ORANGE UMP
Debutant
You make some fine points, & I agree & support much of what you say.
Sorry about the tardiness of my reply. I have been away for a few weeks.
Whatsmore your reply is intelligent & respectful. Well done & good luck with the season ahead.
Not a problem OMNI. Thanks it has already been a good start to the season. I too ventured up the hume to watch the Broadford vs Lancefield. Just I watched it from a slightly closer position than you and had a whistle in my hand (You can round me down to 1 of 3 people now). I appreciate the positive feedback from our game in your later post. I think the game really played itself and made it easy for us to umpire. Good work to Broadford on an excellent day (on and off field) and well done Lancefield, who look to be heading in a great direction. Great to see blokes like Collins and Sherwan back. Really looking forward to this weeks game. Should be an absolute cracker.
I will say one thing though, there were 2 occasions that goals were questioned, all seemed above board to me (I was midzone at both occasions), and I was able to observe the goal umpires in excellent position. Broadford like a couple of other grounds in the league don't have the tallest posts. The taller they are, the easier the interpretation. If it goes over a post it is hard to work out exactly where the ball was. Not an excuse if we got it wrong, but I will honestly say that it wasn't anything to do with Barry Hall. We all make mistakes, I will admit that I paid a free kick to Lancefield and after watching the footage on the RDFL website, I got it horribly wrong. Lucky for me it had no effect on the game.