Player Watch Rising Star 2022 Discussion

[Jeremias]

I don’t rate the award as it’s flawed. Simply pointing out the influence of Windhager in a far tougher game was greater.

Based on what?

 

[bluebaggerjuls]

I don’t rate the award as it’s flawed. Simply pointing out the influence of Windhager in a far tougher game was greater.

no he didnt

 

[bluebaggerjuls]

Based on what?

his 11 handballs!

 

[staffonly]

Alright mate. Carlton playing interstate, key players out injured, playing as a small forward, had a huge impact on the game.

Stop trying to detract from others because you're a sooky la la

Alright mate. Carlton playing interstate, key players out injured, playing as a small forward, had a huge impact on the game.

Stop trying to detract from others because you're a sooky la la

Aren’t they bottom 5?

 

[Foucault1989]

Aren’t they bottom 5?

So the Rising Star nomination should be awarded to the player who played a higher team not who played a better game?

Waaaa waaaa ma playa didn't get recognised for an award I supposedly don't care about. Waaaaaa

 

[staffonly]

So the Rising Star nomination should be awarded to the player who played a higher team not who played a better game?

Waaaa waaaa ma playa didn't get recognised for an award I supposedly don't care about. Waaaaaa

I said already the systems flawed.

 

[HeHateMe]

How have other teams nominations back up the next week ?

Chappy sucked ass yesterday


Sent from my iPad using BigFooty.com

Duke was his regular self. Hasn't played a bad game all year. 22 D, 7 CP, 7 SI, 529 MG against the tigers, which is pretty much mirroring his season averages

I have him just edging Martin right now, just...

 

[Foucault1989]

Windhager. 1

I said already the systems flawed.

Winghager - 15 disposals. 4 kicks and 11 handballs. No goals. 2 tackles. 2 marks. 49 AFL fantasy points.

Durdin - 19 disposals. 11 kicks and 8 handballs. 2.1. 3 marks 2 tackles. 79 AFL fantasy points.

You're flawed and saltyyyyyy

 

[staffonly]

Windhager. 1
Winghager - 15 disposals. 4 kicks and 11 handballs. No goals. 2 tackles. 2 marks. 49 AFL fantasy points.

Durdin - 19 disposals. 11 kicks and 8 handballs. 2.1. 3 marks 2 tackles. 79 AFL fantasy points.

You're flawed and saltyyyyyy

Four more touches in a easy win.

 

[Foucault1989]

Four more touches in a easy win.

But the context. Significantly more kicks, kicking goals, he pushed into defence and saved us a few times. We won comfortably because of his excellent game.

Did you watch the Carlton game? He was a livewire. 19 touches for a small forward is like 35 for a midfielder

 

[Jeremias]

Four more touches in a easy win.

I still want to know how you measured influence.

 

[staffonly]

But the context. Significantly more kicks, kicking goals, he pushed into defence and saved us a few times. We won comfortably because of his excellent game.

Did you watch the Carlton game? He was a livewire. 19 touches for a small forward is like 35 for a midfielder

Windhager was everywhere put Danger out of the game while bullocking and winning one on one contests. Turned the game when he went into the middle.

 

[GhostofJimJess]

Duke was his regular self. Hasn't played a bad game all year. 22 D, 7 CP, 7 SI, 529 MG against the tigers, which is pretty much mirroring his season averages

I have him just edging Martin right now, just...

Newcombe carved us up in the first 45 minutes of the match on Saturday. Great young player and would be a worthy winner based on what I've seen of him so far, albeit only one game actually live.

 

[Foucault1989]

Windhager was everywhere put Danger out of the game while bullocking and winning one on one contests. Turned the game when he went into the middle.

I'm sure he played well, just not as good as Durdin. I hope you sleep well at night following this. This has really upset you

 

[staffonly]

I'm sure he played well, just not as good as Durdin. I hope you sleep well at night following this. This has really upset you

Windhager massive wrap by Johnno Brown during On The Couch.

Knows nothing obviously

 

[eth-dog]

How have other teams nominations back up the next week ?

Chappy sucked ass yesterday


Sent from my iPad using BigFooty.com

Martin was invisible round 2

 

[Elmer_Hauser]

Newcombe carved us up in the first 45 minutes of the match on Saturday. Great young player and would be a worthy winner based on what I've seen of him so far, albeit only one game actually live.

Gibcus shouldn't be too far away from a nomination. He is somewhere in my top 5 so far this year (it's a great group)

 

[Jeremias]

I still want to know how you measured influence.

staffonly? Anything?

 

[GhostofJimJess]

Gibcus shouldn't be too far away from a nomination. He is somewhere in my top 5 so far this year (it's a great group)

Yeah, the first 8-10 weeks tend to send up blokes who have had big individual outings. Gibcus has been really consistent in his 7 matches so far so will eventually get the nod.

 

[HairyO]

How have other teams nominations back up the next week ?

Chappy sucked ass yesterday


Sent from my iPad using BigFooty.com

Newcombe has been solid every week. He tired in the 4th often. Being a 14 game player carrying an entire midfield.m.

 

[T2B_]

Windhager far better without the fanfare.

Absolute BS.

Your man will get his turn no doubt, but there was no comparison this week.

 

[staffonly]

Absolute BS.

Your man will get his turn no doubt, but there was no comparison this week.

Browny doesn’t agree

 

[Jeremias]

Browny doesn’t matter

EFA.

Now, how about that impact measurement metric?

 

[staffonly]

EFA.

Now, how about that impact measurement metric?

Popularity contest or AFL legends opinion.

Let me see

 

[Jeremias]

Popularity contest or AFL legends opinion.

Let me see

Nathan Buckley is on the weekly selection panel.

He was a better player than Brown, so I guess by your own logic Brown’s opinion is null and void.

Nice melt though. Has been fun to watch.