Game Day Rd 9 - Brisbane v Carlton

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow, v poor first post, you take an unwarranted shot at the club and also misconstrue the point of a book that your daughter understands. Ultimately everyone is responsible.

He doesn't understand the Very Hungry Catterpillar either. Too advanced.
 
Really dissapointed with the game tonight. There are just things that we just continue to do that are frustrating. We must have the most unaccountable defenders going around. I know modern footy is about run off half back etc but surely that is after you have done your defensive role. A game like tonight should really shows up where our problems are. Sam Michael did his job, Kruezer who is suppose to be a gun, was kept in check. Why do our senior defenders play soooooo far off their man. Patful and Adcock were terrible as defenders tonight and I will also throw McGrath and Yeo in their as well. Yeo is in his first couple of seasons so is forgiven. The other are suppose to be senior players, Jed is co captain, how can they be so poor?

The only reason we got so close was that Maloney and Black stood up and got the ball going forward, after this stopped only poor kicking by the Blues saved a blow out.

I also have to have a swipe at Vossy, Joel was done right from the start and we didn't have a plan B? They didn't even give him a rest, as the game went on he was making mistakes because he was exhausted.

Last year we got pumped by the Bombers, Blues and Pies, we are 1-1 and should be 2-0, we are improving but if we dish this up next week then we will get pumped.
 
Lisle ?????? Thoughts , sorry but if you lot hang ace out to dry it's time to get the pegs out on him

We were just too inconsistent , too many out of defence no pressure till the ball gets past half way every game

Your weekly Ace related tantrums have become one of my guilty pleasures.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Nah he won't play next week, Cloke and Dwyer would kill him.

I am not so sure. I would give him another game tbh, he did his job tonight. It is a bit of a reflection of where our defensive is at when we really need Clarke to come back in, given he has played 4? games.
 
I also have to have a swipe at Vossy, Joel was done right from the start and we didn't have a plan B? They didn't even give him a rest, as the game went on he was making mistakes because he was exhausted.

Not much he could do 2 of our 4 best tall defenders were suspended. Another one was injured.

Plan B would have been a white flag.
 
Do we have any rebounding defenders that can use the ball well at all? We need some right about now. With Golby/Hanley combo pushing further up the ground we need someone for deep defensive 50. Yeo cannot kick to save his life, Docherty isn't showing anything at all, and Adcock is just over enthusiastic most of the time and gets ahead of himself.
 
Lisle ?????? Thoughts , sorry but if you lot hang ace out to dry it's time to get the pegs out on him

We were just too inconsistent , too many out of defence no pressure till the ball gets past half way every game
Oh Irish, get over it mate.
Just , get over it.
 
I also have to have a swipe at Vossy, Joel was done right from the start and we didn't have a plan B? They didn't even give him a rest, as the game went on he was making mistakes because he was exhausted.

o_O Waite was kept pretty quiet from part way through the second quarter. I spent most of the game thinking "Plan B" had worked.
 
Lisle is soft as butter. The final straw was when we was held out of a contest by Bryce Squibbs ffs. WTF is wrong with the team... why can't we play hard running, hard hitting football for 4 quarters?? Michael was extremely poor! use your body ffs, you love it so much are you scared for getting bruise? We played the worst footy I have ever seen in the last quarter. Kick outs are shithouse, why kick it 10 m ffs when the clock is running down in the last quarter?????

These small sideways kicks are adding nothing! Only reason we have to do them is because people up the ground are not running hard enough! Voss is not a gameday coach and was outcoached when it mattered most

Yeah we should make Capper coach right?
 
As a couple of others alluded to, he was brought in to counteract the resting ruckmen in the forward line. For his debut. To play in a position in which I don't think he's played this year in the reserves. Kreuzer and Warnock had three behinds between them

Agreed. Kreuzer's three behinds were from a tough snap on the boundary, and two shots from 40m+ out. He wasn't giving away any easy shots.

The slow start cost us again though, working your way back from 22 points down at quarter time is always going to put you behind the 8-ball.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I am not so sure. I would give him another game tbh, he did his job tonight. It is a bit of a reflection of where our defensive is at when we really need Clarke to come back in, given he has played 4? games.

Would agree with you but Patfull didn't play the required role either way. He stood 10-15 metres off Waite for much of the night. Merrett and or Maguire would've been handy but not having them was even more the reason why J-Patt had to lockdown
 
Do we have any rebounding defenders that can use the ball well at all? We need some right about now. With Golby/Hanley combo pushing further up the ground we need someone for deep defensive 50. Yeo cannot kick to save his life, Docherty isn't showing anything at all, and Adcock is just over enthusiastic most of the time and gets ahead of himself.

Docherty isn't showing anything at all?

Did you actually watch the game tonight?
 
Last time I checked that's no reason for a smiley face ;)
Nup we wont.
Really dissapointed with the game tonight. There are just things that we just continue to do that are frustrating. We must have the most unaccountable defenders going around. I know modern footy is about run off half back etc but surely that is after you have done your defensive role. A game like tonight should really shows up where our problems are. Sam Michael did his job, Kruezer who is suppose to be a gun, was kept in check. Why do our senior defenders play soooooo far off their man. Patful and Adcock were terrible as defenders tonight and I will also throw McGrath and Yeo in their as well. Yeo is in his first couple of seasons so is forgiven. The other are suppose to be senior players, Jed is co captain, how can they be so poor?

The only reason we got so close was that Maloney and Black stood up and got the ball going forward, after this stopped only poor kicking by the Blues saved a blow out.

I also have to have a swipe at Vossy, Joel was done right from the start and we didn't have a plan B? They didn't even give him a rest, as the game went on he was making mistakes because he was exhausted.

Last year we got pumped by the Bombers, Blues and Pies, we are 1-1 and should be 2-0, we are improving but if we dish this up next week then we will get pumped.

Who by, we had no backline mate, Patfull did the best he could.
What was Vossy supposed to do, we had no one else.
If we had Merrett.Golby and Clarke we most likely would have won.
I am shitty with Merrett to be honest.
 
Not much he could do 2 of our 4 best tall defenders were suspended. Another one was injured.

Plan B would have been a white flag.


Staker?, Lisle wasn't doing much up forward in the first half and has played down back? Surely we could have made a few moves even to give Joel a rest. Waite was their only weapon up forward, it wasn't just the goals he scored it was also the lift that he gave the blues that hurt us.
 
Docherty isn't showing anything at all?

Did you actually watch the game tonight?
Yeah I watched it, what I was referring to was his kicking. I thought he played well enough but his disposal let him down, especially when he wasn't kicking it sideways. He came to the club as a potential Drummond replacement (long accurate kicks). I have not recalled one yet.
 
Yeah I watched it, what I was referring to was his kicking. I thought he played well enough but his disposal let him down, especially when he wasn't kicking it sideways. He came to the club as a potential Drummond replacement (long accurate kicks). I have not recalled one yet.
Meh
 
Not good enough in the end but we are definitely improved from last year. The games was there to be won and the more experienced heads got there in the end.

Joel was beaten but I thought our biggest blunder was not having Staker back full time to help.

Thought Michael had a solid debut, did his job on the resting ruck-man. Green looked good when he came on. Lisle not getting it done as either a ruck-man or forward, when Leuy went off we were still in it but we lost our ability to compete at the stoppages. Longer a must in inclusion for me.

The second quarter showed what we can be, but are list is just not well enough developed to compete with a top 8 side with that many outs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top