what we tried at the end of the game


Clark and Henry sprinting off the half back line froman a centre bounce, Ryan was as attacking wing as you can be


Freddy and Clark then did it after the goal but Freddy wasn't running fast enough imo


Coz went forward


Atleast we tried something