Richmond’s next senior coach

Who do you want to be the next senior coach

  • Andrew McQualter

    Votes: 87 37.8%
  • Adem Yze

    Votes: 146 63.5%

  • Total voters
    230

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
signed the contract in 2015 to coach port

its well known
Na not that far back but you are spot on with that information he has signed with Port and yet again you are spitting facts with its well known

Good to see a man of integrity here
 
Na not that far back but you are spot on with that information he has signed with Port and yet again you are spitting facts with its well known

Good to see a man of integrity here
happy to be of service
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Carr’s record at North Adelaide
4 wins
4 wins
11 wins (won flag from 5th)
4 wins.

Very concerning record. No impact in first 2 years, fluke flag with 11 wins , then immediate drop off.

If Mini brings it home strong, just give him the chance. Let him choose/keep 1/2 assistants and change up the rest.
Agree if we finish the season strong. It’s as good as Minis.
 
Carr’s record at North Adelaide
4 wins
4 wins
11 wins (won flag from 5th)
4 wins.

Very concerning record. No impact in first 2 years, fluke flag with 11 wins , then immediate drop off.

If Mini brings it home strong, just give him the chance. Let him choose/keep 1/2 assistants and change up the rest.
wonder what all the Carr fanboyz say now the truth has come out , also telling the season after he leaves north Adelaide come second lol ,,,, he’s in same class as Neeld and David noble you ship of fools , it’s black and white
 
Also gold coast are fuming

They sack dew

Media believes they want dimma this is incorrect

They were desperate for mcqualter a former Sun's player loved by all They sack dew not knowing mcqualter signed a succession deal with us back in 2017

They now show interest in dimma as his the next best behind mini
Andrew shouldn't you be focused on the game today instead of posting on Big Footy
 
Finally we agree on something and then SK can be in the 8 year succession plan.lol
Bring over Josh Drummond as well.
you have changed your view as often as a baby needs changing. lol
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Couldn't believe my eyes in the game day thread when everyone was lauding mini for "moving the magnets" and put Balta forward.

Our defence absolutely went to shit the moment that move was made. Their key forwards were already having a good game but to move your best KPD out to compound the problem is borderline moronic.

One tin arse goal doesn't mean the move worked at all.

Could be the dumbest coaching move you'll see all season from 18 clubs including West Coast and North Melbourne.

Went into the game with no marking targets when Ryan and Cumberland were available (Miller does not count ) so you need to own that decision. You don't then completely sabotage team structure by moving the #1 intercept marker in the AFL.

Thanks but no thanks Mini. Good luck in the future.
 
Last edited:
Jay Clark has said today on Triple M that Ross Lyon has talked to the Tigers Coaching panel. I mean if you want references I think that Bacher's from Malcom Turnbull is the only better one to happen in AFL

LMAO wgaf about Ross Lyon? It's about the equivalent of Rodney Eade or Terry Wallace. Lyons on record that McQualter is his mate so he's hardly gonna slag him. Might as well disregard his biased comments unless we ask his Nanna if he's a good boy too.
 
Couldn't believe my eyes in the game day thread when everyone was lauding mini for "moving the magnets" and put Balta forward.

Our defence absolutely went to s**t the moment that move was made. Their key forwards were already having a good game but to move your best KPD out to compound the problem is borderline moronic.

One tin arse goal doesn't mean the move worked at all.

Could be the dumbest coaching move you'll see all season from 18 clubs including West Coast and North Melbourne.

Thanks but no thanks Mini. Good luck in the future.

Couldn't have said it better myself. Mean while Cumberland would have been pretty handy. His 💩 has more forward craft than Cotchin. Or is it too soon to say that since so many are still basking in his 3 goal game 8 weeks ago. New coach. New eyes. Cleanout old, and passed it passenger premiership players.
 
Couldn't have said it better myself. Mean while Cumberland would have been pretty handy. His 💩 has more forward craft than Cotchin. Or is it too soon to say that since so many are still basking in his 3 goal game 8 weeks ago. New coach. New eyes. Cleanout old, and passed it passenger premiership players.
Cumberland has no
Consistency or defensive aspect to his game . He plays 5-10 mins a game when no-one gives him Any attention .he shouldn’t be getting a game and should be traded or delisted
 
Club are rapt with mini today they pencilled in a 50 point loss so to get as close as we did has given the club great confidence they made the right call making mini our coach for next 3 years
 
Jay Clark has said today on Triple M that Ross Lyon has talked to the Tigers Coaching panel. I mean if you want references I think that Bacher's from Malcom Turnbull is the only better one to happen in AFL
This was for corey enright
 
McQualter is making slight tweaks to Hardwicks game plan. So todays loss isn’t his fault.

I thought it was obvious ten mins into the third we needed more speed around the ball and the sub needed to be made. 4 Melbourne goals later mini finally made the switch.

He moved Balta forward in the last which was a risk but one that didn’t pay off as our defence was absolutely destroyed in that quarter.

Gawn stepped up in that last half and it wasn’t Minis fault we seemed to target him when we were kicking out of defence. He was the difference, but we also helped him.

I also didn’t like his call this week that Cotch and Riewoldt have the final say on retiring this year. They have regressed significantly and are now holding players back in their positions.

We allowed our champs their milestone games, but now is the time to announce that round 23 vs North will be their farewell game. Bring in a big crowd to see them off like the champs they are. If Mini can’t do this, then I’m not sure he’s the man that can make the hard calls for the club long term.
 
McQualter is making slight tweaks to Hardwicks game plan. So todays loss isn’t his fault.

Sorry but that doesn't wash at all.

Only way that works is if you also concede that his wins aren't his either. Can't have it both ways.

Went into the game with no marking targets so he needs to own that decision. If he left things then that's fine too that's his call but Balta moving forward was one of the dumbest coaching moves you'll ever see when the opposition keys are dominating the air.

You don't completely sabotage team structure by moving the #1 intercept marker in the AFL to the forward line. What did he think was going to happen? The risk vs reward was insanely unrealistic.

Now, he probably doesn't win that game regardless but he doesn't get a free pass for "tweaks" just because we lose.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top